Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 19 - Page 108

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Does ARS know that Mannat has not recorded anything?

Yes when she played the recording it played the Maa song …. Which Mannat said she sings that with Shruthi all the time!

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Yes when she played the recording it played the Maa song …. Which Mannat said she sings that with Shruthi all the time!

Thats why she had to agree to ARS's condition.

Originally posted by: moonwearer

Every time Mannat has stepped in to do good to others Vikrath either on his own accord or pushed by others demands a proof of Mannat. She is also cornered by Im The BOSS .or yelled and screamed at by Neetu. She has been insulted, slapped, pushed out and several attempts on her life have been made. We as viewers were so fed up with the happenings in Saluja Mansion AKA as mad house that we wished Mannat would leave.

Vikrant by turning a deaf ear, blind eye and not standing up for the lady he claims to love has obviously exasperated Mannat.

After the death of Sunitha she must definitely be worried for the safety of her Shrutima. She has tried to live up to her side of the deal. She was justified in attempting to leave the city under compulsion last time by Vikrant and this time by ARS. But due to the doings os ARS and her henchmen she does return stung by the deviant ways of ARS. Vikrant is no hapless young person that needs a fairy to protect him provided he uses his head which he seems to have misplaced somewhere.

Yaar even in Shalini track mei a lot more happend to her but she took all that for justice or Shalini

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

yaar no one is saying mannath should stand infront of vikranth to protect him.... A scene where she is feeling for vikranth, her dilemma to leave the city for vikranth... Would be good .. this would have made lot of difference. Are she didn't even try to tell him ars and malla are manipulating him ( woh believe karega ya nahi is secondary)

Yaar even in Shalini track mei a lot more happend to her but she took all that for justice or Shalini

Yess you're right,even in anguish she informed everything to him in Shalini’s case though he didn’t believe her till the end..Here she is behaving weirdly and not caring for him, not showing any feelings..She knew now that it was a fake proposal planned by Malla and himself, then why was malla manipulated her to stay away from him..Mannat is also shown not applying her brains..Both the leads are brainless in this track, only nalla is playing smart in her foul game ...

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

yaar no one is saying mannath should stand infront of vikranth to protect him.... A scene where she is feeling for vikranth, her dilemma to leave the city for vikranth... Would be good .. this would have made lot of difference. Are she didn't even try to tell him ars and malla are manipulating him ( woh believe karega ya nahi is secondary)

Yaar even in Shalini track mei a lot more happend to her but she took all that for justice or Shalini

Yaa i get you hey. At some point when some people were saying she doesn't even seem affected that Vikrant is marrying Malla i was supporting saying she has probably blocked her emotions but now her continuously distancing herself from Vikrant this way despite the challenges in place and her knowing how much he loves her and leaving him to the wolves when he has been her BKB is not coming across well.

But maybe based on Shruti's interview we may be in store for a flashback scene tomorrow coz in her interview she did say she told Mannat running away is not the solution. She needs to stand and fight as she is now aware Mannat loves Vikrant.

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Yess you're right,even in anguish she informed everything to him in Shalini’s case though he didn’t believe her till the end..Here she is behaving weirdly and not caring for him, not showing any feelings..She knew now that it was a fake proposal planned by Malla and himself, then why was malla manipulated her to stay away from him..Mannat is also shown not applying her brains..Both the leads are brainless in this track, only nalla is playing smart in her foul game ...

I think it's hard to compare Mannat fighting for Shalini vs Mannat fighting for Vikrant. And in my opinion, it has a lot to do with the power dynamics and social status of the two. In Shalini's case, Mannat went the extra mile for her, because in some ways she had also experienced an almost assault when she moved into the shady crawl after being thrown out of her burnt home. Also, ARS used her position as Shalini's boss, kidnapped her brother, threatened to release clips of the assault to get Shalini to do her bidding practically rendering her helpless needing Mannat to fully go all in for her instead.

In Vikrant's case, he is fully capable of fighting for himself with equal footing and power. So, there is only a certain extent Mannat can fight for him. If he doesn't trust her or put in the effort to actually fight for himself or try to find out what is going on around him when there's ample evidence that something is amiss, there really isn't much Mannat can do. It is not like Vikrant did not know about the fake engagement, he agreed to it ... he participated in all the functions that were taking place.

That being said, I do think they could have done a better job with showing Mannat realizing her feelings towards Vikrant and how it affects her.

I think despite knowing Vikku loves her, she’d be shown choosing not to act on it simply because his lack of trust on her. She’s been hurt by his callous attitude in this track and with him siding with his mother without giving an ear to what Mannat had to say would always act as a road block b/w her & vikku. Who’s to guarantee that Neetu won’t harass her even more post them getting together?

She probably thought to move on instead of investing into a relationship which had no further given the unequal power dynamics and shaky trust on each other!

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

The gist of today’s episode is in Ronnie’s dialogue—- galti jitni badi hoti hai sazah use bhi badi

ARS was defeated had to donate liver due to her own mistakes rather crime against Mannat

Vikrant is paying the price of proposing Malla and then going ahead with his plan. Ronnie was not having any reasons and rightly so.

This dialogue will play out when everyone finds out Malla and ARSs true crimes and I hope Malla specifically pays a hefty price.

I am busy this morning so will update everyone later in yhe afternoon. Abhi keh liye Vikrant koh chod doh … he is paying the price as we all told gadha hai Malla keh plan meh believe karke propose kiya. Poor guy is just in love with Mannat and is heart broken at the same time, leave him alone!

Malla and Sonia Khanna are your true villain and ab Dadi bhi add hui hai…. Dadi bhi kam nahi thi aaj.

Ditto to every word

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

yaar no one is saying mannath should stand infront of vikranth to protect him.... A scene where she is feeling for vikranth, her dilemma to leave the city for vikranth... Would be good .. this would have made lot of difference. Are she didn't even try to tell him ars and malla are manipulating him ( woh believe karega ya nahi is secondary)

Yaar even in Shalini track mei a lot more happend to her but she took all that for justice or Shalini

I dont mind this, as long as they imply she doesn’t love him yet or has not realized her feelings.

But they randomly give her dialogues that imply otherwise.

I am telling you there are more than one writers who dont talk to each other. Jiska jo man kare likh raha

PS: Vikrant coming out of this on his own will help salvage him better than Mannat fighting for him.