Karishma or Kareena?

I kindly put this question for your show of hands, I know it's no picnic and a gargantuan double bind for me itself in concluding out the two, who's considered more prime significant than the other.

You may mentally wrestle over who ultimately shines for you, or you predominantly have a preference. Either/or, I'd like to know. So please kindly share your subjective reflection

Your election may be based upon: countenance, demeanour or creative attainment.

If judging on creative attainment, please bear in mind Kareena has been making grade in more new wrinkle concepts of cinema being explored set side by side Karishma's era of movies based on regressed conceptual cinema.

You may comment your choices below in addition and any reasons for selection.

I think Karishma is the better dancer and has done lots of good work. Post Raja Hindustani she really did well.

But I think Kareena has been more smart with her better choices and has a good strategy to stay relevant

Originally posted by: carisma2

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

I think Karishma is the better dancer and has done lots of good work. Post Raja Hindustani she really did well.

But I think Kareena has been more smart with her better choices and has a good strategy to stay relevant

I have to agree with you. I am a little biased and favourable to Karishma as once was in the list of my fav's. Karishma's dancing was pretty awesome and totally fitting to her era. I know people like to refer to Aish as a doll, but I have always seen Karishma hit into that box more. Sometimes I do feel that somewhere Kareena's acting is more grounded than Karishma's. But then I think of the movie Shakti - and it's decided for me. It's deffo Karishma.

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

I cant choose

You gotta chose your fav between Kareen and Karishma not Kareena and Carisma.

I thought your fav was Kareena. No?

Maroon, teri porsch mein ek hi passenger seat hai - ek ko bhita and dusri ko paidal bej.

Off Screen chemistry I like Karishma more. She was bold, she had her own personality. She went for her dreams. She has seen trauma in her childhood and she said heck with this i will join Bollywood where in Kapoor Family women were not encouraged. There were a lot of controversy that she wore short clothes in movies. She worked a lot. Not sure how much support she had but mentally she is a very strong person. I was so sad when she stop doing movies. I love her off screen personality. Very humble and present herself with good manners.

Now to Kareena, i feel she didn't had to work hard as her sister. She even said that she wanted success as her sister got. I only liked her in Jab we Met. I guess also because she had so many digging comments with other actors.

Originally posted by: carisma2

You gotta chose your fav between Kareen and Karishma not Kareena and Carisma.

I thought your fav was Kareena. No?

Maroon, teri porsch mein ek hi passenger seat hai - ek ko bhita and dusri ko paidal bej.

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

What about Madhuri. Where can I sit her

Lap, perhaps?

If your wife doesn't kill you first!

Kareena is better in every way as an actress she's far superior

Karims was highly overrated in the 90's

She didn't even look that good with her bushy eyebrows

To me 90's heroines madhuri, juhi, urmila, and manisha are best

kajol n karisma are nepo overrated

Originally posted by: Bekind

Off Screen chemistry I like Karishma more. She was bold, she had her own personality. She went for her dreams. She has seen trauma in her childhood and she said heck with this i will join Bollywood where in Kapoor Family women were not encouraged. There were a lot of controversy that she wore short clothes in movies. She worked a lot. Not sure how much support she had but mentally she is a very strong person. I was so sad when she stop doing movies. I love her off screen personality. Very humble and present herself with good manners.

Now to Kareena, i feel she didn't had to work hard as her sister. She even said that she wanted success as her sister got. I only liked her in Jab we Met. I guess also because she had so many digging comments with other actors.

I have noticed many a times, off screen Kareena has a terrible attitude. However she is getting a little humble now as movies are not falling at her feet as before her becoming Mrs Kapoor Khan. She's also looking better than she did before, onscreen - for her age. I like her family commitment and seems to be a hands on mum and somewhere made the effort of forming a bond with her husband's children. I liked Kareena's Kurbaan as well as jab we met.

Karishma, It's tragic. It's like her whole world just turned upside down and she got sunk in somewhere. She isn't getting that recognition no more. I recently watched the interview where she was saying they used to literally burn their feet and dance on set in extreme hot weather conditions. So it really shows the dedication there.