Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 118

I am not saying he should have learned anything .. but the way he was ranting to Mannat about separating him from his family and polluting their minds etc was wrong...

I am glad Mannat and Ronnie both called him out on that.

The excitement to put her in jail was again very wrong... so was listening Y instigating him. Threatening Mannat with cancellation of her food license. None of these was because Yuvi was ill. It was personal vendetta.

Aren't those signs of 'no change'????

You may hate him ... I dont... but I dont worry about him the way people do...

His intentions were never to separate ManVik... just like Mannat or RoTus intentions were not to lie to Vik... its a case of good people doing mistakes. Cant judge him on that.

He is neither supposed to have any growth or realization of his actions... he is not the ML. He will be there till Dua learns to accept Vik.

DK has also killed Aish... threat is neutralized. DKs true realization will happen only when he finds out Aish was alive all this while and he helped her get out.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Jyo, I don't know if they will even address the CA part since even Mannat doesn't remember this part. Her pain has been that Vikrant rejected Dua and now with what Vikrant saw it's only going to get worse since "writers" play with Vikrant like a football

Absolutely agree with CA point ,Rd..

Vik was/ is stuck with that point based on his fbs, the photo shown by Vish, her lies, her not giving importance to his love,standing with RoTu ,against him..It was clear in yesterday's confrontation..

The writers are definitely playing ONLY with his character, kya dyshmani hai bhai..

As Addy said, there is not a single flower in his garden, still there is no hope in near future also...😢

Originally posted by: Moor278

I am not saying he should have learned anything .. but the way he was ranting to Mannat about separating him from his family and polluting their minds etc was wrong...

I am glad Mannat and Ronnie both called him out on that.

The excitement to put her in jail was again very wrong... so was listening Y instigating him.

Aren't those signs of 'no change'????

That's my confusion, why do we believe he should change in 7 years if he believed he was the victim all these years and now he just found out about Mannat's new family which proves what Vish said was correct?

I understand he needs retrospection, but he doesn't have any information where he can go down that path of redemption yet just like they haven't shown anyone from Indore gang except for Ronnie who believes they have done anything wrong.

Vikrant's comment about Mannat stealing his family is wrong and out of line , and good that Mannat reminded him who kicked them out. I even loved Ronnie called Vikrant Aman since that's what he wanted to be known as pre-leap.

But, Mannat's comment about how he never tried to contact them to see if RoTu were alive or not was uncalled for. Wonder why RoTu, didn't try to find out how Vikrant was doing since they were the ones who deceived him his whole life and drugged him ?

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Absolutely agree with CA point ,Rd..

Vik was/ is stuck with that point based on his fbs, the photo shown by Vish, her lies, her not giving importance to his love,standing with RoTu ,against him..It was clear in yesterday's confrontation..

The writers are definitely playing ONLY with his character, kya dyshmani hai bhai..

As Addy said, there is not a single flower in his garden, still there is no hope in near future also...😢

I am a minority 🙈

I would want the writers to show how both Mannat and Vikrant were wrong. If Vikrant's biggest mistake was CA Mannat, Mannat's was supporting RoTu's criminal activities,Neetu's drugging and planning on hiding his birth truth forever with RoTu & DK.

We cannot expect a person to react in a certain way to such a life altering lie & deception all in a matter of hours and then also expect him to act rationally. You make a choice to lie and deceive someone there will be repercussions just like how Vikrant ended up stuck in a scam wedding for his lies.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

That's my confusion, why do we believe he should change in 7 years if he believed he was the victim all these years and now he just found out about Mannat's new family which proves what Vish said was correct?

Pray tell when and why would Mannat want to separate him from his family and live in poverty if she was a GD... has Vik pondered over this? What was this accusation?

I understand he needs retrospection, but he doesn't have any information where he can go down that path of redemption yet just like they haven't shown anyone from Indore gang except for Ronnie who believes they have done anything wrong.

I am not asking for introspection... it is the same habit of jumping to conclusions and not wondering about another version which is the problem... does Vik honestly think Mannat would harm kids???? Wasn't that entire tirade a personal vendetta disguised as accusation over dirty water ice Gola???? Sinha/Jindal was filing a complaint anyway... why did Vik jump in?

Vikrant's comment about Mannat stealing his family is wrong and out of line , and good that Mannat reminded him who kicked them out. I even loved Ronnie called Vikrant Aman since that's what he wanted to be known as pre-leap.

But, Mannat's comment about how he never tried to contact them to see if RoTu were alive or not was uncalled for. Wonder why RoTu, didn't try to find out how Vikrant was doing since they were the ones who deceived him his whole life and drugged him ?

Have you like Vik forgotten that he threw them out??? Didn't want to listen to them or have anything to do with them???

You can justify Viks POV only till a certain extent RD... yesterday's episode wasnt that.

And I am fine with it... fully expecting his obnoxious behaviour to continue for more days now.

Or atleast till he meets Neetu and softens a bit.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

You know I am always here waiting to give my 100% for the a memorial

This is where you stump me... missed the first point I made....

I dont see anyone treating DK as God except you...

Mannat and RoTu call his favours as ehsaan... we dont do that to a family member. He is just a person living in the same house as them. Nothing more.

Temple to tab banega jab use God ki tarah treatment milega. Ronnie officially declared they have only one child. DK didnt feature when he told Mannat they are like his parents.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

That's my confusion, why do we believe he should change in 7 years if he believed he was the victim all these years and now he just found out about Mannat's new family which proves what Vish said was correct?

I understand he needs retrospection, but he doesn't have any information where he can go down that path of redemption yet just like they haven't shown anyone from Indore gang except for Ronnie who believes they have done anything wrong.

Vikrant's comment about Mannat stealing his family is wrong and out of line , and good that Mannat reminded him who kicked them out. I even loved Ronnie called Vikrant Aman since that's what he wanted to be known as pre-leap.

But, Mannat's comment about how he never tried to contact them to see if RoTu were alive or not was uncalled for. Wonder why RoTu, didn't try to find out how Vikrant was doing since they were the ones who deceived him his whole life and drugged him ?

Agreed ,Rd..

Sach gang still believe that they had not done anything wrong ..They are proving Vish's allegations are true like a cat closing its eyes while drinking milk.They are ignoring reality or hiding the truth of Dua and their fake pati & patni khel, thinking that the problem or their actions will remain unnoticed by the world.

Why is there an expectation for Vik to redeem himself, considering he is being manipulated by the antagonists and remains unaware of the truth? While Mannat’s reactions are more tempered than Vik's, she accepted UV as his son and Y as his wife without hesitation. Vik’s perspective is similar, especially since he is operating based on their shared history.

Originally posted by: Moor278

You can justify Viks POV only till a certain extent RD... yesterday's episode wasnt that.

And I am fine with it... fully expecting his obnoxious behaviour to continue for more days now.

Or atleast till he meets Neetu and softens a bit.

Moor I was referring to Dua calling Mannat maa and a side kick baba, nothing to do with GD. GD mentioned pre-leap if he felt Mannat was GD why would she write her part of the shares to Vikrant which weren't even his.

Ofcourse he was taking revenge on Mannat, any doubt kyaa ? This is why I mentioned last week Mannat reacted like an over fermented idli batter when she saw Vikrant with his "new family" and Vikrant will act like a volcano after seeing her "new family"

It's the same naa, if Mannat believes Vikrant after kicking them out for deceiving him should have called to check on RoTu , shouldn't RoTu who knew they did wrong by lying to him all his life, drugged him to erase his memories would even wonder how he was doing considering he was their life line ?

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I am a minority 🙈

I would want the writers to show how both Mannat and Vikrant were wrong. If Vikrant's biggest mistake was CA Mannat, Mannat's was supporting RoTu's criminal activities,Neetu's drugging and planning on hiding his birth truth forever with RoTu & DK.

We cannot expect a person to react in a certain way to such a life altering lie & deception all in a matter of hours and then also expect him to act rationally. You make a choice to lie and deceive someone there will be repercussions just like how Vikrant ended up stuck in a scam wedding for his lies.

I think their problem is complicated. When both parties are wrong it's then not clear cut. What led to the separation is the Dua bit which Vikrant is not to blame for and he is not even aware of. Basing on both of their characters even though he chased them out of the house they all knew they were to blame and i feel they would have given him time to calm down. The Malla stunt at Shruti's funeral is what sealed the separation.

And when you look at it from Vikrant's angle as well that's the missing link. Yes he reacted badly but he came back once he heard about Shruti's death. The problem with Vikrant is he hasn't replayed that day in his mind otherwise he probably would have realised something. Just before the leap when he was in his room he kept saying she wanted to tell me something. I think their disappearing act messed him up so he then just goes back to blaming them for the lies.