Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 6 - Page 94

Originally posted by: KarwaChothThali

Note: mentions of Ayesha’s previous show to answer this, because I think it is connected to issue of expectations from Mannat’s character. Not intending to get into lost debate.

Maine to pehle bhi bola hae- I am not at all looking for Sai Joshi here. To be honest majority had issue there with ML not being available to FL needs and deprioritizing her and still we had to ‘accept’ that he loved her. And yes Sai faought all alone but it all did break her to a point of complete breakdown. Didnt we all wish for her to have a friend and companion who was there for her?

Vikrant is doing what majority wanted Certain sm1 did for Sai.

Here atleast one thing is established that Vikrant and mannat has cosmic connection and he can not see Mannat in trouble. She is not some forced responsibility that he claim he loves as it fits his needs and vadas. Its easy to accept ML when he is shown to support FL vs ‘assume’ that he loves her while she struggles and fights all her battles alone(including a miscarriage in love marriage, how absurd was that?)

Vikrant is Mannat ki life ka BDB, that was established in first episode - That is premise of story. As long as it is executed well- I am all in for it.
Mera problem execution and pace se hae.

Gyan:

We are human and everyone needs a support, be it from parent, friends, spouse etc- some may be more and some less. Some may learn to be strong by being with others- Mannat is probably that person. She was only fed about someone will come and be her savior by Shruti, may be with Vikrant by her side, she finds her strength.

Also I am happy Ayesha took quite an opposite role to Sai- I do want Ayesha to explore different characters. It was an adjustment in beginning, since my connect for Sai was too strong. But she got hold of Mannat’s character and Vikrant alongside, made it easy to accept.

PS: Lost never gave good closure to S and her sufferings and most fans were connected to that character and probably still looking for that. Unless we accept that she was hopelessly in love w man who didn’t deserve her, we will never get closure. I came to terms w this fact and moved on.

Can I just say I love you 🫂

Bold 💯 💯 power to n why I started watching the show. So many times I hoped lost will show her mental breakdown which never happened. The trauma she went through was unimaginable and not go through a breakdown even for the strongest person.

I am so so glad they are not showing Mannat as super human and takes Vikrant's help, guidance and doesn't shy away from crying or telling him her deep fears and insecurities. This is what a normal human would act like.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Oh.. so you think Mannat nahi lekin Shalini ka bhai kidnap hoga .... ARS ke Raj main ho sakta hai

Shemer and Uma were saying there's another BTS where Mannat is going to Vik it seems.

As per IF article Vik sides with Shalini and as per previous BTS Vik is absent when the chori kaand is happening.

So will he support Shalini only because Ms. Mannat is saying so??? 🤔

Vikrant will soon be like ‘Mannat ne bola hae to hae’

Read it as Ankhe movie ‘delnaz ne bola ‘ tone

Vikrant kyaa chance pe dance maar Raha hain in the wiping tears scene 😍

https://x.com/KRadhaa49285/status/1903793928832499959?t=p6YDfHlg_I7ONpEMQYUQTQ&s=19

Originally posted by: KarwaChothThali

Note: mentions of Ayesha’s previous show to answer this, because I think it is connected to issue of expectations from Mannat’s character. Not intending to get into lost debate.

Maine to pehle bhi bola hae- I am not at all looking for Sai Joshi here. To be honest majority had issue there with ML not being available to FL needs and deprioritizing her and still we had to ‘accept’ that he loved her. And yes Sai faought all alone but it all did break her to a point of complete breakdown. Didnt we all wish for her to have a friend and companion who was there for her?

Vikrant is doing what majority wanted Certain sm1 did for Sai.

Here atleast one thing is established that Vikrant and mannat has cosmic connection and he can not see Mannat in trouble. She is not some forced responsibility that he claim he loves as it fits his needs and vadas. Its easy to accept ML when he is shown to support FL vs ‘assume’ that he loves her while she struggles and fights all her battles alone(including a miscarriage in love marriage, how absurd was that?)

Vikrant is Mannat ki life ka BDB, that was established in first episode - That is premise of story. As long as it is executed well- I am all in for it.
Mera problem execution and pace se hae.

Gyan:

We are human and everyone needs a support, be it from parent, friends, spouse etc- some may be more and some less. Some may learn to be strong by being with others- Mannat is probably that person. She was only fed about someone will come and be her savior by Shruti, may be with Vikrant by her side, she finds her strength.

Also I am happy Ayesha took quite an opposite role to Sai- I do want Ayesha to explore different characters. It was an adjustment in beginning, since my connect for Sai was too strong. But she got hold of Mannat’s character and Vikrant alongside, made it easy to accept.

PS: Lost never gave good closure to S and her sufferings and most fans were connected to that character and probably still looking for that. Unless we accept that she was hopelessly in love w man who didn’t deserve her, we will never get closure. I came to terms w this fact and moved on.

Absolutely agree with this one.....💯💯💯💯

Sai and Mannat is polar opposite characters..In lost Sai didn't get any justice aur support till the end...

And here mannat has vikrant with her from the first episode..and I hope ye last tak aisa hi rahee....yes I agree that FL should be strong and not behave like a doormat ..but in certain situations everyone needs some help and a shoulder to lean on ..we all are human beings with emotions and weakness not some wonderwomen....and here mannat ka support system is vikrant...the makers established this fact from the beginning...ARS is her hurdle and vikrant is her saviour....tired of seeing FL doing all kind of jobs like a wonderwomen and ML who has no opinion of his own and act like a pendulum...hope hamara ManVik hamesha aise saath milkar sabse ladeee 🥰

I'm glad ayesha took this role ❤

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Makes sense of how we are used to things being a certain way in ITV and wish things take the same route.Do you think we contradict as viewers by asking for something new if we want the same thing to be served with new faces ?

Bold- 💯 love couples who are there for each other, several scenes last week which established this 🤩. With Holika track how Mannat saves Shruti by herself, felt this was established .Vikrant is there only when needed until then they are not bringing him in.

Italic - oh wow the montage changed kyaa, didn't realize

@bold... no don't think so... Haven't watched much ITV... but from the ones I have seen... I think it's how the story is built up... how the leads are connected to each other.. story wise.

In Mannat, it's primarily a story of her and her biological mom. Vikrant is Mannats support.

Yeah... Holika was exactly that... Vik came in only when required. Same with the goon attack. Mannat managed on her own until she couldn't and asked for help from one person she knew would help her.

In hotstar ... The montage is Vik holding an umbrella for her. She stands independently... Don't know about TV.

Originally posted by: Moor278

@bold... no don't think so... Haven't watched much ITV... but from the ones I have seen... I think it's how the story is built up... how the leads are connected to each other.. story wise.

In Mannat, it's primarily a story of her and her biological mom. Vikrant is Mannats support.

Yeah... Holika was exactly that... Vik came in only when required. Same with the goon attack. Mannat managed on her own until she couldn't and asked for help from one person she knew would help her.

In hotstar ... The montage is Vik holding an umbrella for her. She stands independently... Don't know about TV.

Meine zyaada ITV nahee dekha par after lost took a long break like Ayesha to get over the trauma of that show . Usee pehla the last show I invested was naa bole tum naa Maine huch kaha on colors

I get absolutely confused when viewers ask for leads to behave a certain way from previous shows or characters or story to take a turn in a certain way from other shows. It's like we are not giving the makers a chance to show something different and then complain when they follow the suit of other shows. No wonder whole Sitara shows are rinse and repeat of their own shows

And finally Bold is what I am here for and hopefully they serve us what was promised 🤩

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Your papa did a good thing warna you would have still been in that world wondering what's happening

Yhhh..I'm glad that he did it...bachaya mereko from a lifetime trauma

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Question seeing so many comments that finally Mannat will fight alone without Vikrant's help.

Trying to understand why anyone has to fight alone and what is wrong in taking help of someone from same gender or opposite gender. What am I missing here 🧐. Are we confusing feminism Yaa Kuch aur chal Raha hain which I am missing 🤔

All answers welcome, kyunki Mein sach Mein Janna chaahatee hoon

After being traumatised by lost, I don’t care about feminism on ITV given the creatives have a very twisted view of strong female.

As long as the FL isn’t a doormat/sacrificial lamb and there’s a hot ML who’s not bhabhi/chachi/mummy lover, I’m happy. Thoda angst aur bahut saara romance de do, apun khush

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Question seeing so many comments that finally Mannat will fight alone without Vikrant's help.

Trying to understand why anyone has to fight alone and what is wrong in taking help of someone from same gender or opposite gender. What am I missing here 🧐. Are we confusing feminism Yaa Kuch aur chal Raha hain which I am missing 🤔

All answers welcome, kyunki Mein sach Mein Janna chaahatee hoon

Million Dollar Question….

I also don’t understand why why why Mannat cannot take help from Vikrant! It doesn’t make her weak it’s human to ask for help. This is also such a farce behind the so called feminist agenda.

It’s like they want the FL to suffer and fight alone … they cannot accept the fact that there are really “Good” men in the world and yes they care!

Oh well…. I for one want another punch from Vikrant!! 🤣 kya dhasu punch tha Puneet koh!

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

After being traumatised by lost, I don’t care about feminism on ITV given the creatives have a very twisted view of strong female.

As long as the FL isn’t a doormat/sacrificial lamb and there’s a hot ML who’s not bhabhi/chachi/mummy lover, I’m happy. Thoda angst aur bahut saara romance de do, apun khush

Kyaa kah rahee hon , woh feminism thaa lost mein. Nakko re baba aisa feminism

💯 Shat parishad on 2nd paragraph