Is Aishwarya Rai’s filmography a disgrace to actresses of her time? - Page 3

Rani, Preity, Kareena are very good in bubbly ,over the top,  bold roles...People generally love such kind of roles, which have  mass flavor. But they cannot play, a HDDCS, Raincoat or Devadas..They are not cut for it...Their cuteness, confidence or arrogance will come through...

On the otherhand Ash cannot do such energetic roles, she will look artifical...But excellent in roles that require controlled acting.

Nandini in HDDCS has an innate innocence in her, Preity will look naughty, both Rani and Kareena will look haughty.

Rani, Preity, Kareena are overrated.

Ash is underrated, simply because people want that ''exaggerated expressions'' from actors.

Uh oh some Rani fans are butt hurt I see 

Can’t believe members still fall for these troll topics and starts writing essays in such topics  

Originally posted by: bollymolly

Rani, Preity, Kareena are very good in bubbly ,over the top,  bold roles...People generally love such kind of roles, which have  mass flavor. But they cannot play, a HDDCS, Raincoat or Devadas..They are not cut for it...Their cuteness, confidence or arrogance will come through...

On the otherhand Ash cannot do such energetic roles, she will look artifical...But excellent in roles that require controlled acting.

Nandini in HDDCS has an innate innocence in her, Preity will look naughty, both Rani and Kareena will look haughty.

Rani, Preity, Kareena are overrated.

Ash is underrated, simply because people want that ''exaggerated expressions'' from actors.

you mean Rani who was lauded by her critics during that time for being the queen of subtlety cannot do subtle roles but Ash can 

Originally posted by: Lord_Voldemort

Uh oh some Rani fans are butt hurt I see 

Rani fans can also have a good laugh at such ridiculous essays .. or are we not allowed to do that as per Ashu Janu fans 

Originally posted by: Nishita123

Can’t believe members still fall for these troll topics and starts writing essays in such topics  

I live for reading such essays

this could be once of the the biggest comedy ever happened on IF

Guzaarish is considered a cult classic now. Even if it was flop but people consider it a masterpiece.

Let’s not forget she was shadow banned in the industry so that certainly affected her work. Her run from her first movie to Devdas was indeed iconic. After 2003, she did some great work, not consistently but she did do well, 

She’s certainly better than most of the actress y’all are cheering for today. I also think Ash is more of  celebrity than an actress, she’s like the more talented version of Katrina Kaif. 

Edited by Shaitan-Haiwan - 2 months ago

Forget the movies, it's not like she was very good in them anywayz. 

So nope...no one needs to feel any disgrace.

Having said that I don’t think her career is a disgrace .. there are other actresses for whom this title suits better 

Let’s not get there