Indian Idol 14 - Performance Discussion (3&4 Feb'24) - Page 7

wish they would have better song selection in these shows.

Channel, show & judges pushing Subhadeep with his classical-semi classical forte.

Ananya has been very consistent from the beginning. So has been Utkarsh, and Piyush. Utkarsh never was in bottom 3 nor had a bad performance up to date. So this was shocking. He was made “Bali ka bakra” to make someone else shine-best performer 🙄if this happens to Piyush also we all know what is up 😡

Dipan & Vaibhav has also had good performances.

I personally prefer Obom’s voice over Anjana. Obom & Adya fall under different catagory with their voice quality. I know most here think they both are weakest. As I feel Anjana and Adhya are limited genre singers. Anjana has improved some but keeps going back to her limited genre “Rock”. Judges & Janta follow the latest trend. 🙄


Obom also has given up few weeks back which one can see with his ok performances. MENUKa has breathing & anxiety issues with fast paced songs. She has beautiful voice but with limitations. Her elimination I can accept. But Utkarsh, Piyush, Ananya going b4 rest would be hard to digest 🙁

Only we can have one winner so no reason to debate over our favorites.

My million $ Q is why musicians are slowing down tempo of many songs? Also none of the judges have given feedback on few contestant’s holding mic & taking a breath away from mic. That should be the first thing singer should be trained along with their singing riaz.

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

My million $ Q is why musicians are slowing down tempo of many songs? Also none of the judges have given feedback on few contestant’s holding mic & taking a breath away from mic. That should be the first thing singer should be trained along with their singing riaz.

Several years ago when judges used to give genuine feedback, this was also a point mentioned. Since the last few years they have stopped giving that feedback. Maybe their assumption is that during recording their are blockers in front of the mic anyway.

Originally posted by: PV_IFhandle

Several years ago when judges used to give genuine feedback, this was also a point mentioned. Since the last few years they have stopped giving that feedback. Maybe their assumption is that during recording their are blockers in front of the mic anyway.

But that's very distracting as a listener.

One singer who has mastered this holding of breath is Sayli. She sings fast paced songs but we don't get to hear her breath.

Even Anjali

After two three performances of Utkarsh all marathi audiance started commenting about his song selection and requested channel to keep it classical but scripted show didn't hear. He is versatile but his fanbase love to hear classical more and want him to carry forward the legacy of Marathi Natyasangeet, Abhang and pure classical songs as mentioned by Mahesh Kale.

Originally posted by: Raffta

After two three performances of Utkarsh all marathi audiance started commenting about his song selection and requested channel to keep it classical but scripted show didn't hear. He is versatile but his fanbase love to hear classical more and want him to carry forward the legacy of Marathi Natyasangeet, Abhang and pure classical songs as mentioned by Mahesh Kale.

So called Ustad used Rahul Despande and his duet to sell online singing classes.

Never seen before.

I guess his financial position was not good but I smell so many fishy things about him from Season 11.

Originally posted by: Raffta

So called Ustad used Rahul Despande and his duet to sell online singing classes.

Never seen before.

I guess his financial position was not good but I smell so many fishy things about him from Season 11.

Originally posted by: PV_IFhandle

Several years ago when judges used to give genuine feedback, this was also a point mentioned. Since the last few years they have stopped giving that feedback. Maybe their assumption is that during recording their are blockers in front of the mic anyway.