Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No "126" - Page 142

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

57.7k

Users

25

Likes

3.8k

Frequent Posters

Darkxmatter thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 hours ago

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

Wahi toh....It’s as if Leena takes a strange delight in the spectacle of women’s suffering. Her stories don’t just depict martyrdom — they revel in it.

By simply showing that “women choose martyrdom,” she isn’t making any additional point as a writer. We already know this. We live in societies where a large part of it celebrate women who suffer quietly and shame those who demand better. A writer’s role is to question that conditioning — not to reproduce it uncritically for the sake of drama.

Leena’s women never evolve beyond their pain.Instead, Leena’s women are trapped in an endless loop of suffering and sacrifice, as if the only way for them to be “great” is to be perpetually broken. She’ll glorify their endurance, romanticize their misery, and call it empowerment — when in reality, it’s nothing but emotional punishment dressed as depth.

There’s always some divine intervention, family crisis, or misplaced guilt waiting to drag them down the moment they start to rise. And like in "Ishani" just when the audience hopes she’ll finally let her heroine breathe, Leena pulled out her favourite trick — spiritual escapism.

“Don’t give her a career, Give her moksha.🤣” Leena's writing operates on one bizarre rule — baas, any excuse to not give her female leads a dignified, normal life

They do not learn to differentiate between compassion and self-destruction. And when they finally walk away, it isn’t toward liberation — it’s toward divinity or death, because even their self-discovery has to look tragic.

It’s not empowerment; it’s some weird suffering fetish.

And the saddest part is She seems to believe she’s writing progressive stories.

I am starting to think this is AI writing. 🤣

Darkxmatter thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 hours ago

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

Wahi toh....It’s as if Leena takes a strange delight in the spectacle of women’s suffering. Her stories don’t just depict martyrdom — they revel in it.

By simply showing that “women choose martyrdom,” she isn’t making any additional point as a writer. We already know this. We live in societies where a large part of it celebrate women who suffer quietly and shame those who demand better. A writer’s role is to question that conditioning — not to reproduce it uncritically for the sake of drama.

Leena’s women never evolve beyond their pain.Instead, Leena’s women are trapped in an endless loop of suffering and sacrifice, as if the only way for them to be “great” is to be perpetually broken. She’ll glorify their endurance, romanticize their misery, and call it empowerment — when in reality, it’s nothing but emotional punishment dressed as depth.

There’s always some divine intervention, family crisis, or misplaced guilt waiting to drag them down the moment they start to rise. And like in "Ishani" just when the audience hopes she’ll finally let her heroine breathe, Leena pulled out her favourite trick — spiritual escapism.

“Don’t give her a career, Give her moksha.🤣” Leena's writing operates on one bizarre rule — baas, any excuse to not give her female leads a dignified, normal life

They do not learn to differentiate between compassion and self-destruction. And when they finally walk away, it isn’t toward liberation — it’s toward divinity or death, because even their self-discovery has to look tragic.

It’s not empowerment; it’s some weird suffering fetish.

And the saddest part is She seems to believe she’s writing progressive stories.

What do you think of yrkkh writers ? I think They have the same theme for there lead characters

sanfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 hours ago

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

Wahi toh....It’s as if Leena takes a strange delight in the spectacle of women’s suffering. Her stories don’t just depict martyrdom — they revel in it.

By simply showing that “women choose martyrdom,” she isn’t making any additional point as a writer. We already know this. We live in societies where a large part of it celebrate women who suffer quietly and shame those who demand better. A writer’s role is to question that conditioning — not to reproduce it uncritically for the sake of drama.

Leena’s women never evolve beyond their pain.Instead, Leena’s women are trapped in an endless loop of suffering and sacrifice, as if the only way for them to be “great” is to be perpetually broken. She’ll glorify their endurance, romanticize their misery, and call it empowerment — when in reality, it’s nothing but emotional punishment dressed as depth.

There’s always some divine intervention, family crisis, or misplaced guilt waiting to drag them down the moment they start to rise. And like in "Ishani" just when the audience hopes she’ll finally let her heroine breathe, Leena pulled out her favourite trick — spiritual escapism.

“Don’t give her a career, Give her moksha.🤣” Leena's writing operates on one bizarre rule — baas, any excuse to not give her female leads a dignified, normal life

They do not learn to differentiate between compassion and self-destruction. And when they finally walk away, it isn’t toward liberation — it’s toward divinity or death, because even their self-discovery has to look tragic.

It’s not empowerment; it’s some weird suffering fetish.

And the saddest part is She seems to believe she’s writing progressive stories.

If I were to take Ishaani itself… apparently she had a father who was supposedly a bit supportive… this means that at some level Ishaani had lived some time in a progressive environment however weak it be… so Leena’s premise of an Ishaani having to marry an older man and further endure abuse would have made no sense… cos why would a person who has tasted some freedom submit so tamely to some stupid existence.

Leena knows that showing a woman saying no to abuse charts a path that has a logical end signifying liberation. So, Leena drags the premise with the stupidest tropes so she can add to the episode count. That is the sum total of her creativity - EPISODE BANK GENERATION

asmitamohanty thumbnail
Most Posts (June 2024) Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 hours ago

Originally posted by: Darkxmatter

I am starting to think this is AI writing. 🤣

Sorry? What?

Darkxmatter thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 hours ago

AAAAAAAAAAIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 🤣🤣🤣

Edited by Darkxmatter - 6 hours ago
asmitamohanty thumbnail
Most Posts (June 2024) Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 hours ago

Originally posted by: Darkxmatter

What do you think of yrkkh writers ? I think They have the same theme for there lead characters

Well I have not seen yrkkh since a long time....I used to watch it during Naitik-Akshara track...and a bit of Kaira....

Particularly the part when Ashnoor was there...and writing was really really good at that time..

In season 3 and 4 I obviously know what they showed in terms of storyline overall from sm and other discussions but then as long as you have not seen the episode you can't actually capture the nuances in writing..

But Naitik and Akshara part was really good.The Naitik-Akshara track didn’t depend on toxic drama. It was about small, real conflicts - learning to adjust in marriage, balancing in-laws, work-life dilemmas, losing and rebuilding trust.The emotions felt lived-in, not scripted for shock values.Even during moments of disagreement, both characters had mutual respect, something Leena’s writing almost never allows between her couples...and Both the families Singhania and Maheshwari family felt really natural..show captured nuances of middle-class Indian families - rituals, warmth, generational gaps, yet deep love underneath.It wasn’t just about the leads.. every elder had a distinct emotional arc

Yrkkh was a good show at that time..it had writing that respected emotions..

I don't think we can even expect such things in a Leena show...


Baaki if you are asking me about yrkkh 's writing of present time, I don't have much to offer

rushi1981 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 hours ago

Just checked..Hiba unblocked krushal 😂

asmitamohanty thumbnail
Most Posts (June 2024) Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 hours ago

Originally posted by: rushi1981

Just checked..Hiba unblocked krushal 😂

😂 Oh my, the saga continues!

It’s honestly giving such comedic vibes at this point — block, unfollow, shade, emotional post, subtle unblock. They’re basically scripting their own ITV plotline off-screen...🤣🤣

asmitamohanty thumbnail
Most Posts (June 2024) Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 hours ago

Originally posted by: sanfan

If I were to take Ishaani itself… apparently she had a father who was supposedly a bit supportive… this means that at some level Ishaani had lived some time in a progressive environment however weak it be… so Leena’s premise of an Ishaani having to marry an older man and further endure abuse would have made no sense… cos why would a person who has tasted some freedom submit so tamely to some stupid existence.

Leena knows that showing a woman saying no to abuse charts a path that has a logical end signifying liberation. So, Leena drags the premise with the stupidest tropes so she can add to the episode count. That is the sum total of her creativity - EPISODE BANK GENERATION

You know Rekha dii....i have not seen the part of "Ishaani 's life" that they had shown in "Jhanak" simply bcz I had completely cut myself off at that point and was trying to detach..

But but I agree with you regarding Leena 's style..Leena thrives on manufactured helplessness. She deliberately strips her women of agency because empowerment ends a story, whereas endurance keeps TRPs running.

What’s even more ironic is that she pretends to be writing from a moral or emotional depth --- “the journey of sacrifice,” “the pain of womanhood,” etc...but it’s hollow. There’s no catharsis, no consequence, no introspection. Just recycled trauma presented as sanctity.

Dibya_C thumbnail
Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 hours ago

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

😂 Oh my, the saga continues!

It’s honestly giving such comedic vibes at this point — block, unfollow, shade, emotional post, subtle unblock. They’re basically scripting their own ITV plotline off-screen...🤣🤣

R aaaaa...abhi firse followings, followed by joint appearances honge...

AYji aur Shalini...I have won the bet...well partially...🤪

Related Topics

Jhanak thumbnail

Posted by: ALUJNA21 · 1 months ago

Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No "125 "

Expand ▼
Jhanak thumbnail

Posted by: ALUJNA21 · 2 months ago

Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No "124 "

Expand ▼
Jhanak thumbnail

Posted by: ExoticDisaster · 2 months ago

Welcome to Let us go through the rules before proceeding any further! Banner Size should be 1456W X 180H. You MUST read this before you get into...

Expand ▼
Jhanak thumbnail

Posted by: DreamOfEndless · 1 years ago

Welcome to Jhanak Picture Gallery! Post all the pictures related to the show here in this thread ONLY. If you want to thank any member for...

Expand ▼
Jhanak thumbnail

Posted by: ExoticDisaster · 1 years ago

!! Warm Welcome to all the Members!! DO post all the creations related to Jhanak here. Rules to Follow : You can Comment but refrain from...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".