Tere Bin S02 (GEO) #2 - Yumna Zaidi, Wahaj Ali- Page 34

Show Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

78.6k

Users

28

Likes

2.1k

Frequent Posters

1263316 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: anu41982

This scene was a beauty!

However, this scene, at least for me, was more for Meerab than for Murtasim though. Murtasim knew she loves him way before this, only that she was reluctant (and scared too) to accept it to herself, let alone accepting out loud. For Meerab, her love had to be forgiving - like his always was for her. She held him accountable for series of presumed 'crimes', emotionally that is what held her back always. One of the last grudge she held against him was the system he represented - Meerab's ideologies were strongly against the feudal system and patriarchal nature that subdued its women and their choices. He was at the helm of that system - so for Meerab, he represented the system, as the leader, he manoeuvred it, he got everything he wanted and wished for - women are rendered powerless, while the men had all the power, and in Meerab's eye, he was the one who had all and enjoyed it all.

The same day of this scene, before going for shopping, she tells him that she knows his love for her, but manogi tab, jab main tumse tum jaisi mohabbat karo - simple, he loves her with all her faults, despite everything, but she is not there, not yet, so she will hold it to herself. So when he revealed that he too lost his passion, had to give up his life choices, had to make sacrifices in this system just like her (and like the girls of the family), that he had not embraced being the 'sarbarah' of the family merrily and that he had no interest in the system he represented which she held him accountable for - there was nothing she could hold against him - seeing him so vulnerable, bearing his heart to her - her love was liberated. She who was stubborn as a mule, knew shedding a tear for his pain and his loss would be the direct give away - not for him, for her(her monologue in Ep. 38), so she held back, stubbornly holding her tears, but when he softly cups her face, the dam breaks - the final shackle is broken, she let go of everything, knowing that she is truly enamoured by the man in front her. I loved the fact that they gave no dialogues for Yumna and she showed all the right emotions in this scene. smiley1smiley1


You’ve put it here so beautifully - it’s given another dimension and depth to this scene for me now 🥹

I too clocked her pointed words at him “Maanu gi tou tab… jab tumse tum JAISI mohabbat karoon gi” It was a very roundabout way of telling him yes she has feelings but there are things holding her back.
and like you said, when he tells her about his past and how he took on his responsibility as the feudal lord, that dam broke for her then and there.

Which is why I also feel she thought that their love would be strong enough to weather the maryam elopement situation. Maybe that dam breaking gave her renewed confidence in their relationship that it would be strong enough to tackle the repercussions from the elopement. And maybe it would have been enough had it not been for the fact that it was Malik Zubair and how Haya framed Meerab 🤦🏻‍♀️

its kind of poetic in a way. Murtasim lost faith in their love (something he was so confident about) the MOMENT it became a fact for Meerab. The tables turned in that episode.

1263316 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: anu41982

As an antagonist, Haya's character was written very well. Agreed - it was clear from some full scenes and the way some scenes were executed, the makers wanted sympathy for her - at least till she decided to almost kill Meerab and then went ahead to present her sister to the arch nemesis of the family on a platter in the name of her 'love' (she never loved Murtasim, hence the quotationsmiley2)! She had ample screen space, especially for a character that did not need to show an elaborated arc as it was a negative one from the beginning. But I agree with you, except for the finale episode, the portrayal of Haya is mediocre - especially the body language and voice modulations were monotonous - most of the time, I didn't like the dialogue delivery. But she did well in the finale episode - I loved her final close up.

Maybe I’m in the minority but I never felt the writer wanted sympathy for Haya at all. I believe Nooran even said that despite Haya’s desperate antics, her schemes only brought Meerab and Murtasim closer together than before. And from the lines given to Haya it’s pretty clear her love is supposed to be superficial, based on status (hence the focus Haya is shown to have on the ring, the room, the title, ordering around servants). Her subservience to Murtasim is in direct contrast to Meerab’s nonchalance. A doormat through n through whereas Meerab was anything but.
plus the amount of cringe stalker obsessive lines given to Haya I find it hard to believe she was supposed to be sympathetic. Not at all. Things like “Galla Daba ke jaan lena, hastay hastay de doon gi” and “hum bhi kawaaray, hamaray woh bhi kanwaray” 🤢- these are not lines you give to a character you sympathize with.

For me Sabeena played her well. It had to be downplayed because Haya was very over the top in her lines and words. If she had been overplayed it would have been too cringe - even more so than what it was lol. And I think the monotonous tone helped with showing how fake and shallow her love was. And her scenes with Maryam - be it her being frustrated at a situation or her taunting Maryam - were performed so well. Sabeena herself admits that she downplayed the character for these reasons lol. And for me this acting choice worked.

Maybe a lot of people just hate Haya (understandably) and weren’t too happy with Sabeena teasing the audience so by extension the performance of the actor also gets disliked, but I honestly thought she did a fab job. It was so fun to see her squirm and loose 😂 and if it was fun then it means the villain did their job well

nightingale1234 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Virgo27

According to writer Haya was written in a manner that people sympathize with her as she was suffering from one sided love. But no one felt her pain in fact her expressions were cringe. Her character was written good as compared to meerab but she didn't deliver good performance.

Sabeena was fine in kabuli pulao. So, she can act if she's given right direction.. I think incase of TB, nooran loved haya and murtasim the most...I think she wanted to show haya's pain and her unrequited love for murtasim.. Probably she had written it in that way.But, siraj didn't give much importance haya and was more focused on murtasim and his love for meerab. He had already envisioned haya as a vamp so, didn't want to indulge in her part of story much..So, most of the things looked half baked..

Not that I have any complain..I wouldn't have liked if haya had grabbed all the screenspace..I m glad that siraj chose to give more and more about meerasim than showing haya's sob storysmiley36

Achelvi thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 2 years ago

Nooran made many contrasting statements before and after. She did say she wanted audience to feel sympathy for haya which didn't happen..she said she connects to haya more she is haya in real life so she gave her more importance than meerab in terms of dialogues and POV...it's yumna with her performance conveyed her emotions without any dialogues, we could understand her pain dilemma

Sabeena was ok was haya...she looked weak in front of others in terms of performance

Nooran even said the story is inspired by her cousin. The problem with writing was quite visible before episode 23 and after... it looked like someone else wrote after that, there were many loopholes which as audience we were hoping will get closed eventually which didn't happen...story in itself was good but couldn't be executed properly

She is very good in writing romantic scenes...she should concentrate on character graphs as a whole rather than shock value for each episode and forgetting to continue it in next episode

If not for wahaj and yumna it wouldn't have been this successful and Siraj with his direction made wahaj look so good as murtasim

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".