Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 36 - Page 71

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

How are you guys taking this so seriously?

What do you mean?

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Why should mannat give another chance to the man who is trying to forget her even after he realised his mistake, and is in relationship with a girl for 2-3 years and allows her to hug him, get close to him.. And is comfortable enough to share his room with her...... Just because he says he loves her and has maintained physical fidelity, should mannat give him another chance..??

That’ll be for Mannat to weigh up and decide whether she can ever forgive him for everything he has done and how much she loves him……. there are so many factors as @Betty has pointed out, to consider and weigh up together with what Mannat’s current priorities and focus are, it’s not an easy choice for any woman to make… there is also Dua to consider too.

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Why should mannat give another chance to the man who is trying to forget her even after he realised his mistake, and is in relationship with a girl for 2-3 years and allows her to hug him, get close to him.. And is comfortable enough to share his room with her...... Just because he says he loves her and has maintained physical fidelity, should mannat give him another chance..??

After seeing the BTS today, my urge to wallop him is still strong. “Poor little boy,oh i am a victim” attitude wasnt amusing.

What stopped him from investigating where they all disappeared to??

Next week we hit a year of the show and in that time,he hasnt grown up. How much longer do we have to wait? Or will the show end with him still being an imbecile??

He gives everyone power over him,his things,his room,his bed etc.

But he could never trust Mannat without proof.

So has babaji renewed Manvik vows in Gurudwara with the additional touch of sindoor afterwards? I can understand why she stayed away from that city after she left. If it was me i'd have been grateful to be asked first before being given the blessing It's hard to view the blessing in a positive light.

If i was Mannat i'd start taking him to task for not focussing on the important things of giving Vikrant a brain and eyes.

It's like after a 7 year escape there has been a renewed effort to tie her down again for more pain.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

So the Mumbai trip secret is shared with the Nani Trust Dua to share the secret with someone who can't disclose

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ofir3QfpARE

Nowhere to hide for Mannat, Shruti nani has approved the mumbai trip

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6p_jNkKGEM

Dua and Bunty did what ManVik couldn’t

Eloping together

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Not defending his actions so don't come at me

The complication is in that to him Mannat has moved on and is not coming back so he had to move on too but the moving on is facing challenges in that he is failing to fully commit in the new relationship.

If Yashika didn't have an ulterior motive Vikrant wouldn't have lasted 2years in that relationship. She is the one carrying that relationship.

Won't comment about Mannat giving him another chance. I think Manvik have bigger issues to address apart from him trying to move on. His nail in the coffin is believing that she moved onto his brother. He may face bigger challenges with that more than him having a girlfriend. The girlfriend issue is a ripple effect of him not having trust.

No.. No... Why would I come at you😂🤭😅

In fact I myself cannot be mad at Vik, I am actually mad at writers for presenting Vik's character arc in such a way... They put lot of efforts in making Vik do mistakes.. And when it's time to deal with the consequences of it they get too laid back in writing his character....

Actually issue is more about time...if it's shorter duration it's understandable that people take time to realise their feelings...but even after 2-3yrs holding onto the relationship despite knowing one is not able to move on is wrong...in such situation the person is neither being loyal to their past nor present...And now that you pointed out yash having ulterior motive and hence holding onto relationship, you might be right.... Maybe Vik tried to free her from relationship but we could assume that yash is one who keeps on insisting and holding onto relationship...

But did they mention anywhere in episodes that it is 2-3 yrs relationship...?... We came to this conclusion because of leena's interview... Right???... Maybe she is mistaken, may be their relationship is not of 2-3 yrs but yash came into his life 2-3 yrs back.. And intially it was a wellwisher, then business partner and eventually got into relationship, so the actual relationship could be of much lesser duration

What happened to all the earlier aashirwad of Babaji and Mata Rani?

Those blessings ultimately led to Mannat becoming a mother without marriage. Instead of honouring faith, the makers seem to be mocking gods, rituals, sindoor, and now they’ve even dragged Shruthi’s atma into it. This doesn’t feel like storytelling anymore—it feels disrespectful.

Also, Mannat never gave him any promise that no one else would ever be in her life if he wasn’t there. She didn’t need words—she proved it through her actions, by never allowing anyone to come close to her.

For Vikrant, on the other hand, everything was only words.When it came to actions, he failed to stand by the very values he once spoke about.

If Vikrant can use his power and money to stop Dhairya’s promotion, why couldn’t he use the same influence to find Mannat? Even if not out of love, at least for closure. That itself shows where his priorities truly lie.

And after the truth comes out, if someone tells him that DK and Mannat stayed in a closed room, will he accept it calmly? Of course not. He would instantly assume the worst—exactly how he judged Mannat earlier. That alone exposes his double standards.

The problem isn’t just the plot—it’s the way faith, morality, and character consistency are being twisted to suit convenience. Instead of depth, we’re getting contradictions that insult both emotions and intelligence.

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

No.. No... Why would I come at you😂🤭😅

In fact I myself cannot be mad at Vik, I am actually mad at writers for presenting Vik's character arc in such a way... They put lot of efforts in making Vik do mistakes.. And when it's time to deal with the consequences of it they get too laid back in writing his character....

Actually issue is more about time...if it's shorter duration it's understandable that people take time to realise their feelings...but even after 2-3yrs holding onto the relationship despite knowing one is not able to move on is wrong...in such situation the person is neither being loyal to their past nor present...And now that you pointed out yash having ulterior motive and hence holding onto relationship, you might be right.... Maybe Vik tried to free her from relationship but we could assume that yash is one who keeps on insisting and holding onto relationship...

But did they mention anywhere in episodes that it is 2-3 yrs relationship...?... We came to this conclusion because of leena's interview... Right???... Maybe she is mistaken, may be their relationship is not of 2-3 yrs but yash came into his life 2-3 yrs back.. And intially it was a wellwisher, then business partner and eventually got into relationship, so the actual relationship could be of much lesser duration

Is Yashika a business partner or a girlfriend who has just given herself rights in Vikrant's life? I'm not understanding how she can fail to pay her rent for 2months if she is a business partner. The partnership is not paying well enough?

Yah the 2-3year relationship we got it from leena's interview.

Vikrant's post leap situation reminds me of karwachauth terrace fight. We know mannat has always kept him at babaji da banda position, in same way Vikrant has put mannat in position where she can do no wrong. One who will always teach him, show him correct way or will make sure to salvage his mess. I know its selfish but its Vikrant, he never claimed he is selfless when it comes to Mannat. In terrace fight to Mannat blasted him off saying I wont show you correct way always, but he still kept expecting the same from her. He is stuck in the same situation 7 years back and holding the grudge that she sided with his parents who in his eyes were wrong. He always expected her to be the right one in their relationship so he flipped when he got to know she lied and even more, she is siding with wrong people.

Still after all this he expected her to come back. Again selfish, but thats how their relationship has always been. He knows he is a flawed man and loves mannat because she accepts him with his flaws. He thinks mannat is flawless and when this image broke, he couldnt handle it. Even after all of that he thought she will come back to him because if we see their history, Mannat always comes back. They never had a separation which lasted more than a day. He knows Mannat is quite stubborn, she never gives up on them, on him, on any situation. Even if she is angry at him, she has come back to make situation better or to prove him wrong, eg bobby's case, sunita's death, after vimal marriage. Every single instance she came back to make things right and he thought it will happen again. She can never abandon him.

But this time Mannat had it enough. He always thought their love is enough to make her come back to him but it didnt happen this time. He only knows half situation of Mannat not coming back to him but we know why she left. So thats why I feel his next words are gonna come true later on where he said he will fight with entire world and even with her, for her. This is where Adnan's iv plays out where he said Vikrant will fight for his love which was taken away from him unknowingly. He only knows only few reasons but we know there have been multiple reasons which played out and they will come out when truth will start getting exposed. He will also realise he also played a major part to push her away.

Rn it seems the 3 vamps are against yashika and ars is trying to keep her away but i will both the parties will dig out truths about eo to keep eachother at the gunpoint. This entire situation will flip once Mannat will enter into the picture, as she will be their common enemy. About Mannat, i feel she will be nonchalant from now on. She will be hurt but she has bigger things to worry about. I'm expecting Vikrant to lose it more, given he will have to see Mannat Dk more. Unlike Yashika Vikrant who are clingy and more on face, Mannat Dk are quite natural due to living togther for 7 years. Their one domestic conversation is enough to set Vikrant off.

Yashika and Dk are the biggest hurdles for Vikrant to get back Mannat and Dua respectively. I dont think Mannat will forgive him easily for yashika, this will give a way for angst and more redemption. About Dua, he will always have to share her with DK as for her he will always be no 1. In my opnion, the truth expose will mostly happen from Yuvi as he is that connection to which vamp camp is holding on. He will be definitely on Mannat's radar if he keeps misbehaving with Dua. Once Vikrant takes Mannat onboard as chef or partner, it will be a major hindrance for ars just like initial days where all her plans flopped because Vikrant hired mannat. She will have to use each of vamp as card, yashika to keep mannat away, malla & yuvi to keep dua away and viskakha to keep rotu away. So if Yuvi's truth gets exposed, Vikrant will get a rude shock of his life and vamp camp will start falling apart like house of cards.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Is Yashika a business partner or a girlfriend who has just given herself rights in Vikrant's life? I'm not understanding how she can fail to pay her rent for 2months if she is a business partner. The partnership is not paying well enough?

Yah the 2-3year relationship we got it from leena's interview.

There is no backstory of how and when yash entered vik's life, why Vik agreed for the relationship... Nor is there any backstory of why Vik never went in search of rotu Or what he went through in these 7 years...