Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 29 - Page 47

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Why is everyone so upset with Neetu… this isn’t anything new… she was shown to be obsessed with Vikrant and has always been controlling. Now especially since she knows Vishakha is here she is all the more worried she will lose her….. she knows what they did was wrong.

Anyone who she thinks will take away her son is a threat and she is losing to Mannat… Vikrant is absolutely unconditionally in love with Mannat.

All her behavior is just so obvious…. Again as long as Vikrant doesn’t cater to her whims we are good… I too didn’t understand why he was sunaofying Neetu but oh well … even though Neetu declared with high pitch noise that wedding is off Vikrant was with Mannat… no one is paying any heed to Neetus opinion or dhamki

I haven’t watched the bts …

PS I was floored with Mannats cute slowly asking Vikrant … Aap sach mein theek ho nah… she clearly waited restless but had to wait until the family had asked everything.. Ayesha was so good! If you live in a large family you know this was totally husband wife coded … wives cannot just go infront of everyone and hug or ask her directly… there is that subtlety and Mannat did just that..

That "Suniye na" stood out ..touched me I had mentioned in my earlier post too !

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

PS I was floored with Mannats cute slowly asking Vikrant … Aap sach mein theek ho nah… she clearly waited restless but had to wait until the family had asked everything.. Ayesha was so good! If you live in a large family you know this was totally husband wife coded … wives cannot just go infront of everyone and hug or ask her directly… there is that subtlety and Mannat did just that..

I loved it too. She almost passed out, at one point. But she waited, and then she said 'Suniye na'..' I loved the way she said it..

Implication of this standing position didn't even click to me

https://x.com/ArtNesbur/status/1975394044030415028

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Implication of this standing position didn't even click to me

https://x.com/ArtNesbur/status/1975394044030415028

Chalo SM kah ek naya mehmaan

https://youtu.be/7RI2SHX7Hho

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

O have a different perspective here.

Vikrant did the right thing by making Neetu hear all those words because they have been piling up ..it had more to do with his hurt and sadness that he failed in front of mannat ..

He anyways would have always be with mannat but the chance to tell neetu what he felt when she was spewing the poison..he did not want to let it go..

It was for both mannat and neetu ..he knows he should have taken a more stronger stand but he explained why ..

We don’t scream at our parents ..parents can have bad behaviour but mostly we ignore them ..we don’t drag them out of the house just because they don’t like someone ..

I love the writers here for addressing this beautifully ..

Just because neetu is saying that she is bad omen ..doesn’t make her one!

The best thing is , nobody listens to neetu ..she blabbers and goes off ..

Mannat should be the one taking stand for herself here ..her shruti mom too stands and listens ..

But then mannat counter attacking neetu would make things worse ! Mannat is an intelligent woman and she knows why Neetu is behaving how she is behaving ..she knows that neetu is under a misconception..

We often don’t argue with ppl who doesn’t understand us because that leads to nowhere ..beat is to ignore the person because anyways vikrant is doing what he wants and even making his mom part of those rituals ..

His mom said no shaadi..so what?! Nothing changes ..he is an adult and he has taken decision to marry

Vikrant did not say much because he thought his mother was mentally unstable hearing hai accident news and he was waiting for her to calm down ..but she did not ..

Maybe in future if things don’t improve , he might even walk away ..

But as of now there is no need ..

And also i saw some ppl telling mannat to walk away ..why? Why will she walk away from vikrant just coz Neetu hates her?! There can be ppl who don’t like us ..why will we give up our happiness for them ?

Neetu is filthy mouth person but she doesn’t conspire to kill mannat neither is conspiring to drive her out and playing victim ..it’s just plain hatred which is unbearable here

But love how the writers are addressing the issue

Your post is absolutely bang on, Deepa

Agree with every point

Why should Mannat leave Vik, her love just because Neetu hates her..no, not at all..

Shruti advised her to win her heart ..It's absolutely right advice instead of going against her and increasing rifts in the family, Mannat should be silent and deal cleverly with mental Neetu..

Anyways as long as our boy is absolutely in love with her, he stands by her even silently ,it doesn't matter ,how much Neetu behaves indecently and intolerably..

In a way all these unbearable acts of Neetu play adversely against her in future when the truth is revealed..

Vik did the right thing by sunoge Neetu..as I said it in my earlier post...which he couldn't say directly in front of everyone....

Also the fact that she is so vile towards Mannat will go against her. She should ideally use Mannat to stay close to Vikrant, instead she's driving him away gradually with her behaviour.

He doesn't know anything about them, for him, her insecurity/ hate towards Mannat is baseless.

If we look at this track as a whole , its kinda interesting..It shows the way different people around Vikrant / Aman respond to his pain !

Neetu Saluja , adores him to the core , totally obsessed and cannot imagine life without her son yet she chooses to let her so called pyara puttharji to suffer with all the panic attacks / flashes in order to suppress her own hidden crimes .Such a tainted love

Mannat , his love..unaware of his traumatic past she still becomes his true healer in this storm . Without even knowing the 'Why' behind his pain , she instinctively tries to protect him and becomes the calm to his chaos.

Dhairiya Kumar , the protective brother whose identity still remains unknown to Vikrant / Aman ..his internal conflicts on causing pain to his brother and his silent determination to help his brother recall the old memories without causing further pain is also equally touching.

So each of them represents a different shade of love here ! I really hope the makers do justice to this track and eventually call out the injustice that turned Aman Kumar into Vikrant Saluja !

Originally posted by: Uma85

Neetu Saluja , adores him to the core , totally obsessed and cannot imagine life without her son yet she chooses to let her so called pyara puttharji to suffer with all the panic attacks / flashes in order to suppress her own hidden crimes .Such a tainted love

...and Neetu yesterday said Mannat's love is dikhawa, banaawati.

A laughable comment indeed !!

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Chalo SM kah ek naya mehmaan

https://youtu.be/7RI2SHX7Hho

Mannat's outfit is nice..But what is going on with Vik's costume ? atrocious..that kurta over some loose pants Also Vishaka looks so thin and young ..I am still not getting that motherly vibe watching her can't they not change the cast mid way haan ??