Indian Idol 14 - Performance Discussion (3&4 Feb'24)

Discuss here...

Menuka seemed to have forgot lyrics again. Likely her and Adiya gone

Menuka is going if it's double elimination. Obom was also not great

Piyush was excellent. Ananya & Dipan were really good. Menuka sang well but she forgot the lyrics again. I liked Obom's performance too but he is unable to create the magic like before.

Hemant Kumar special

Was looking forward to this. 😊

Obom - Hai apna dil & O Hansini.

V mediocre. It is as if he has sort of given up. The first one was ok, but as pointed out by Sanuda the second one was rendered totally flat.

Dipan - Yaad kiya dil ne kahan ho tum & Rimjhim gire saawan

A decent effort. The first one was better, he brought in the softness needed for the song.

Menuka - Kahin deep jale & Tera saath.

Blanked out in the first, though she started well. The second one as usual dragged in pace. The judges’ comments were good & fair, they didn’t try to cloak it like last time.

Piyush - Na Tum Hamein , Mujhe choo rahi ho & Megha re. Hemantda, Rafi saab & Suresh wadekar. The first one was superb with brilliant modulations. His voice just glides over you makkhan jaisa 🙂 👌. The last one was awesome esp considering it is a tough song. One of Piyush’s best in this season.

Ananya - Mera dil ne pukare & Banwara badaa naadan. Beautifully rendered.👌 The second one stood out with all those natkhat harkatein. She should have got the Hit se zyaada button.

Ananya rendered good support to Piyush & Dipan too.

The tribute was done well. Adya got to sing the iconic jaane woh kaise… & Menuka the other gem - Tum pukar lo. Menuka did well,

An enjoyable episode.
Moushumi is a delight to watch.
Shreya’s Rimjhim gire & Na tum humein was the icing on the cake. 👌

Hemanda’s compositions and his songs are gems - a much needed Special. 👍👍👌.

Tomorrow is gonna be double elimination. My guess is - Obom, Menuka, Adya could be bottom 3 & the first 2 may go.

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

Hemant Kumar special

Was looking forward to this. 😊

Obom - Hai apna dil & O Hansini.

V mediocre. It is as if he has sort of given up. The first one was ok, but as pointed out by Sanuda the second one was rendered totally flat.

Dipan - Yaad kiya dil ne kahan ho tum & Rimjhim gire saawan

A decent effort. The first one was better, he brought in the softness needed for the song.

Menuka - Kahin deep jale & Tera saath.

Blanked out in the first, though she started well. The second one as usual dragged in pace. The judges’ comments were good & fair, they didn’t try to cloak it like last time.

Piyush - Na Tum Hamein , Mujhe choo rahi ho & Megha re. Hemantda, Rafi saab & Suresh wadekar. The first one was superb with brilliant modulations. His voice just glides over you makkhan jaisa 🙂 👌. The last one was awesome esp considering it is a tough song. One of Piyush’s best in this season.

Ananya - Mera dil ne pukare & Banwara badaa naadan. Beautifully rendered.👌 The second one stood out with all those natkhat harkatein. She should have got the Hit se zyaada button.

Ananya rendered good support to Piyush & Dipan too.

The tribute was done well. Adya got to sing the iconic jaane woh kaise… & Menuka the other gem - Tum pukar lo. Menuka did well,

An enjoyable episode.
Moushumi is a delight to watch.
Shreya’s Rimjhim gire & Na tum humein was the icing on the cake. 👌

Hemanda’s compositions and his songs are gems - a much needed Special. 👍👍👌.

Tomorrow is gonna be double elimination. My guess is - Obom, Menuka, Adya could be bottom 3 & the first 2 may go.

I don’t think Adya will be going saw her insta post she is still in Mumbai and the article I shared earlier where Vishal comment ob her performance was really good so I don’t think she even came in bottom. Well technically she should go by seeing her overall journey till now.

Originally posted by: reborn-re

I don’t think Adya will be going saw her insta post she is still in Mumbai and the article I shared earlier where Vishal comment ob her performance was really good so I don’t think she even came in bottom. Well technically she should go by seeing her overall journey till now.

It was a good episode today! I wasn’t too familiar with Hemant Kumar but I had heard most of the songs.

I felt bad for Menuka though but I’m glad the judges didn’t sugarcoat it like they did last time. It seems like she’s given up as well like Muskaan did and just is riding by. Ananya was great as usual as were Dipan and Piyush.

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

yeah, true. In all probability it is going to be Obom & Menuka

Which will be a farce and truly disgusting . It seems Menuka is becoming a liability for the show as they move towards the finale, and they're simply staging all this drama to justify her exit.

Originally posted by: sahil70

Which will be a farce and truly disgusting . It seems Menuka is becoming a liability for the show as they move towards the finale, and they're simply staging all this drama to justify her exit.