Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 19 - Page 119

I dont get why people are forgetting that Mannat is going through this heartbreak since a few days as compared to Vik whose is only a day old. She has got enough time to process her feelings and be passive.

Vik had been blowing hot and cold ever since he realized he loves her (the M necklace) First took up that boss persona and irritated her till Anu's engagement night... Mannat would have accepted him if he had finished his proposal that night...

But post that event Mannat is going through a lot of trauma which is compounded by Viks fake proposal situation. He is stuck in his own dream world. While Mannat has not got time to process. Theres always an emergent task ahead of her.

Vik proposed to Malla in front of Mannat... Malla later took a promise from her that she wont come in between Vik and Malla. And Mannat was following that till Aish told her the truth and Vik confessed.

But Aish only told her Viks side of things... whereas Malla told her that she has developed feelings for Vik... which is same as what she told Vik in the kaand night...

Mannat over the period of time has repeatedly told him what she expects out of him if he wishes to have a relationship with her and why she cant express... but Vik is stuck on hearing ILU from her.

Mannat had not refused the possibility of the relationship ever... just that her terms dont match with Viks.

Right now Mannat has created a wall around her where even though she might have feelings for Vik... she wont express them aloud since she believes Malla loves him and is now married to Malla ... she had been slowly building them with each rasm and each humiliation that came her way!!!!

The game is what Malla has played with both... even if Vik repeats again and again that it was a prank... Malla has told both that she now feels differently for him... the story matches....

Malla has trapped Vik in a sham marriage and Mannat in emotions.

Both Mannat and Vik would be in guilt ... Vik for pushing Malla down the path and not ending this prank soonerand Mannat for not accepting Vik... until and unless Mallas farce comes out.

Only then can they both be free of the shackles Malla has trapped them into.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

1 person on X not trusting Gagan. Reason is understandable though.

Padhke mujhey stress ho rha hai ab🥲

https://x.com/nakshat_rohini/status/1940031457533075739?t=rwneYLHAslJztWbaz-kxQw&s=19

See Mezbaani does not belong to mannat .. and Gagan had made the legal papers which Mannat got signed from Aishwarya ..

Mannat as it is wont take Mezbaani.. she would have written back the shares to him by now ..

She just wants back up support .. and he needs to over throw aishwarya .. so let’s see .. I foresee Gagan getting killed

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Thank you for all the tags behno 🫂 mere 2 Paisa kaa questions more than answers

Mannat cried when Vikrant proposed to Malla, this is it. They have always emphasized how Mannat turns on/off her emotions in a split second. The only guilt she had was of lying to him, but then again, Vikrant married Malla with in 24 hours. Wouldn't it be unethical if she is shown pining for a married man?

Vikrant's character has always been established to have blind trust & support for S and R families barring 1 or 2 incidents. There were so many red flags during the wedding ceremonies, some of which hurt Mannat, but then it was Malla so he let it go.

We could also debate Vikrant never trusts Mannat even with proof, why did he believe Mannat is a gold digger instantly and compare this to the ONS, where he didn't doubt Malla though he knows she wasn't drunk.

I don't believe there is scope for common sense anymore. Why else would they rely on symbolism and deities just to make fun of all of them in the end. Not to forget Malla getting rewarded for doing exactly what Bobby has done.

😴😴😴 Wrote too much and need a nap now

Agree with you. But if they wanted to establish this trust issue between them then writers could’ve taken Neetu’s exposure route. They could’ve brought up his past in to the picture. Last time also we had this discussion when his truth comes out. It will be the last of him not trusting Mannat. If writers wanted they could’ve shown Neetu getting exposed and Vikrant realising his mistake for not trusting Mannat. Why insert this wedding drama with Malla? It could’ve build trust in ManVik relationship specially from Vikrant’s side. Then they could’ve brought up this ARS/Sonia reveal and Vikrant by her side being her BKB. It would’ve made sense. Actually it would’ve been better to take that route instead this. TBH I was not convinced with Mukta’s post about Sachi Mohobbat. Vikrant loves her truly there is no doubt. If it was about trust then it would’ve made sense. But TBH looks like she herself don’t know what to show. Now he is married to her friend and she is supposed to make him understand about his true love which is Mannat. God! Ethically and morally it sounds gross🤬. Though Malla is wrong but to show this itself is disgusting 🤬.

About Vikrant I am really mad at writers for showing him like this. Trusting everyone blindly but not Mannat🤬.

These writers need to learn from KA writers though they also butchered their show at the end but they never compromised on trust factor of KaViaan. Viaan’s trust on Katha was unshakable. Though she was engaged to another man, was staying with him in the same house but he never doubted her love for him. If any other ML would’ve been at his place he would’ve at least got angry or questioned her but Viaan never did that. He knew she loves him and there must be a reason she is doing all this. Why these writers can’t show this here? How easily Vikrant believed Mannat’s lie? Okay now he himself is in shock but I really hope they will show us his introspection in coming episodes and him at least having some doubts about it🤞

I watched today's episode - only scenes with Mannat, ARS and Shruti

The scene in the hospital is very goood. Mannat treats ARS with disgust. And at the end, when ARS says to herself, that noone gets away with putting me down...I was wondering how did Mannat put her down. It's because Mannt keeps showing her disgust and even said, she wishes she was not her daughter.

Sonia felt put down...I enjoyed it.

I could not bring myself to watch the scenes with Vikrant, Salujas, Keerat. Vikrant is surrounded by people who want to control him, noone cares for his happiness. Ronnie who knows his so well, doe snot even give him time to breath. At least, he could have said, the marriage will happen in two days.

I really wish he would question Mallika...she was not drunk and she was with him, consensually, how could she continue ? When she knew, between the two of them, it was always very clear, Vikrant had always told her, he does not feel anything for her. How could she continue? She has cheated him. How is he not questioning her??

Ultimately from day 1, it is always SOnia who brings Manvik together. Every thing she did against Mannat, was defeated by Vikrant, and at each step they only got closer. Mannat is leaving with her mom, ARS is going to try to kill them both, and Mannat will be back, into SM!

The writers have messed up with this marriage. I hope they move quickly and resolve this first. Malla 's track officially started with the fake proposal, it's been a month. Maybe 15 days more ?? Please...

I am finally starting to realize the show is showing what the initial promos tried to tell us. It is all about social status and why ARS left Mannat to die. Social status will get you blind support and trust from anyone, no proofs needed.

Look at all which happened since Bobby track started and you will notice unconscious bias against characters who are below the social status even from characters portrayed as "positive".

Imagine Mannat in the ONS scene, or Mannat in the party drunk or watch the reaction of SM folks to Keerat accusing Neetu vs Mannat. Mannat is right, it's all about social status.

Just wanted to say this after watching Gagan and Mannat BTS.

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

You mean this? https://www.serialgossip.com/mannat-har-khushi-paane-ki-big-plan-reveals-with-vikrant-and-mannat-already-married-114071-a

Yeh log upcoming articles ke name pe FF likhte hai. They have their office in Uttar Pradesh with no reporters in Mumbai.

How on earth did you discover this fact??

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

yaar I agree with you , I am not denying with mannath suffering... But @bold this is the main point .... Till now we thought mannath love vikranth which is also true as per her dialogues in few episodes but also the way she is reacting and ready to leave him without second thought, it does feel there is no love.... It looks like she care for him + little attached that's it ...

I am telling again and again the fake plan of vikranth is horrible and I believe he should come out of this mess himself... I am not expecting mannath to come and save him but thinking twice before leaving him... Trying to tell him truth of ars and malla would have been better....

Saving vikranth after accident is humanity same as vikranth did for mannath... The person mannath is would have / did same thing for Shruthi also ....

But don't you think she tried alot more for Shalini whose is not even her friend compared to Vikranth who is second most important person of her life

Shalini was raped .. the intended victim was Mannat .. Shalini was made to stay back for Mannat .. it’s bad karma to let anyone else suffer for you

So Mannat tried her level best to give her justice she could have shrugged off and focused on Shruti .. no one would have blamed her .. but Bobby would have attacked Mannat next

Sunita got killed because of Sonia targeting Mannat .. the moment sunita got killed .. Mannat got the important info that aishwarya is behind all this and she knows her birth mother

so thinking about Vikrant’s proposal and his mother drugging him became side plots in the story ..

Let’s see how they take the story further .. something will trigger Vikrant to remember his past .. and Raveena will get him disowned .. then Keerat will tell Malla to divorce Vikrant because Aishwarya knew this from before .. so these are possibilities

Originally posted by: truptishree

Agree with you. But if they wanted to establish this trust issue between them then writers could’ve taken Neetu’s exposure route. They could’ve brought up his past in to the picture. Last time also we had this discussion when his truth comes out. It will be the last of him not trusting Mannat. If writers wanted they could’ve shown Neetu getting exposed and Vikrant realising his mistake for not trusting Mannat. Why insert this wedding drama with Malla? It could’ve build trust in ManVik relationship specially from Vikrant’s side. Then they could’ve brought up this ARS/Sonia reveal and Vikrant by her side being her BKB. It would’ve made sense. Actually it would’ve been better to take that route instead this. TBH I was not convinced with Mukta’s post about Sachi Mohobbat. Vikrant loves her truly there is no doubt. If it was about trust then it would’ve made sense. But TBH looks like she herself don’t know what to show. Now he is married to her friend and she is supposed to make him understand about his true love which is Mannat. God! Ethically and morally it sounds gross🤬. Though Malla is wrong but to show this itself is disgusting 🤬.

About Vikrant I am really mad at writers for showing him like this. Trusting everyone blindly but not Mannat🤬.

These writers need to learn from KA writers though they also butchered their show at the end but they never compromised on trust factor of KaViaan. Viaan’s trust on Katha was unshakable. Though she was engaged to another man, was staying with him in the same house but he never doubted her love for him. If any other ML would’ve been at his place he would’ve at least got angry or questioned her but Viaan never did that. He knew she loves him and there must be a reason she is doing all this. Why these writers can’t show this here? How easily Vikrant believed Mannat’s lie? Okay now he himself is in shock but I really hope they will show us his introspection in coming episodes and him at least having some doubts about it🤞

👍🏻👌well articulated !!

Kya introspection, he is in hulk mode in destroying and crying on mama's lap...chalo yeh bhi dekhte 🤪😝