Originally posted by: mala06
If you have listened them starting from few years back, you can clearly see the biasness of them. During fitoor days they used to criticize Hiba left and right while praise Mahira when she was doing equally toxic character. She even found "chemistry" between Mahira and Usman even when Usman used to mentally torture her in the show.
They warmed up when Hiba gave intetview with them . Also in the interview with Hassan . He showed bad comments written about Hiba in the show and asked her how she feels about it, I found him very nasty. If I was in her place, I would have left that show at exactly that moment. I really disliked it. They also don't like Danish especially Amna who hates him. Don't know the reason. Maybe because he disagreed to give interview to them. They only started praising him after danish gave interview with Hassan.
Coming to Radd. Amna initially said that she was apprehensive about the pair but she saw chemisty in them in the initial episodes and now all of a sudden she is completely going back to her words. Also apparantly Hiba looks good with older guys😡😡. Thats the problem she has.
Now let us suppose it was Mahira doing this show and then Bilal was the lead, with clear age difference and then still she would see the chemistry. Thats what the problem I have with her. She is not geniune. I find Fuschia faar better than them. Atleast they are not biased.
I think even though they are reviewers, they may have that biasness. Even they agree with that. I think, in general, most of the people have inclination towards some people. I remember the main criticism was regarding the screen age of Hiba.
It is easier to openly criticize someone whom they don't know than someone they know. After interacting with the actors they form an opinion and can't be that much open to criticize them. And also they get to understand the actor's perspective so they may consider that too while reviewing. I think that was a segment in the show. It had both the positive and negative comments. I don't think Aamna hates Danish. I have seen her agreeing to his acting being good. It was that the character selection of Danish they dislike. Even Wahaj disagreed to give interview to SH. And they generally talk nicely about him. When they don't know the actors personally, they have no idea about what they are like. But when they interview, they get to understand the actor's personality and perspective. So the perception may change.
Reviews are based on episode by episode. At first, may be she felt apprehensive and later saw the potential in the pairing then, may be now she doesn't feel it. I get the point she was making regarding one set of actors. She named FQ and DT. When she watched the shows, she felt the spark. It is her perspective.
I think it's more about the spark of the actors on the screen when they come together. And regarding the age, she mentions about the screen age. I think the screen age of some actors is more than their real age and for some, it's less. I agree that she has her biases but I don't think she is not genuine. I can see that she has the intellect when she reviews dramas seriously. And I saw her genuinely praising actors and put her point of view across when she criticized.