Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 25 - Page 140

Originally posted by: Resham

I just cannot stop laughing seeing the BTS....seems aage jaake Vikrant ko Ani ke haat pair jodne honge and ask for Mannats hand which won't be easy now ....

Ani should refuse saying he wants someone who trusts his daughters words blindly and not a proof man

Originally posted by: Taiyo

Moor,

Reaction to an actor's acting cannot be always objective. It is subjective. I most focus on story and rarely talk acting, but after reading your post, here is my opinion.

Adnan's acting when he is angry or emotional is quite animated ... that is his style, but that may not to be the liking of all, and it will not work for every character that he may play later on in his career. [I like his voice modulation and more of composed acting.]

I used to find Ayesha weak when she had to emote and talk (She is one of the most fluid actresses on screen). But she has improved a lot, and it just shows, she knows her shortcomings and is working on it.

TV is an audio and visual medium, your words have to be clear so that the audience understands what the character is going through.

At the end, everyone forms an opinion when watching something, and nothing wrong in that, just that it should not come from a place of malice.

Perfectly explained...

Last paragraph and last line is the key

Originally posted by: Rdigest

That's a silly plan honestly, by the time Mannat is home I am sure ARS would have spun another story

I will be surprised if this plan doesn't flop. For someone who was assaulted a few days ago by goons it's surprising that she is willing to risk her life like this with no backup. Varun is on her dad's side right. She could have sent him address to tag along with her.

These superwoman traits they keep showing are just getting the show bashed.

And Malla ordered food from Mezbaani it seems..Lmao...kick this out

Originally posted by: Resham

And Malla ordered food from Mezbaani it seems..Lmao...kick this out

Seriously???

Originally posted by: Resham

And Malla ordered food from Mezbaani it seems..Lmao...kick this out

Of course Mezbaani uskee restaurant hain, paise thodee waste karegee for another restaurant , pehle hee kangaal hain

This is more than insane....I am rolling on the floor by seeing BTS...

Originally posted by: Moor278

Sunday hai aur episode late hai...

Isliye want some discussion and opinion

No offence to anyone or their favourites 😍

What constitutes 'good acting' in emotional scenes especially when the actor is supposed to cry and mouth dialogue?

Reddit is very critical of Ayesha... always has been. Lately I saw some criticizing Adnan too... for his hand gestures and continous movement in such scenes.

People over X, here, lost forum... all have same thing to say... that Ayesha has improved... that in the crying scenes... her dialogues are not audible and only now has she got a hang of it...

This is my question...

Why and how should an actor portray an intensely emotional scene??? Dont we all look ugly and the speech comes out halted and garbled when some one is crying and processing emotions from the sudden shock/trauma/attack????

I have personally never had that issue... the speech was fine to me but I have always heard this about her.

Just because its an actor is it the necessary that the audience hears crystal clear dialogues and it has to be properly audible to us????

Where is the realism????

Ayesha with her performance in such scenes always manages to evoke intense reactions in the viewer... will it be possible if she is controlled and more conscious of what she is saying, how she is saying and how she looks????

Ayesha yesterday and Mona in Mannats arrival post Panmasala wedding had a small nuance... both were trying to pull something away from their throats ... Mona her jewelry and Ayesha her blouse... in a way signifying the suffocation they were feeling... that was a beautiful touch... 😍

And Ayesha was unwell, this scene was not rehearsed and was done in one take!!!! Absolutely brilliant display of her craft!!!!✨️✨️✨️✨️

Adnan acts not just with his voice but his body... he shuffles, has exaggerated hand movements, his veins pop up, face turns red... none of this is possible if the actor is not feeling the characters emotions... He has had 3 scenes (that I remember) where he cried and spoke... Mannats rejection, pyar ki gully after wedding and storeroom... in mezbani his speech was garbled too... by the storeroom situation Vikrant had processed a lot... and was quite clear...

NB used to generate spit in his crying scenes and his haters would criticize that... I didnt like the criticizm (edit) but never mentioned it then.

The only other example that I quote for reference is Katha... Aditi cried stoically... but that could be because since the start of the show Katha had lost her husband and son was dying with cancer. Katha was consciously putting up a happy face for Aarav. She must have processed those emotions multiple times earlier (before the show/story started... ) hence her responses were measured and not overtly emotional.

My question is this... should the actor be more careful and conscious about how he/she looks or should it be as raw as possible... to make it look real and raw but may have to give up on the clarity of speech???

Also the difference between voice of male and female actors... pitch tone and manner of speaking also matters...

Thoughts please 🙏

Good point for Sunday discussion, Moor ..I will try to give my opinions in some time..

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I will be surprised if this plan doesn't flop. For someone who was assaulted a few days ago by goons it's surprising that she is willing to risk her life like this with no backup. Varun is on her dad's side right. She could have sent him address to tag along with her.

These superwoman traits they keep showing are just getting the show bashed.

See ARS said Ani made me say all those dialogues in jail and all the dumbo's believed her. ARS can say Ani forced Malla to say she got her kidnapped by threatening her

Waise looks like in this show we are beyond video proof now , like drug doctor video, ARS trying to kill video, any video Mannat shows can be squashed saying they were forced to say those things and their words will hold more value than Mannat

Mannat should seriously think about shutting the PI shop and shifting to Himalayas for peace.

Mannat should either buy a new phone ya phir Shalini ka phone le jaati... I am surprised Malla didnt recognize her chef coat cover

Stupid hai honestly