All Bella's Fault?

hello

do you guys think that all the torn feeling bella has is self inflicted>?

i mean i am starting to feel real bad for jake! bella flirted with him well not flirted but hung out with him and he fell in love with her but the minute edward comes bk she forgets all that and goes bk to edward!

so do you think its her fault?

Hmm..yeaa iknoww but itz jake fault too..she knows that she likes edward...a then why did he cameee between themm 😆 😆 😆

Well, I want to say yes, and no.

Bella did somethings to make her feel guilty. Like in the third one, asking Jake. She did that to herself. And she did flirt with him in the first book. But then again, humans...Gah 😆 😳

Now Jacob, he liked her and he made it plainly obvious that he did. Yeah, he pushed, but he knew that Bella loved him. He just wanted to know if there was a way she would choose him. Some people would do that, while some, like Edward, would walk away, just to make the one they love happy. They both are a bit different, and htey love her in different ways. 😳

There are times when I re-read the books, that I get mad at Bella, and then there are times, Im mad at Jake...Hehe im never mad at Edward...I wonder why.. 😳 😆

well ive only read twilight so far so from what i know, i think its really jakes fault 😳 😆 😆 i mean sure bella flirted with him but he already knows very well shes in love with eddy 😳 😆 so yh... from what i know so far 😉 😆

hmm....yes I hate Jacob alot but your right its Bella....back at that beach part or whatever....she was fluting with him to get info on the Cullens....thats when Jacob started liking her....ohh you stupid stupid Bella!!

Well To Be perfectly honest its everybody's fault and yet none of them can be blamed. They are all victims of circumstances

Bella flirted with Jake in Twilight bt cmon ,Lets not forget Edward dazzled people frequently to get his way too. It was harmless flirting and she didnt foresee the complications that arised . She doesnt quite understand how she can care so much for someone apart from Edward.

And even after he came back, she did her best to keep Jacob as her best friend to the extent of fighting with EDward. Bt there are some things one HAS TO choose.

It was Edward's fault in the first place as well (not that i blame him for leaving) . If he hadnt left, she wouldnt have had to turn to someone else for comfort.
As he himself put it
"when I left you, Bella, I left you bleeding. Jacob was the one to stitch you back up again. That was bound to leave its mark — on both of you. I'm not sure those kinds of stitches dissolve on their own. I can't blame either of you for something I made necessary. I may gain forgiveness, but that doesn't let me escape the consequences"

Jacob is somewhat less at fault as he is only trying his best to win the girl he loves , even if he doesnt realise how much he is hurting her in the process. He hopes later he will be able to heal her.



P.s. I am an Edwardian through and through. Bt i cant help bt point out where i believe jacob isnt wrong

yeah i agree......to ritika

everybody flirts a bit......nothing harmful in that......and bella truly loved edward and she made it no secret......when edward left she ws broken, worse than that and she tried to bring herself together and found a true friend in jacob........the kind of wreck she ws post edward its not cruel on her part to find anchor to cling to her sanity........but then jake fell in love with her and he not being mature and understanding as edward cd nt walk away and tried to win over bella which ws futile.........not that i blame jake but he did drown himself into this illusion even though he knew bella ws always edward's.............all made mistakes but poor souls, each of them got so much hurt............

and that line ritika quoted about edward telling bella how he understands what they r going thru.......it beautiful and so apt...........it said it all...........

nope edward is most at fault...if he had never left, bella wouldnt have needed jake...and jake wouldnt have loved bella...so at the core, ed is at fault

i don't think its my poor edward's fault maybe alittle but all edward wanted to do is to protect bella

Originally posted by: muqualp

nope edward is most at fault...if he had never left, bella wouldnt have needed jake...and jake wouldnt have loved bella...so at the core, ed is at fault

Edward is the last person that should be blamed!! He only left stupid Bella because he loved her wanted her to be safe..