CID Episode 3 Body in the red suitcase - 28th December - Page 8

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Yes they won't make Daya Shreya together again for sure(unless they go the route you mentioned which I genuinely hope they don't), but what I meant was Shreya is still the heroine of Daya even if their love story didn't reach a final/ happy conclusion. I mean won't you say that Paro was the heroine of Devdas? I feel they shouldn't get any other girl for Daya now with a statement like my love is happy in her life and I am contented seeing her so.

ACP's wife was shown in the very first few episodes. Later the actress(not the character) came in as a criminal in another episode, so we joke that ACP's son and wife both became criminals.

To be honest I liked Daya and Shreya love story (also enjoyed bit Abhijeet Tarika flirting though it got annoying often), what I disliked was the entire story they made for Shreya and Sidharth. I mean it's a crime show, why make it a family drama including. Every episode those days had Daya/Shreya or Abhijeet thinking about what will happen to the other person. That was so unlike CID

You are right, maybe people connect is the reason they aren't giving them promotions

Originally posted by: Ashly_Ansalam

Now ACP have a Grandson, Abhijeet have an adopted daughter and Shreya is imprisoned for treason and she mentioned that she have little baby who had been kidnapped by Eye Gang. If CID saved the kid, then Daya also can have an adopted kid.

Daya has an adopted daughter Divya. She was his friend's daughter who was killed by her husband. He also tried to kill Divya but she escaped. At the end Daya said that she is his daughter henceforth, but she was never shown again. Even ACP's grandson hasn't been shown later.

But about Shreya's child, why would she be with Daya even if they saved the child? Her father is there, nothing showed that Sidhant was evil. Also her grand parents are there.

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Daya has an adopted daughter Divya. She was his friend's daughter who was killed by her husband. He also tried to kill Divya but she escaped. At the end Daya said that she is his daughter henceforth, but she was never shown again. Even ACP's grandson hasn't been shown later.

But about Shreya's child, why would she be with Daya even if they saved the child? Her father is there, nothing showed that Sidhant was evil. Also her grand parents are there.

But really Daya personally adopted her like Abhijeet?

Originally posted by: Ashly_Ansalam

Yeah. Thanks for reminding me about Daya's adopted daughter. The first episode of Kaveri & Lavanya.

But really Daya personally adopted her like Abhijeet?

Yes the same episode.

That's what they showed. He clearly said aaj k baad ye meri beti hai.

Baaki legal process to kisi ka nhi dikhaya

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Yes the same episode.

That's what they showed. He clearly said aaj k baad ye meri beti hai.

Baaki legal process to kisi ka nhi dikhaya

Originally posted by: SoniRita

i agree, that new male officer i m not liking too. Avni is good though

Yup. Avni is good; and there is a great potential for more improvement. I have hopes from here.

That guy should permanently stay away in my opinion. He gave me the same vibes as that officer Suraj, but more subtle ones.

Originally posted by: MJ_1009

i kinda will agree...i mean, sure mistakes do occur but i feel the execution might've be done bit better...maybe thoda aur better execute karte...what i dont like is i feel purvi is shown more serious than pankaj despite them being on the same level so it sets off the bar of having more expectations from purvi than pankaj...pankaj does have good capabiliites but i feel more is expected from purvi than pankaj..

Exactly. Mistakes do occur. After all, everyone is human there and it's human nature to make mistakes.

But at the same time, an experienced officer making such a juvenile mistake looks weird. It's not like in all these years they have never been involved in keeping tabs on suspicious individuals. And never before have they shown any one of them making such mistakes of relaxing vigilance because they felt sympathy for that suspicious person. I could have still digested Avni making such a mistake because she is new. But Purvi (and Pankaj too) has been there for how many years? After all these years, showing her making such an erroneous judgement looks weird.

Originally posted by: Nikita_99503

Yup. Avni is good; and there is a great potential for more improvement. I have hopes from here.

That guy should permanently stay away in my opinion. He gave me the same vibes as that officer Suraj, but more subtle ones.

I'm trying a new thought process here...I decided that it might be easier - to decide whether to watch the episode or not.

Some gems (I want to highlight these first because...they're hilarious!) :

1. Mocking Hindi movies - yeh koi Hindi picture nahi jisme hero kapde badal kar, hairstyle badal kar, ghumta hai toh heroine usse pehchanti nahi. I just need to leave this gem here. This gem deserves a point of its own.
2. The use of AI to build the face into a man's - it's a small thing but at least it made more sense than the previous season when they would touch a few buttons on the keyboard and face swaps would be done instantly on Paint.
3. Abhijeet and Daya with the autowala and with the medical shopwala. These 2 scenes are priceless. The duo is back! The entire exchange with the medical shopwala especially reminded me of Mouse Trap and the exchanges between Dada and Pakya there. Arre bhaisaab. Yeh mera dost hai naa iska chehra dekh dekh ke main bahut bore ho gaya hoon. Kuch aisi dawai di jiye jisse yeh shakal surat you know badal jaaye. And then Abhijeet's fake pissed off expression. WHERE ARE OUR CREATORS??? I NEED A NEW GIF!!!
4. The conclusion and ACP sir comparing the case to a Hindi serial. Man this PH has got no filter. Sab ki band baja rahe hain.
5. Purvi calling Abhijeet khadoos at the end and Daya enjoying it. Arre stop it PH. Please stop it. Kitna hasaonge? GIF CREATORS PLEASE!!!

The issues/questions:

1. Why is the wife walking around just asking random people if they've seen her husband? I get you're traveling in a train compartment together, but no one keeps even that close of an eye on whose traveling with whom. At least show a photo!
2. And is it common for trains to have 2 police constables in each compartment like that? Seemed a bit too convenient.
3. Is it common for trains to have CCTV? I know that local metros have CCTV, but long distance trains?
4. The Tarika angle again - I was hoping that given they had shown the officers matured, this angle would be dealt with a bit better, but Abhijeet had the same puppy look on his face that he used to have in the first season. New PH please itni si ilteja sun lo - yeh track thoda maturely handle kar lo.
5. Why didn't anyone question if the body was even Alok's??? That was literally the first thought that crossed my mind when they said at the railway station that the face isn't recognizable. Abey it's like murder 101. You crush a face to hide someone's identity! Literally the body could already have been in the suitcase and Bittu just disappeared by getting off at Bhusawal. Then Richa did her acting and that was that. Seriously cannot believe that no one immediately thought of that! It took Dr. Salunkhe telling them that the body is 3 days old for them to get to this point.

The good:

1. I saw some people here talk about the IMM2 meme and I don't agree. The suitcase looks like a typical 21" luggage that goes into the checked baggage on planes. I remember Googling this for a story I had been working on years ago and even at that time there were many examples of where a live adult human had been found in this size suitcase by airport employees and also of adult humans who died in transit. If a live (uncut) human can fold and fit into such a suitcase, then so can a cut up body.
   
2. They clearly show a lock on the suitcase so opening it with a knife makes sense and in a way it shows how police or security deal with problem suitcases. Personally I liked that little bit of attention to detail. It's a small matter, but sure was a nice touch.
3. I like the new maturity and empathic nature that they are showing of the officers. In the last few years of season 1, the officers seemed to lose that and would yell at everyone, even the supposed victims or innocent bystanders. Throughout the episode, this new PH repeatedly showed us moments when the officers were more empathic or mature in certain situations where I was 100% expecting them to yell for no reason. Kudos to the new PH for that. Of course it wasn't 100% of the time, but I'll take what we get.
4. The focus on actual investigation and forensics has improved and increased. Again kudos to the new PH for this because in season 1's last few years, the focus had turned to unnecessarily long intros, long interrogations, and sudden leaps in the investigation.
5. The comedy moments with Pankaj - chalo we're getting something of the first season...the comic Pankaj. He's matured, he's gotten better at investigations, but he's still got his moments.
6. The video connections to discuss the case - damn good move. Instead of repeatedly showing the officers traveling back and forth between their locations, they're finally showing some sensibility of them being in place and providing updates on a conference call. Even CID's gone remote.

Overall verdict: A good episode overall. Some loopholes and some WTF moments, but a lot of gems. I'd give it a 3 out of 5.

I actually liked the episode, i am loving this new PH. The dialogue were funny and too good. Moments between rikshawala and daya-abhi was top notch, the auto wala was too smart haha. And then the whole medicine shop scene omg they made case so interesting

The Purvi- senior officers scene haha epic when she called Abhi khadoos and then Daya was like she called you khadoos haha kya scene tha.

Pankaj is funny, 26 passengers but total 27 passengers so the 1 missing is murderer lmao that scene was too funny.

Abhi asked Salunke sir abt Tarika lmao too good, tarik pe tarik toh tarika ka kab pata chalega

And ACP trolling the serial plot haha too funny.