Originally posted by: AuntyDepressant
All of us? Once again a claim not substantiated well enough. Dawn piece is just an opinion like yours. SH is not worth much in my opinion. Their views on Aswad's character in ham kahan kay sachay thay was quite problematic to be honest. Also, SH themselves changed their opinion once PKS started getting the hype. Their opinions usually change according to the popularity of the actors. Not worth the hype they get that everyone seems to be quoting them. Btw Aamna also used to criticize Sajjal in her initial dramas and according to her Mahira is a good actor. Ahem!
Also, your statement was "t's only when his character went down the drain yumna started getting more appreciation as abdullah's character wasn't worth any sympathy and mahjabeen was the bechari masloom fl. "
Your generalization of Yumna getting appreciation only in later episodes is wrong as I mentioned there are many who appreciate her acting in initial episodes as well as later.
And FYI I mentioned people being able to relate to Meerab's character despite it being badly written is due to Yumna and her acting and her ability to convey emotions and as an example I mentioned Meerab and Yumna trending in the countries where previously Pakistani dramas were not watched and that means they were not previously Yumna's fans. It wasn't about popularity. Being able to comprehend and understand what the other person's point is before commenting is an important part of healthy discussion.
All of us as in people on this thread who replied to you.
FYI reviews are opinion of people only. Pak industry don't have any critics only reviewers that don't know much about the technical aspect of movie making.
You also only have opinion of people to back your claims of yumna being a better actor than Bilal and sajal. 🤣
How is your opinion a fact and rest of our opinion just biased views?
Did i ever say aamna never criticised sajal? Hassan said sajal wasn't as convincing in the initial episodes of KA as well. The only difference is suprising sajal fans didn't go around bashing them for their views like yumna fans does to every other reviewers who don't worship her.
Also who are the people that relate to meerab according to you? She is one of the most bashed female lead ever in pak drama history and also one of the most badly written one and the worst performance of an actress of yumna's calibre. Except yumna fans hyping her up literally everyone feels she isn't good as meerab. Her character don't have the basic brain cell to function as a human being. She apparently had consensual sex with her legally wedded husband but got traumatized and ran away from home in the middle of the night. Who are the people that relate to this bullshit?
Edited by spnfan - 2 years ago
363