Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2025
THE GOLDEN ROAD (TO UNLIMITED DEVOTION)
David Avallone
Her name was Dawn, as far as I knew. Later I found out it wasn’t: she had picked it, with great intention, for reasons both obvious and known only to herself.
In the summer of 1987, I was on my way to California when my beat-up ’71 Chevy Impala convertible blew its engine in some desert nowhere and stranded me. I found a furnished dump and got a job in a furniture factory while a sweaty jacka.s named Reid worked very slowly on my car. Refurbishing the engine would eat up the humble stake I had saved to start my new life, which meant that, even after Reid the Snail finished, I’d have to stick around until I earned it back.
I spent a couple of months assembling the rails that hold cubicles together. It felt like working in one Dickensian workhouse to put together the cells for other poor suckers in some future workhouse. But the pay was fair, as was Dawn, my supervisor.
Even before I knew it was an alias, her name had a fanciful Ian Fleming feel. I clocked in at six every July and August morning and was greeted by a tall and gorgeous woman who called herself Dawn Summers. She had a sunny smile and an explosion of frizzy blond hair like a supernova. She whistled while she worked, and from her it was somehow sweet, rather than annoying. Her eyes were blue and kind, and as blue as they were, they were kinder than they were blue.
She was thirty-something and fun and charming. I was twenty-two and fresh out of school. I wasn’t without some kind of rudimentary charm myself, but I’d never asked out an adult woman and was paralyzed by the prospect. Dawn was flirty, sure, but wasn’t she at least a little flirty with everyone? There was something in her eyes when she looked at me that I was desperate to take personally, but should I? My confidence was still very much under construction, a fragile structure in need of more concrete and rebar.
By the first week of August, Reid had finally finished the Impala, and by the second week the sack of cash under my bed had almost hit my “time to move on” goal. On the one hand, I couldn’t wait to get back on the road. On the other, there was Dawn, and the way she looked at me, which I was desperate to take personally.
One sun-blasted morning, a truck was late with a shipment of rails, and my section of the line shut down. Me and five other guys stood around the loading dock, killing time. Five other guys and Dawn.
I didn’t socialize much at work. Our routine didn’t allow for more than a few words with each other in the break room. The other guys had all gone to high school together. They called me “Hollywood,” because I’d been dumb enough on Day One to explain where I was going. These guys would live and die within fifteen miles of the hospital they were born in, and my kind of dream—the kind you cross a continent for—seemed like a fantasy to them. At first, “Hollywood” was intended to needle me, but we’d grown on each other just enough that it didn’t feel like a tease anymore. Just a nickname.
While we waited for the overdue truck, one of the other workers—a handsome dude whose name was probably John—asked Dawn, “What are you doing Saturday night?”
The rest of the boys made predictable noises of surprise and admiration at John’s taking the big swing right there in front of us. That was the kind of boldness I didn’t yet possess, and I was envious. Also, cliché or no cliché, my heart literally sank. It was a long time ago, but I can still remember my disappointment. Maybe she’d say yes, maybe she’d say no … but how could I ask her out now that John had made his move? It would seem like he’d given me the idea.
But something happened that was completely outside my life experience. Dawn gave him that big sunny smile and said, “I’m busy Saturday night.” She took a dramatic pause, then looked directly at me with a shy conspiratorial grin. “David is taking me out.”
I would love to report that I was smooth, but I can’t imagine my face was clear of surprise. Lucky for both of us, this wasn’t the most observant crowd in the world.
“That’s right.” I probably blushed. “We have a date. Saturday.”
The boys made more sitcom-audience noises. (I say “boys,” though they were all older than me, some by a decade. But that seventh-grade bio-class boy energy was still there.) Dawn blushed prettily in return, and my heart shot back from the bottom of my stomach, smashed its way through my brain, and shattered my skull on its way to the bright blue desert sky.
Before the situation became unbearably awkward, the truck showed up, and we returned to making partitions to keep future corporate drones separated and lonely.
At the end of the day, I found Dawn in the parking lot, leaning on her Volkswagen Bug. Waiting for me. For me. I went a little lightheaded at the sight of her.
“Surprised?” she said.
“Honestly? Yeah.”
“Silly boy. I thought I was obvious.”
If I’d had the self-awareness back then that I developed in the years that followed, I could have told her that my peer group had treated me like a homely weirdo for most of my life, and a couple of pretty girlfriends hadn’t managed to drown out that childhood chorus. But the guy who could have said all that didn’t exist yet.
“I wasn’t sure. I figured … I’m just some guy passing through, you wouldn’t be interested.”
She laughed. “An attractive man who’s not going to stick around and complicate my life? Baby boy, you’re perfect.”
From anyone else, I would have chafed like hell against that “baby boy,” but I was new at this, and the prospect of a woman wanting to use me and let me go was startling and wonderful.
“There’s a pretty good band Saturday night at Jerome’s,” she said. “Do you dance, David?”
She had never once called me “Hollywood.” Another thing the older, wiser me might have taken note of.
Jerome’s was a friendly dive bar in an abandoned mining camp just outside of town. Did I dance? After a fashion. I knew how to hold a woman and swing her around.
“I’ll pick you up at eight,” I said, and tried not to stammer.
Jerome’s was hopping, and the band was surprisingly great. They played an impressive array of cover tunes from a wide spectrum of pop, and I felt a particular pang when they hit Steely Dan’s “My Old School.” But Annandale was over two thousand miles in my rearview mirror. They followed it with “Cream Puff War,” and maybe I should have listened a little closer to the lyrics, like Bogart dancing with Bergman to “Perfidia” in Casablanca. Maybe you never notice those things while the story is in progress.
Freed from the confines of the furniture factory, Dawn was a revelation. Dancing with joyous abandon, eyes shining like diamonds in the neon light, singing along, kicking off her shoes and dancing barefoot on the sawdust. I was careful not to step on her pink-painted toes. I could tell she liked my arms around her, liked the gentle pressure on the lower back that telegraphs the upcoming swing. She was a little taller than me and giggled uncontrollably when I dipped her. I played into that a bit and dipped her almost to the floor. “Don’t drop me!” she cried.
Dawn, radiating light and heat, uncontainable, captivated the crowd. Every eye in the place was on her, and that suited me just fine. I’d wondered, on the drive to pick her up, if the locals would resent seeing their resident supernova squired by the itinerant city boy … but she was more intoxicating than anything coming out of Jerome’s taps, and her joy obliterated any jealousy that might have lingered in an observer’s heart.
And then, during what turned out to be our last dance, she pulled me close and kissed me. If there were any jealous eyes watching, I was too delirious to notice. I might have started shaking—I was still young enough for that—but a couple of drinks had taken the edge off my nerves.
“Let’s go look at the stars,” she whispered in my ear.
And we did.
The Fair Grounds were a couple of miles farther out of town. At night, I couldn’t tell what made them “Fair Grounds” and not just a patch of scrubby grass in the desert. The nowhere town didn’t put out much in the way of light pollution, and I—growing up in New Jersey suburbs—had never seen so many stars.
The star-gazing part didn’t last long. Despite our being grown adults who both had keys to rooms with doors that locked, the back seat of my convertible under the starry sky was where it happened. The supernova consumed me. At first with a flattering impatience, and then again with slow-motion intensity.
In between, we talked. I can be embarrassingly chatty in the afterglow, or mid-glow, or whatever you want to call it. I talked about where I was going, about my dreams. It didn’t occur to me how that might strike her, but she was as kind as her blue, blue eyes.
I don’t remember when we collapsed into unconsciousness.
I woke up entangled in her, in every sense you can imagine. The sun was just beginning to crack the sky and flood the desert plain with golden light. I sat up and watched it rise. I looked down at her and her eyes were open, and just that much bluer and kinder. She sat up with me and took in the view.
“This is my favorite. My favorite time,” she said.
“Dawn’s favorite time is dawn.” I kidded. “That follows.”
She smiled, but her mind had gone somewhere else, and she was still there.
“See the road?” she said. “The golden road?”
I followed her gaze to the lone country lane that ran from horizon to horizon. The daybreak had painted it with molten sunlight.
“It’s like the Yellow Brick Road, but even more beautiful, more …”
She trailed off. Thoughtful.
“It’s an invitation,” I offered. “To go and keep going,”
She turned to me, nodding. “I knew you’d get it. You were following it, following the golden road, when you got shipwrecked.”
I gestured to the Impala’s endless black hood. “It took him a while, but Reid has repaired the mast and patched the hull.”
I wouldn’t say she frowned, but she got serious. I put my arms around her and kissed her. “That doesn’t mean I’m going. Not—”
“—not right now,” she interrupted me. “Not today. But you are going. You have to.”
“You said that was part of the attraction.”
“And it was. Is. You fall for a sailor, you can’t be mad when he goes back to sea.”
“Am I a sailor or the Scarecrow? We’re mixing our myths.”
She laughed, and she was so absolutely stunning I said a thing I hadn’t expected to say. “It’s a big car, Dawn. Seats two, with plenty of space left over. You could take the golden road, too. Take it all the way to the sea. With me.”
“Oh, baby boy … you don’t mean that. It’s sweet, but don’t confuse a girl.”
I took a deep breath and looked out at her golden road. Did I mean it?
“Before yesterday,” I said, “I had a clear path ahead. Another paycheck or two, and then westward I’d go. Things are less clear today. The boy is as confused as the girl.”
We both looked back at the brightening desert plain, and I decided to change the subject. I looked at my watch. “The Red Fox is open. Nothing confusing about coffee and flapjacks.”
So we ate breakfast and drank coffee and stared at each other with that comfort and bliss and affection completely unique to a “morning after” with no regrets. We spent the rest of the day in my furnished dump and continued to make up for lost time. We didn’t talk about the future, or any yellow-brick or golden roads, or Odysseus and Calypso.…
On Monday and Tuesday and Wednesday, she spent the night with me, then slipped out while it was still dark to shower and dress for work at her own home. We kept it cool at the factory, but the boys on the floor knew. They teased me about it, but it wasn’t mean. They were envious, sure, but they were also impressed. And they started asking me when I was planning to leave town, which was as charming as it was unsubtle.
Dawn and I made plans to go back to Jerome’s on Saturday night.
“Farewell party?” she said, with a sad little smile.
“One-week anniversary,” I said, and she laughed and beamed.
Thursday night, she didn’t come over. I called her place, and she didn’t pick up. I tried not to let my jealous, insecure twenty-two-year-old heart fry my brain. But I also didn’t get any sleep.
Friday morning, she wasn’t at work. Me and the boys got to it, assembling cubicle walls, but my heart was in my throat. Another cliché, but how else do you say it? My head was pounding. If you can’t remember that kind of physical pain, then you don’t remember your own fragile young self.
On my first break, I was picking up a payphone to try her at home when the cops walked in.
I hung up without dialing and watched them talk to the receptionist. Saw her point at me. My mind went to the worst thing, but I didn’t guess right. There were other bad things it could have been, including at least one that never would have occurred to me.
They held up a picture of a woman with straight dark hair and sad eyes. Black and white, so you couldn’t see the blue. But you could see the kindness. They asked the obvious question.
“Of course. That’s Dawn, my supervisor. Did something happen to her?”
I got that smug-cop smirk. The “I know something you don’t know” smirk. I kept my face blank and impassive.
“She didn’t show up to work today. You know anything about that?”
“Nope. She seemed fine yesterday.”
“What about last night?” His self-satisfaction was at its peak, but I didn’t bite.
“In general, yesterday includes a full twenty-four hours. But I didn’t see her after work, if that’s what you’re being cute about.”
He didn’t like that. He wanted a confession I’d been sleeping with her. “And the night before?”
“The night before, she was her usual happy self. What happened?”
“You her boyfriend?”
“You her mother?” I don’t usually mouth off to cops. They have guns and limitless sadism and immunity from any consequences. But a bunch of folks from the floor had stopped work and were watching from a safe distance. I felt like my odds of getting beaten up or killed were slim.
“Listen, as.hole. We know you’ve been sleeping with her. Did she ever tell you her real name’s Alice Yvonne Bennett? And that she’s a fugitive?”
“The one-armed man did it,” I said. I couldn’t help myself. This was a few years before the big movie, so the cop just got confused and angrier.
“The one-armed—what the f.ck are you talking about?”
“Look,” I said, taking a deep breath. “I’m sorry. It was a joke. I’m worried about her, and you two aren’t making me less worried. What’s she wanted for?”
The cops looked at each other. The silent one finally spoke. “Murder. Your girlfriend Dawn who’s really Alice? Well, thing is, she murdered a man and ran away. Still worried about her?”
I played the part of shocked clown for a bit, and they calmed down. It wasn’t entirely an act. I could think of reasons why a perfectly good person might run from a murder charge, but did I really want to start making excuses without hearing the story from her? Murder was hard to square with the woman I knew—but how well did I really know her? How well does anyone know anyone? Maybe for Dawn-who-was-Alice, the appeal of the golden road was just the appeal of escape.
I finished my day. I gave the front office the address of my old college buddy Bill in Los Angeles to send my last check to. With any luck, I could be on Bill’s doorstep before the check hit his mailbox. I knew quitting now would look suspicious and leaving town only more so. Maybe those two cops and their buddies would chase me to the state line. Maybe they’d check to see if she was in my trunk.
Maybe it would take a little pressure off her if they wasted their time following me.
I didn’t care. I hadn’t killed anyone, and without Dawn I was done with this nowhere desert town.
I went back to my furnished dump and packed what little I had. I looked out the window and, sure enough, Tweedledum and Tweedledee had parked their cruiser across the street. Real subtle. Sterling police work.
I thought I was ready to roar off into the desert and leave Dawn behind me. In 1987, there were no cell phones and no internet. If I hit the road, the golden road, that would be it. I would never see her again, never know her story.
That didn’t feel right, and I had a hard time accepting it.
Around dusk, I realized where she might be, if she wanted to see me one last time. If she wasn’t already halfway to Mexico. First I had to lose the cops. I had an idea about that, too.
They watched me lug my duffel bag out to my car. They watched me leave the key to my dump in the mailbox. I’m sure they were excited. I got in the Impala and took a little tour of the nowhere town. They probably thought I was trying to lose them, but mostly I was trying to bore them.
After about a half hour of meandering, I drove into Reid’s junkyard. The cops parked outside the entrance and waited.
Reid was surprised to see me. We didn’t like each other. I was playing a hunch, though. His whole operation was shady, and there was no way in the world he liked cops. I told him these two were hassling me. I told him I’d noticed he had a back gate that led to a desert road. He stared at me in silence until I gave him a fifty. He took in the grim visage of President Grant, and said, “I’ll open the gate. Let me pull my tow truck across the entrance, so they can’t see you or follow you through the yard.”
I spotted something helpful in his office and bought it for another twenty. Reid was having a big day.
He unlatched the back gate, then went around to fire up his truck. The sun had set. My lights were off. If I could keep off the brakes, they wouldn’t see me driving into the desert. If I fought the impulse to speed, they wouldn’t see a dust cloud. Reid rolled his tow truck to the front gate, and I pulled slowly out onto the dirt road. I took the time to get out and close the gate behind me, just in case.
The road was ruler-straight for miles. I didn’t know how long it would take Tweedledee and Tweedledum to figure out what had happened, but I planned to be invisible long before they did.
A few miles down the road, I looked in the rearview and saw no signs of pursuit. Bless you, Reid. You overcharged for the engine block, but you came through in the end. I’d gambled on him loving a scam, any scam at all, more than he disliked me, and I’d been right.
With the help of a tattered map I’d picked up when I first hit town, I found the Fair Grounds. They were empty, of course. But I parked in roughly the spot I had a week ago, before the stargazing, and sat on the hood of my Impala. And waited.
The Milky Way wheeled slowly overhead. I tried to remember if I’d seen it before, but mostly I thought about the supernova whose name was Dawn or Alice. Dawn the explosion of life and joy, Alice the sad-eyed murderess.
I figured I’d give her until an hour or two after daybreak, then find my way to the closest thick horizontal line on the map and turn west.
It was still full dark when I saw headlights, small and close together. Not a cruiser. More like a VW Bug.
I got off the hood and watched her approach.
In spite of everything, her smile was still breathtaking, a supernova by starlight. We didn’t embrace. She knew there had to be some talk first.
“I don’t know if I’m surprised or not surprised,” she said. “I wanted you to be here.”
“I wasn’t sure you’d want to see me again. But if you did …”
She let it hang there, looked at her feet. “What did they tell you?”
“They told me you killed a man.”
She looked up at me. “I did, David. I did that. I won’t lie to you.”
“There’s a lot of reasons a woman kills a man. Which one was it?”
“Maybe not the first one that comes to mind.”
I mulled that for a minute, then took a stab at it. “So it wasn’t you? Then who was it? Mother, sister, niece …?”
She looked at the horizon. The light had started to creep over. “You’re smart,” she said. “I always liked that about you.”
“Go on.”
She made eye contact again. “I have a sister. She had a husband. She showed up at my house one night, and her face … well, I barely recognized her past the bruises and the blood. I was washing out her wounds when he came pounding on the door and yelling for her.” There was a pause. She bit her lip. “I kept a baseball bat by my front door.”
“Did he threaten you?”
“He never got a chance to. Swinging the bat at his head was … it wasn’t a hard decision. It was no decision at all. It felt good. Overdue. Even when I saw the blood, I didn’t stop. I didn’t want to stop.”
She wasn’t emotional about it. I wondered how long ago it had been. The girl in the photo with the dark straight hair looked maybe five years younger. But that didn’t matter.
“Was there a trial? Or did you not stick around?”
“I didn’t stick around. Her husband was a cop, David. I beat a cop to death. So it was another easy decision. I called an ambulance for my sister, kissed her on the forehead, and then—”
“—and then the golden road.”
“Something like that,” she said. We both looked over at the sunrise. Alice, not Dawn, but also Dawn. She gave a small laugh. “You kill anybody back in Jersey, David?”
“No. I’m one of those idiots who’s running away from a perfectly fine life. There might have been an unpaid parking ticket or two.” I took a breath. “You could leave the Bug here and get in the Impala.”
She smiled again. “I couldn’t. You’re the sweetest boy, and your future is bright. I’d bring you down, and those dreams of yours … they wouldn’t come true. They’d never have a chance.”
“I’m tougher than I look. And smart, like you said.”
“All that is true. But you didn’t sign up for this. I know how you feel right now, but … we just met. Really. You don’t owe me the things my troubles would take from you. You owe yourself a new life, like I did when I ran. Chase it. Give it your unlimited devotion and be happy. I’ll be okay. I promise.”
“Dawn,” I started, but it was all I said.
“David.” That was all she said. But it said everything.
I got my dusty Mets cap from my trunk and handed it to her. “Stuff your hair under that until you have time for a new dye job.”
“Yes, sir,” she said.
Then I went back into the trunk for the set of license plates I’d bought from Reid and a flathead screwdriver. I replaced the plates on the Bug, while she stared off at the golden road, stretching out to her next new life.
Last kisses are a lot like first kisses.