Week 20 - 24 November - Page 10

Originally posted by: Chemcart_MJ

may be they are writing comments for her since she is not able to say anything

btw I have a doubt, whether contestants unko seriously lete honge ki nahi.

Originally posted by: Minionite

I don't think that she herself will come back again

As I said in one of the comments that I think now they are writing scripts for her to comment so that at least she speaks something, may be that's why she is repeating, I mean vo bechare kitna likhenge, judges jo bhi khana khate honge usme thoda bohot script writers can write, baaki toh they will have to give their own input naa, even if you want to fake praise someone toh bhi you should have the knowledge of the flavors, spices, different textures aur jo bhi hota hai unka.

but wait, she doesn't know about savory, she doesn't know about dessert, toh phir vo kis cheez ki chef hain? As much as I know she is a pastry chef, pastry dessert mei aati hai naa, toh at least she must be knowing about desserts.

I think they are bringing female judges not just to appear woke, but I guess there are so many other reasons for this, that's why they are so much insisting on female judges.

I think ki either

1.chef Garima did not come because her child was born in May and the show started in Sept or Oct, so baccha 4-5 months kaa hoga naa.

2. The reason you told, I mean she refused because she could not tolerate itni phaltu ki nautanki.

May be that's why female judges are not willing to come, bhai after work they have their own family, upar se itni nautanki, patience lagta hai.

We should appreciate chef Ranveer for this, I mean jitna sab he did for the show (every publicity is good publicity) and how much we criticized him but still he came back, I thought iss baar toh nahi aaenge.

I don't know about Aruna's dishes, but she did not know how to talk, she treated that guest chef as if she was working under her.

upar se chef Ranveer kaa mumma mumma was too much, I mean KDK was a good cook I guess, but cheff kaa mumma annoyed the audience more, that's why people started criticizing KDK.

There are a lot of other good female chefs, who I’d like to believe have enough knowledge to be on Masterchef. Why go far, bring Chef Pankaj Bhadouria the first winner of MC. You hit two birds with one stone - female and a winner of the show!

There are so many lovely Indian female chefs:

Madhu Krishnan

Anahita Dhondy

Bani Nanda

Romy Gill (UK based)

Maneet Chauhan

Asma Khan (UK based)

I would like to see Nikita & Ripudaman but probably when the hypocrisy is improved from the season to some extent at least.

Originally posted by: IWasHareeshFan

but who expects them to do so and why?

Channel??? Or producer??? For why ? Trp n benefits

These might be the cases...

I think they approached Anahita Dandi but the plan didn't work, why I feel this because out of nowhere chef Vikas posted a clip of Anahita Dandi from last season, but after few days he deleted that clip, at least I cannot see that on his IG page now.

Even she refused I guess, and others will refused as well, specially MCI ke winners toh I think nahi aana chahenge because even they have gone through all this.

Originally posted by: ShailyG

I just remembered that during initial seasons of Indian Idol, a kashmiri was made winner, while he didn't deserve to be in top 5 as well. He was advertised as first Kashmiri participant.

Later judges also confessed that they were also not in favor of it. Still it happened. Just to mention, that Arijit Singh was also one of the participants during that season and was eliminated

Similar thing is happening here... since first week, we have big hoardings of Rukhsar everywhere in the city.

Votes Qazi touqeer got broke all the records. People were good back then itna hatred,racism tha nehi.

He was not a very good singer or trained at all, but rest contestants under estimated him,they barely talked to him and audiences connected with him.

guys, please make a new thread for this weeks discussion

I think you make every week, so if you don't mind can you please?

I don’t follow this season but by chance saw Aruna posted video about last season top 6 coming to the show. So did they came yet? If they haven’t please do let me know too.

Originally posted by: reborn-re

I don’t follow this season but by chance saw Aruna posted video about last season top 6 coming to the show. So did they came yet? If they haven’t please do let me know too.

Yes, they came in Diwali special episode

Watch episode 17/18/19, I am not sure, but they came in one of the three episodes only.