𝓙𝓱𝓪𝓷𝓪𝓴 Written Update And Episode Discussion Thread 52 - Page 92

Originally posted by: vira76

Read my second post on this… I love you has been just another word for Ani for longest time … isn’t it? We were all so annoyed with “I love you Arshi” before the said I love you to jhanak … he has been very casual about it …

I completely agreed with this!

....

Ye to mne show k starting k waqt bhi kha tha ILU sirf insaan dilse kehta jb feel krta hn. Aisey randomly nhi....ajkl k bachy bhi soch samj kr kehty hn ye words b 😅

Alright now that Anum reminded me of the medicine incident one more trait of Ani Bose

Anirudh Helping someone in need , even if means it’s hurting his loved ones… we all fell in love with this anirudh nose who helped a poor orphan girl. Now that he is raising his voice for Arshi , demanding justice it’s hurting us because well for obvious reasons! When he helped jhanak, he hurt his family members even his parents and his fiancé who he was in relationship with for six long years. We never questioned that time , how can he defend Jhanak a stranger at cost of his fiancé and his family’s emotions … because he was doing the right thing and if was working in our favor , we liked it. But now we question it… so again him blaming Jhanak and going as far as willing to punish her , is it really character assassin? Or is it really old vs new ani… Before it was costing him his relationship with his family , and his fiancé , now it is costing him his relationship with Jhanak! So he has justice ka keeda! God of justice ! Just like jhanak is goddess lf mahanata… this explains to me where there was no “Hichak” in his voice when he said j will pay for her crimes !

Originally posted by: great_love

Beautiful explain ppak...

Same I was trying to explain her but words are coming in flow ...

By the way what's your name?

Priya & yours?

Originally posted by: xnbstar

Ani ko bs thora se doubt aya tha but instantly he corrected k mujhe aisa soch kr bhi bura lgta hn

It's completely makers fault to write the accurate dialogues as per the situation. Kuch bhi likhy jarey hn abhi without any proper justifications.

Audience 90% assume krke apna dil behlati hn...Solid screenplay me aisa to nhi chalta na...

no wrong dialogs...intentionally writing to cause undue irritation from viewers

Originally posted by: vira76

Alright now that Anum reminded me of the medicine incident one more trait of Ani Bose

Anirudh Helping someone in need , even if means it’s hurting his loved ones… we all fell in love with this anirudh nose who helped a poor orphan girl. Now that he is raising his voice for Arshi , demanding justice it’s hurting us because well for obvious reasons! When he helped jhanak, he hurt his family members even his parents and his fiancé who he was in relationship with for six long years. We never questioned that time , how can he defend Jhanak a stranger at cost of his fiancé and his family’s emotions … because he was doing the right thing and if was working in our favor , we liked it. But now we question it… so again him blaming Jhanak and going as far as willing to punish her , is it really character assassin? Or is it really old vs new ani… Before it was costing him his relationship with his family , and his fiancé , now it is costing him his relationship with Jhanak! So he has justice ka keeda! God of justice ! Just like jhanak is goddess lf mahanata…

So Ani saved J out of helping someone in need.

Ani has never made Srishti aunty pay for anything she did to J.

She drugged J to point of death, let her drift in the river, planned her marriage to an evil man, had her kidnapped.

So now when helping Arshi

why J should pay? Like he forgave Srishti, save Arshi and let J alone.

No justice keeda...the guy only lives by one rule Jhanak. When J is concerned, his dimaag starts working ot and not always is right.

based on his characterization so far, no way is he fighting for Arshi against J. It simply wont happen. J may mistake, family may mistake, he will be fighting for Arshi, but not against J.

The whole story since day 1 is Ani performing to protect J. Why will he not now, when he for sure knows j has no motive

He isn’t fighting J against Arshi .. what I meant is him saying that J will pay price if she committed a crime without second thought etc … I am saying he has inherent sense of justice in him and based on that he helped J as well

As far as punishing Shristi goes, drugging and drowning isn’t exposed yet. But when it is I am willing to think he will stand up against that as well.

Plus the tejas wedding and kidnapping , he did stand up against it as well. Yes didn’t go as far as involving police , but he did his part. Jhanak also needs to be willing when it comes to filing a police complaint! Let’s also consider that.

Originally posted by: PPak

So Ani saved J out of helping someone in need.

Ani has never made Srishti aunty pay for anything she did to J.

She drugged J to point of death, let her drift in the river, planned her marriage to an evil man, had her kidnapped.

So now when helping Arshi

why J should pay? Like he forgave Srishti, save Arshi and let J alone.

No justice keeda...the guy only lives by one rule Jhanak. When J is concerned, his dimaag starts working ot and not always is right.

based on his characterization so far, no way is he fighting for Arshi against J. It simply wont happen. J may mistake, family may mistake, he will be fighting for Arshi, but not against J.

The whole story since day 1 is Ani performing to protect J. Why will he not now, when he for sure knows j has no motive

The very first meeting of Ani Jhanka, their argument :

Meri hone wali biwi se mafi maango ...

why bcoz there was a discomfort due to sudden break!!!

J said then i fell down, i am hurt and you want me to ask maafi to some one who is saying she is fine ...

---

this is repeat 2. same same but different different...

Here Arshi is really hurt, and presumably bcoz of J. Only Shrishti knows that this is not true. (on the side note: I cant believe her confidence. Does she actually think that J mauqe ka faida uthaya and Arshi ki taraf diya ko dhakel diya. She always believed pro max that J has bad intentions in spite of no rational evidence.)

There is a possibility that Arshi also knows (front seat audience) the actual truth, that her mother wanted to harm J but it back fired, hence she is in shock. Maybe she is angry at her mother. Ani talked to her, counsellers did, but we havent yet seen mother-daughter convo. Will she respond to her mother who actually caused her wedding and profession!

--

I believe Chotton also witnessed it, but he is afraid to speak up, because of his standing in the family. When DidiMuni consoled J, he gathered that she has seen it as well. Chotton can believe that Shrishti can hurt J, but DidiMuni cannot fathom what she saw was actually possible, hence she withdrew herself. Initially when Chotton defended J in front of his mother, it seemed that Minton had discussed it. But yday's epi it was clear that they didn't, so assuming that Chotton witnessed it as well.

--

Another aspect of Ani doubting J:

"bcoz J wanted to stop the wedding" there was a glimmer of hope, but he immediately stopped, considering what it implied. I don't think he was actually doubting J. All the statements (support of Arshi or against J) are mere statements not his feelings. Not even 0.000001% doubt, just nannha sa dil wanting his heart's desire for her to stop the wedding.

--

Yes he wants justice for Arshi. But it also implies deep faith that J is not the culprit. Stating again anything from Ani are mere statements not his feelings. All his life he has been acting according to J and he knows how to give a performance that no one will know which is real, in his monologue!

--

I still believe in his deep love for J. Everything is for J and about J. A story is not in an incomplete precap or 1-2 episodes, let the whole sequence play out before calling it quits.

--

This is coming from someone who is still going thru PTSD of ghum experience.

Originally posted by: PPak

no wrong dialogs...intentionally writing to cause undue irritation from viewers

Makers hmey jalana or phir marna chahty h bs 🤬

Originally posted by: szsiddiqa

The very first meeting of Ani Jhanka, their argument :

Meri hone wali biwi se mafi maango ...

why bcoz there was a discomfort due to sudden break!!!

J said then i fell down, i am hurt and you want me to ask maafi to some one who is saying she is fine ...

---

this is repeat 2. same same but different different...

Here Arshi is really hurt, and presumably bcoz of J. Only Shrishti knows that this is not true. (on the side note: I cant believe her confidence. Does she actually think that J mauqe ka faida uthaya and Arshi ki taraf diya ko dhakel diya. She always believed pro max that J has bad intentions in spite of no rational evidence.)

There is a possibility that Arshi also knows (front seat audience) the actual truth, that her mother wanted to harm J but it back fired, hence she is in shock. Maybe she is angry at her mother. Ani talked to her, counsellers did, but we havent yet seen mother-daughter convo. Will she respond to her mother who actually caused her wedding and profession!

--

I believe Chotton also witnessed it, but he is afraid to speak up, because of his standing in the family. When DidiMuni consoled J, he gathered that she has seen it as well. Chotton can believe that Shrishti can hurt J, but DidiMuni cannot fathom what she saw was actually possible, hence she withdrew herself. Initially when Chotton defended J in front of his mother, it seemed that Minton had discussed it. But yday's epi it was clear that they didn't, so assuming that Chotton witnessed it as well.

--

Another aspect of Ani doubting J:

"bcoz J wanted to stop the wedding" there was a glimmer of hope, but he immediately stopped considering what it implied. I don't think he was actually doubting J. All the statements (support of Arshi or against J) are mere statements not his feelings. Not even 0.000001% doubt, just nannha sa dil wanting his heart's desire for her to stop the wedding.

--

Yes he wants justice for Arshi. But it also implies deep faith that J is not the culprit.

--

I still believe in his deep love for J. Everything is for J and about J. A story is not in an incomplete precap or 1-2 episodes, let the whole sequence play out before calling it quits.

--

This is coming from someone who is still going thru PTSD of ghum experience.

@red That sums everything ❤️

.....

Phir bhi poor writing to hn yaha ...koi maney ya na maney! 🤬

Arshi has been character who was motivated to live the most lol 😂 isse motivation ki zaroorat nahi hai ! She has so many dreams and honeymoon plans with ani .. since when she needed motivation to live ! Makers are hell bent on showing Arshi as a “bechari” and jhanak not the “bechari” … and now with a fire incident they showed her like he is in freaking coma!! 🤣🤣 itana desperation to earn sympathy for a character?!! lolz

Originally posted by: PPak

he was trying to motivate Aershi when she is sick.

Dr told him right, when people are sick they don't understand. He wanted to give Arshi a false sense of love to motivate her to fight and get out of her situation.

If Ani cared so much abt Arshi he wont be blatantly deceiving her so far nor look at Jhanak the way he was during his wedding to Arshi.

He already made the decision to let J go and stay married to Arshi. He did not even try to get out of the marriage. That we can blame him for. That he is weak to refuse to marry someone he does not love and cheats her. But I wont blame him that he thinks J wanted to kill Arshi. He of all people should know. J rejected him many times, there is no motive for J to hurt Arshi, its clear she pushed Ani to it.

In fact anyone who saw J sign the annulment papers and thinks J has a motive needs to get their heads checked. But lets say we excuse BH wasi's and say - well they they saw the performing Ani and thought he did not want J - so she had to sign...what about Ani - he has no excuse. So he must be 'performing'

If Ani really believes J is capable of hurting Arsshi the last 230 episodes we need to chalk to wasted time and emotions and hope we gj.et a new ML. Bcos then even at 500th episode after investing twice our time we will still see Ani not trust J for Arshi.

Arshi will never go away from their lives till last episode. We need to accept this.