Would "Abhira" be called Abheera and hated had she been baby Birla?

I am really curious and probably may not believe (or even be able to read) lot of responses.

Still wondering of a few scenarios.. I will never agree that amount of hate fictional character gets and obsession of people with hating her just stems from character herself but mostly because of her history...

Scenario 1: keep it simple

Assume ManRa would have married, they would have a child who became FL of the show... Would Chuhi still get so much of support?

Scenario 2- Like Abhir - Like Abhira...

Baby would have been AkshNav's child by birth but would have been bought up for say 10 years this time by ManRa... And she would have actually called Trashmanyu her papa, and not spoken much about Abhinav at all... Would she still be hated?

Scenario 3 - undo Gen 2

Here we completely write of Chuhi... This is also for AkshNav fans... Had there be two daughters one with Abhinav and after his death, Akshu married and moved on with Trashmanyu... Had a daughter.. BUT..

Twist here is that ManRa bought up Abhira together, their parvarish, and their daughter as soul for let's say 5-10 years ... And Akshara would have been pregnant again with ManRa kid and before she was out in the world her Dad died and mom died during birth... So, she had legit bought up as an orphan cuz well Birlas were on road after Parth's scam...

But you know Manra would be FL and not AkshNav wali Abhira... Cuz you know na.. Rule book says Child of *Leads* is FL.

Scenario 4: Changed scenario

Abhir was indeed Abhira (Girl Child) who was bought up by Akshnav. And after years Akshnavi was born after death of Abhinav.

Abhira was lost after tragic lanslide and grew up on her own.

ManRa raised Akshnavi for 6 years and she was their parvarish.

Basically Biological Swap:

Akshnavi Birla and Abhira Sharma..

And who would have been lead and loved more?

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

I am really curious and probably may not believe (or even be able to read) lot of responses.

Still wondering of a few scenarios.. I will never agree that amount of hate fictional character gets and obsession of people with hating her just stems from character herself but mostly because of her history...

Scenario 1: keep it simple

Assume ManRa would have married, they would have a child who became FL of the show... Would Chuhi still get so much of support?

Scenario 2- Like Abhir - Like Abhira...

Baby would have been AkshNav's child by birth but would have been bought up for say 10 years this time by ManRa... And she would have actually called Trashmanyu her papa, and not spoken much about Abhinav at all... Would she still be hated?

Scenario 3 - undo Gen 2

Here we completely write of Chuhi... This is also for AkshNav fans... Had there be two daughters one with Abhinav and after his death, Akshu married and moved on with Trashmanyu... Had a daughter.. BUT..

Twist here is that ManRa bought up Abhira together, their parvarish, and their daughter as soul for let's say 5-10 years ... And Akshara would have been pregnant again with ManRa kid and before she was out in the world her Dad died and mom died during birth... So, she had legit bought up as an orphan cuz well Birlas were on road after Parth's scam...

But you know Manra would be FL and not AkshNav wali Abhira... Cuz you know na.. Rule book says Child of *Leads* is FL.

Scenario 4: Changed scenario

Abhir was indeed Abhira (Girl Child) who was bought up by Akshnav. And after years Akshnavi was born after death of Abhinav.

Abhira was lost after tragic lanslide and grew up on her own.

ManRa raised Akshnavi for 6 years and she was their parvarish.

Basically Biological Swap:

Akshnavi Birla and Abhira Sharma..

And who would have been lead and loved more?

Sej bohot kuch ho sakta hai but muje guess nahi jarna..Lets read others POV..

But this kind of post Uma answers very well

I hate her for her character, would have hated her even if she had been a Birla, a Singhania or even a Maheshwari had she still been like this.

I don't hate her because of her parentage, I hate her because of what her character has turned into - a clown.

I was discussing about this with someone in another forum. I probably would still dislike Abhira as my main problem is her behaviour and the way she acts not her father who has no relation in this new gen.

For example most Ghum members were Sairat fans yet most of them dislike ‘Badi Savi’ even though she is their daughter solely due to her obnoxious behaviour.

Heck I used to dislike Naira who was OG Akshara ki Beti as I hated her behaviour. She was just too irritating and mahaan. A complete joke after her mother.

This is my viewpoint as a neutral unbiased member

Itna sochna na pade isliye, Har gen main ek hi daughter hoti haa. Mostly I guess whoever is born first

In any scenario, AKshu's firstborn daughter would have been the lead

But I would have loved Abhira, irrespective of who her father was.

People shouldn’t be hating daughter because of her father even though the father was changed at the last minute due to obvious reasons.

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

I am really curious and probably may not believe (or even be able to read) lot of responses.

Still wondering of a few scenarios.. I will never agree that amount of hate fictional character gets and obsession of people with hating her just stems from character herself but mostly because of her history...

Scenario 1: keep it simple

Assume ManRa would have married, they would have a child who became FL of the show... Would Chuhi still get so much of support?

Scenario 2- Like Abhir - Like Abhira...

Baby would have been AkshNav's child by birth but would have been bought up for say 10 years this time by ManRa... And she would have actually called Trashmanyu her papa, and not spoken much about Abhinav at all... Would she still be hated?

Scenario 3 - undo Gen 2

Here we completely write of Chuhi... This is also for AkshNav fans... Had there be two daughters one with Abhinav and after his death, Akshu married and moved on with Trashmanyu... Had a daughter.. BUT..

Twist here is that ManRa bought up Abhira together, their parvarish, and their daughter as soul for let's say 5-10 years ... And Akshara would have been pregnant again with ManRa kid and before she was out in the world her Dad died and mom died during birth... So, she had legit bought up as an orphan cuz well Birlas were on road after Parth's scam...

But you know Manra would be FL and not AkshNav wali Abhira... Cuz you know na.. Rule book says Child of *Leads* is FL.

Scenario 4: Changed scenario

Abhir was indeed Abhira (Girl Child) who was bought up by Akshnav. And after years Akshnavi was born after death of Abhinav.

Abhira was lost after tragic lanslide and grew up on her own.

ManRa raised Akshnavi for 6 years and she was their parvarish.

Basically Biological Swap:

Akshnavi Birla and Abhira Sharma..

And who would have been lead and loved more?

Originally posted by: itsShonali

I hate her for her character, would have hated her even if she had been a Birla, a Singhania or even a Maheshwari had she still been like this.

I don't hate her because of her parentage, I hate her because of what her character has turned into - a clown.

I dislike her coz she does not know where to draw the line in boundaries..she thinks she is helping but it's triggering trauma ..

She says one thing and does not follow when it comes to herself

Running away with some one else kid and then acting as if it was not a mistake when others taunt..u ran away trauma or whatever but u did ..then u need to accept consequences of that action

I feel Abhira is hated simply because she is Akshnav 's daughter. Abhira forgives easily and has people pleasing tendencies but she ain't a proper doormat that most female leads are. Infact, We have had a bigger doormat, her own mother who was absolutely adored till she loved the anti-hero. The moment her mother decided to stand up for herself and fell for a better human, she was hated. I myself am no fan of her and have criticized her many times, but the way she is slt shamed here, I have no words to say.

Calling Abhira Sharma as ugly, kachri, Navri, Bacha chor like her father etc proves my point.

FL is always hated by a section of online viewers because of her long lectures and mahanta syndrome (obviously there are exceptions).

BUT

I'm 100% sure if Abhimanyu-Akshara's biological daughter or even the daughter they raised together (Abhinav-Akshara's biological child) was the FL a small section of online viewers wouldn't have supported cheater, two-timer, manipulator, revengeful girgit like Ruhi over Abhira.

Imagine hating Akshara Sharma because she moved on too quick from one man to another, to find father ji but supporting Ruhi Birla and addressing her wrongdoings as "mistakes" or "triggered by trauma" she literally wanted to get married to jeth g while being a married woman. She wanted to destroy a home with her 7 step plan. If any other character did something like this we would have seen paragraphs condemning their actions.

Ruhi is a fictional character who was/is sabotaged but Akshara & Abhira are not fictional characters?