Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 19 - Page 109

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Does ARS know that Mannat has not recorded anything?

She is told by Mannat herself..when ARS picks up the phone of hers silently thinking she doesn't know but Mannu not only tells her the phone password but also makes her listen to Maa song and says she never recorded it...

https://x.com/rubiiiii_18/status/1939885829167731041?s=46

Lagta hai shadi k baad ab reception kalesh ki baari hai

Or is it an old one from the Anu’s engagement track?

Originally posted by: Moor278

The way I see it...

Vikrant himself believes he is capable of this... because of his obvious feelings for Mannat... from Cools update yesterday... it seems he was immediately convinced when Malla dropped this bomb that he imagined Mannat.

I feel it will be only Mannat or her conviction which can hit through his muddled brain that he won't do it...

Uske liye Mannat has to know first ki ye hua hai... and she also has to see that Malla is not exactly what she portrays...

So I suppose... 3-4 weeks for this truth to come out for Mannat ... 2 weeks min if TRP dips

Tab tak MVS MVS MVS suno

Ditto ditto 🥲

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Yes when she played the recording it played the Maa song …. Which Mannat said she sings that with Shruthi all the time!

This doesn't add up...

Call it my shipper heart... but something is amiss...

Did they add this later so that Mannat now has a reason to stay in SM??? Out of fear of her and Shrutis life???

It didn't look like Mannat was bluffing on the seashore... and why would she who knows Vik wont believe her without proof or ARS who manipulates the truth... not have a recording????

There are some glaring loopholes now!!!!! Few of the BTS and articles have not made it to the episode at all...

Is it possible ViMal was not meant to happen... and there would be a last minute stop from Mannat Ekta style???? But then they changed tracks at the last minute???

If the article is true (about this being a secret plan) which I dont think is possible myself... these little discrepancies would come out then I suppose 🙄

Originally posted by: Moor278

This doesn't add up...

Call it my shipper heart... but something is amiss...

Did they add this later so that Mannat now has a reason to stay in SM??? Out of fear of her and Shrutis life???

It didn't look like Mannat was bluffing on the seashore... and why would she who knows Vik wont believe her without proof or ARS who manipulates the truth... not have a recording????

There are some glaring loopholes now!!!!! Few of the BTS and articles have not made it to the episode at all...

Is it possible ViMal was meant to happen... and there would be a last minute stop from Mannat Ekta style???? But then they changed tracks at the last minute???

If the article is true (about this being a secret plan) which I dont think is possible myself... these little discrepancies would come out then I suppose 🙄

@bold because at that point she didn’t know that Vikku loves her. She’d left Saluja mansion feeling dejected when he again shouted and misbehaved with her at the behest of his mother. And after that she got news of Shruti’s deteriorating health. I don’t think her motive ever was to bring out ARS’s truth in front of vikku. He was quite irrelevant to her atp! So it could well easily be a bluff given her motive was to save Shruti and not expose ARS!

As far as return to SM is concerned, she mentioned in the BTS that she wants to keep her enemies closer and take revenge for again trying to harm her & her Shruti maa despite the fact they were peacefully leaving the city as per their agreement!

Originally posted by: Resham

She is told by Mannat herself..when ARS picks up the phone of hers silently thinking she doesn't know but Mannu not only tells her the phone password but also makes her listen to Maa song and says she never recorded it...

The only person who will believe Vikrant at this point is Mannat.

Mannat went and made sure he got his license back for Mezbaani. She is soo protective about him. She didn't want to tell him about Neetu because it would hurt him. She was trying to get Neetu to stop giving him the pills.

She trusted him with the CD...when the CD got lost.

So even now if she gets to know or if he tells her, she will stand by him. And she will look for proof.

But unfortunately, Vikrant needs to take a huge leap of faith with her ...(without any proof ). And that has always been the problem. Will he believe her?

He always needs proof from Mannat. When Mannat showed Bobby's necklace, he was willing to call the police. But when the twin necklace showed up, he stepped back.

I don't know why he has this aberration, that he only trusts his family and by association, everyone around his family or whoever his family trusts. At this point, he trusts Malla more than anyone else.

Even after she told him, she let him go on because she fell in love, it has not struck him that she took advantage??

Can they not show him asking her at least one question...we can get married but what you did was wrong, especially when I trusted you as a friend. If the gender was reversed, and a male friend did the same, it is a breach of trust.

It is hard to justify this marriage or Vikrant's behaviour to not even question Malla. This kind of unwavering faith he should have on Mannat, but he doesn't.

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

@bold because at that point she didn’t know that Vikku loves her. She’d left Saluja mansion feeling dejected when he again shouted and misbehaved with her at the behest of his mother. And after that she got news of Shruti’s deteriorating health. I don’t think her motive ever was to bring out ARS’s truth in front of vikku. He was quite irrelevant to her atp! So it could well easily be a bluff given her motive was to save Shruti and not expose ARS!

As far as return to SM is concerned, she mentioned in the BTS that she wants to keep her enemies closer and take revenge for again trying to harm her & her Shruti maa despite the fact they were peacefully leaving the city as per their agreement!

Bold..

Yes..... I dont think she wanted to bring out ARSs truth either... in that same scene she acknowledged that she wants nothing from ARS except the liver..

I am not saying to show it to Vik... but that scene itself had repeated mentions from both how no one will believe her without proofs... Vik was mentioned as example by Aish...

I am wondering from that perspective... doing a recording to blackmail ARS till she gets the liver is completely logical... baad main delete Kar de...

On that note I now recall another BTS where Aish asks her mobile phone in hospital to delete the recording. 🙄

Originally posted by: Moor278

The way I see it...

Vikrant himself believes he is capable of this... because of his obvious feelings for Mannat... from Cools update yesterday... it seems he was immediately convinced when Malla dropped this bomb that he imagined Mannat.

I feel it will be only Mannat or her conviction which can hit through his muddled brain that he won't do it...

Uske liye Mannat has to know first ki ye hua hai... and she also has to see that Malla is not exactly what she portrays...

So I suppose... 3-4 weeks for this truth to come out for Mannat ... 2 weeks min if TRP dips

Tab tak MVS MVS MVS suno

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

I am so irritated to hear MVS in BTS itself

Desperate churail