TERE BIN -Yumna Zaidi-Wahaj Ali DT#5 (Geo) "Mere Saath hi Lagalo, DIL" - Page 25

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

71.4k

Users

50

Likes

3.1k

Frequent Posters

columbia thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: ABBY_JERAN

And if this story indeed is about a man and how he is balancing everything

Then I would say Alhamdulillah for this change on tv

Coz all we saw on Indian and pak tv was men coming from office for too long now

Let the dynamic shift a bit plz


Also in one of the few threads someone here said it's just wahaj one man show....ladki koi BHI hogi toh chalti

Lol....I strongly disagree to that also

I don't think any XYZ ladki wouldn't been able to bring the fire to meerub


Koi bhi Nahin chalti



The thing is in every thread we are repeating the same things and same overall thoughts over and over again. It’s obvious that our minds are insisting on providing some sense of rationale behind our mindlessness need to watch the show.

I am staking claim on Murtasim’s shawl…baaki sab gaya tel lene.


-INAAYAT- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Gundamwing

Yumna has made meerub her own, she is closer in age to wahaj it gives this couple their takkar chmistry. Meerub has maturity and vulnerability in her character portrayed well by yumna, it is really a fine balance, any other actor would tip the balance. The story in not there yet where she is able to prove that she is wise but I think eventually I see her being murtasim strength. I don’t want to see her weeping all the time I like the fact that she challenges him. So overall good casting choice.


Agree! I keep wondering what is it that is working here and this explains it somehow. Yumna and Wahaj are pretty much the same age and seem to have bonded well enough for Yumna to give up on certain reservations that she has with her male co-stars. Also, Yumna needs a solid on-paper role to shine and she is a director's actor. This one is just not the exact cut for her or maybe the story hasn't reached the point where she gets her due (which I hardly doubt she will get here). Overall, this show is only going to give her popularity but will add nothing good to her resume. I also believe, she knows she's getting past the peak of her career. Hence she chose this one.

Tulip9 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: ABBY_JERAN

And if this story indeed is about a man and how he is balancing everything

Then I would say Alhamdulillah for this change on tv

Coz all we saw on Indian and pak tv was men coming from office for too long now

Let the dynamic shift a bit plz


Also in one of the few threads someone here said it's just wahaj one man show....ladki koi BHI hogi toh chalti

Lol....I strongly disagree to that also

I don't think any XYZ ladki wouldn't been able to bring the fire to meerub


Koi bhi Nahin chalti

@bold true . I was also hurt by that comment . Kyunki yumna ke alava koi bhi Na hi chalti. She is such a big star . But , many of the people downgrade her . It's sad
columbia thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Madhuilove

@bold true . I was also hurt by that comment . Kyunki yumna ke alava koi bhi Na hi chalti. She is such a big star . But , many of the people downgrade her . It's sad


really!?! I am unaware of this. I in fact find Yumna an excellent actress. She and Sajal for me are really top actresses on PTV, I do think Sajal has the more conventional looks that will give her international projects, unfortunately Yumna doesn’t. But who knows Yumna lives in the US for at least few months in the year, so she could very well get an agent for herself and seek off beat roles. In fact I find both of the, better actresses than Mahira Khan.

But I have no issue with Yumna playing this role, even though I do think it’s a badly written role for her, especially since she has always played very character driven roles. Why not, she tried something, maybe it will work for her in ways we don’t know. Maybe an American agent told her she will need to be to able to show some following online…to be able to convince her to for an audition, who knows?!


good for her. Let her take all the risks she wants to.

SherDilNetaji thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: columbia


good lord, if I were to compare pride and prejudice with this so called lame Robin Hood story, it would be intellectualization to the point of no return.
A marriage of equals is of course probably an incorrect way to put it and I did take some literary license in using the term, I did mean equality in marriage. And yes, equality in marriage is possible. Not just in books but in real life too,

End of the day, this is tv show which is supposed to sell ideals and fantasy, in fact, there is nothing in this show that is close to any reality, definitely not the life I lead.

But I find this drama so close to reality, I have seen women’s like MB who always wanted their sons to get married but then don’t want them too close to their wife. Then women like Meerub too exist where to prove that they are right they would do anything, you all are talking about how she is behaving right now, but I couldn’t relate with her before marriage too, I mean why she agreed for the marriage? I understand She had no place to go, but she was shown as an educated girl, she could have gotten a job or a house on her, but then she chose to get married for teaching them all a lesson for god knows what cause if anyone in the show who deserves to be shown the mirror was her parents and Anwar not Murtasim and it would all have made sense if she had run away after saying no, what was the need of the contract? And then Men like Murtasim too exist, they wants their wives to do everything they ask without any question. He has a reason to behave like his words are law cause people around him does what he says, he came from that power so it’s natural for him to expect the same from his wife. He never had people opposing him and when Meerub is doing the same he is refusing to think it in any other way except that she is undermining his authority. And when you are in power, a small no is enough to undermine your authority and power. Just think of it as politically, like in MahaBharat when Yudhishthir was staking the other Pandavas they could have openly said no but they didn’t cause he was the king and if they are refusing to accept his decisions then it would have been termed as rebellion and Murtasim though not in this sense but is still a political head so challenging his decisions in front of entire village only has one meaning that is challenging his authority, his position and no one is going to take it easily. We need to see Murtasim in two light, one as a husband and one as a leader, I don’t know what you all think about him as a husband but there are many instances when he has listened to her, but then what he did in the village instances is purely politics, even though he has used “Izzat ke badle Izzat”, he did what was needs to be done to prevent such further instances and to show that no one can cross him and go on without facing any consequences. They are following feudalism in their village and there words of the lord holds much much more importance than law. Even though we think that marriage should have equality, Meerub would never be Murtasim’s equal in the political sphere. Politic works differently than marriage, they have not whitewashed Murtasim’s character, they have justified it politically.

As someone gave the example of balance of power between the Jodha and Akbar without ruining their character but it was easy for them to show cause Jodha came from political family and she never underestimated Akbar’s authority as king and when she did she faced the consequences. They knew the power both of them holds and respected that fact. And it is clearly written in the description that Murtasim came from power and this power was all about his political position and Meerub was shown as the girl who challenges what she finds wrong, she knows law but in Murtasim’s world his words are law. You can challenge one’s ideology but if you challenge one’s power then there would be consequences. We all are seeing it as only a romantic show but when we take other aspects in consideration the script and characters are not as faulty as we see them.

Edited by Moonks - 2 years ago
spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: arshi1983


We are not even half-way through this story, they've just established the characters until now , their real journey together will begin most likely from the next episode and I plan to be patient to see the growth.


The show is executed in a manner where all the sympathy and love falls into murtasim's lap and meerab comes off as an irritating spoiled brat---Who is seeing her as a brat? Not me , neither her father nor her husband ,its just a certain section in the audience. To each their own! Why do we jump the gun and place the characters on a pedestal before hearing them out completely. I will wait until the end!

The drama finished 16 episode. That's too much episodes wasted if it's just for character establishment and set the pace for the real journey. The drama might be of 35-40 episodes and the drama already finished almost half of it. Even Hindi serials start their main storyline by ep 16.

Meerab being an immature brat is a very popular opinion. It's everywhere on social media and even the reviewers point it out again and again and says she tests murtasim's patiences way too much when on a technical pov she wasn't wrong for taking the bullets or going to the panchayat. She gets way more blame for her actions than murtasim. She even gets bashed for going out of the car to play with the goats even though that was out of pure innocence and curiosity. Majority who watched the show are pro-murtasim and it's very evident. Even the makers are pro-murtu and they won't hesitate to compromise on meerab's characterisation to uplift murtasim.

I don't see anyone jumping the guns but discussing and analysis what's already been shown to us and expecting what might happen in the future track with the experience of watching pak dramas like we all know the show mostly won't end with meerab having a career and practicing law. The chances are very slim. Even meerab herself seems to have forgotten about it.

Nephy1 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: ABBY_JERAN

And if this story indeed is about a man and how he is balancing everything

Then I would say Alhamdulillah for this change on tv

Coz all we saw on Indian and pak tv was men coming from office for too long now

Let the dynamic shift a bit plz


Also in one of the few threads someone here said it's just wahaj one man show....ladki koi BHI hogi toh chalti

Lol....I strongly disagree to that also

I don't think any XYZ ladki wouldn't been able to bring the fire to meerub


Koi bhi Nahin chalti

Nope...

At the end of the day ,I think its becoz of Yumna and YumHaj chemistry that is making people go crazy.

Nephy1 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Moonks

But I find this drama close to reality, I have seen women’s like MB who always wanted their sons to get married but then don’t want them too close to their wife. Then women like Meerub too exist where to prove that they are right they would do anything, you all are talking about how she is behaving right now, but I couldn’t relate with her before marriage too, I mean why she agreed for the marriage? I understand She had no place to go, but she was shown as an educated girl, she could have gotten a job or a house on her, but then she chose to get married for teaching them all a lesson for god knows what cause if anyone in the show who deserves to be shown the mirror was her parents and Anwar not Murtasim and it would all have made sense if she had run away after saying no, what was the need of the contract? And then Men like Murtasim too exist, they wants their wives to do everything they ask without any question. He has a reason to behave like his words are law cause people around him does what he says, he came from that power so it’s natural for him to expect the same from his wife. He never had people opposing him and when Meerub is doing the same he is refusing to think it in any other way except that she is undermining his authority. And when you are in power, a small no is enough to undermine your authority and power. Just think of it as politically, like in MahaBharat when Yudhishthir was staking the other Pandavas they could have openly said no but they didn’t cause he was the king and if they are refusing to accept his decisions then it would term as rebellion and Murtasim though not in this sense but is still a political head so challenging his decisions in front of entire village only has one meaning that is challenging his authority, his position and no one is going to take it easily. We need to see Murtasim in two light, one as a husband and one as a leader, I don’t know what you all think about him as a husband but there are many instances when he has listened to her, but then what he did in the village instances is purely politics, even though he has used “Izzat ke badle Izzat”, he did what was needs to be done to prevent such further instances and to show that no one can cross him and go on without facing any consequences. They are following feudalism in their village and there words of the lord holds much much more importance than law. Even though we think that marriage should have equality, Meerub would never be Murtasim’s equal in the political sphere. Politic works differently than marriage, they have not whitewashed Murtasim’s character, they have justified it politically.

As someone gave the example of balance of power between the Jodha and Akbar without ruining their character but it was easy for them to show cause Jodha came from political family and she never underestimated Akbar’s authority as king and when she did she faced the consequences. They knew the power both of them holds and respected that fact. And it is clearly written in the description that Murtasim came from power and this power was all about his political position and Meerub was shown as the girl who challenges what she finds wrong, she knows law but in Murtasim’s world his words are law. You can challenge one’s ideology but if you challenge one’s power then there would be consequences. We all are seeing it as only a romantic show but when we take other aspects in consideration the script and characters are not as faulty as we see them.

@B-Yup..thats it,its not regressiveness on his part,its mostly tge way to exist safely and keep his loved ones safe in that kind a society system.

And people here I see that think about things on individual basis they tend to forget that we co-exist in a societ which is driven by certain rules which changes every kilometre,every city,every society,culture,state and country.

They all are not progressive,many of them have flaws and need changes and changes are occuring also continously but that doesn't mean that in present people will not ensure their safety becoz for now it is very very wrong or unjustified in the hope that after some decades it will change.

Muratsim has 2 characters one is of husband and other is of leader to his village people,what he has done was very wrong but think in a way that if leader's wife can get abducted in his presence and bodygurad's than how risky it can get for normal females of his village,he had to ensure their safety and we can clearly saw that poloce has not much say in this feudal system.

Meerab is also right that in this conflict why women are suffering she was thinking more on social change,in frame of possibilities and foremost to protect the one female in front of her.

Murtasim was thinking more about current socuetal norms,what is present situation and safety of many women of his side.

Still in this regressiveness he tries to maintain some justifications,ek teer se do nishane.

Hus problem us he want meerab to liten him without questioning as well as understand him as others do.

But he doesn't get that meerab had no exposure to these things he need to take her in confidence and slowly a day may come where she will trust enough to not question him regarding his leadership decisions.

If you have seen she tend to trust him as husband.So its not like she doesn't trust him,its that she is strange to his political ways and how things work there.

And one more things I want to add,he just doesn't want meerab to respect in front of people,he expected the same from his mother for meerub becoz thats how it is at the end.

There are many things you find wrong is your parents ways becoz of generational gap,you have more broad mind but that doesn't mean you will go on public humiliation to them but at the same time its also parent's job to explain things otherwise it ill surely create conflict between them and us.

Edited by Nephy1 - 2 years ago
spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: columbia


really!?! I am unaware of this. I in fact find Yumna an excellent actress. She and Sajal for me are really top actresses on PTV, I do think Sajal has the more conventional looks that will give her international projects, unfortunately Yumna doesn’t. But who knows Yumna lives in the US for at least few months in the year, so she could very well get an agent for herself and seek off beat roles. In fact I find both of the, better actresses than Mahira Khan.

But I have no issue with Yumna playing this role, even though I do think it’s a badly written role for her, especially since she has always played very character driven roles. Why not, she tried something, maybe it will work for her in ways we don’t know. Maybe an American agent told her she will need to be to able to show some following online…to be able to convince her to for an audition, who knows?!


good for her. Let her take all the risks she wants to.

I think even Maya Ali is a better actor than Mahira khan. Sajal and yumna are way above her. She is more of a star than performer. She knows how to carry herself and have a public image except that i never got the hype for Mahira.

Sajal looks like a doll and has more of an innocent youthful look which attracts people more than yumna who gives off more of a girl next door image. I actually like yumna in her western casual looks than traditional looks. Her real life look is good.

I think yumna mainly did it for mass audience and to gain more star power. The dramas she usually does only give her acknowledgement as a good actor but no star power.

columbia thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

So yaaar I can’t relate to these two at all. I tots love their chemistry and frankly Wahaj is really good looking. Timepass OTT show this is.


No one in my immediate family or friends circle is like murtasim at all. I mean so he is some village ka chief or generational wealthy person of a small town and to think that in itself is possible is kind of silly. It’s like saying all those CEO stories with naive intern girls is real…they are not, they prey on some wired Prince Charming complex.


at the same time, let me say, I am quite opinionated and quite stand up and say what I want kind of girl. Do people think I am bratty, sure. But there is no way in hell will I want to be with a man who cannot get on with that program. My fiancé was a very charming and yet quite an upright guy. He did have his dominating moments and so did I. Once his aunt told him, “Teri honevali kaafi mufat hai, teri baat nahi sunne vaali” and he said “mai uska boss ya baap nahi hun” .


the thing is that whole Insta love that they show murtasim having for Meerab without even knowing her, just by watching her pray in itself is a fantasy that has been built. He falls for her, he thinks he can make her “his” or tame her with those OTT lines, then he is showing her various sides of him - a caring husband, a just leader all of this wanting her to love him. But does he love her as the person she is??! No he wants the wife, loves the woman, but not her spirit, not her personality. It’s all on his terms.

So in the end, at least for a story told through his lens, it most probably will be like she will love the husband, and adjust herself to his personality. Then hand claps will happen because everyone will say he made her fall in love with him.


and that’s it.

Abbb de bhi do Mujhe voh shawl.



Related Topics

Pakistani Serials thumbnail

Posted by: anikamathur · 1 years ago

Hamza Ali Abbasi and Sajal Ali To Pair Up For A New Drama Titled Farar after 5 years 👇🏻👇🏻...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials thumbnail

Posted by: anikamathur · 11 months ago

Ali Raza and Sohai Ali Abro to do a New Drama titled Dastak Directed by Marina Khan and Produced by Humayun Saeed Through Six Sigma...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials thumbnail

Posted by: anikamathur · 10 months ago

Wahaj Ali and Mahira Khan To Do a new drama directed by Haissam Hussain and It is written by Hashim Nadeem...

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials thumbnail

Posted by: heavenlybliss · 3 years ago

https://reviewit.pk/iqra-aziz-and-imran-ashraf-all-set-to-star-together-again-after-ranjha-ranjha-kardi/

Expand ▼
Pakistani Serials thumbnail

Posted by: awida · 1 years ago

Hello everybody. This show is under production. Written by: Fatima Faizan Directed by: Siraj Ul Haq Starring: Ahsan Khan and Mehwish Hayat...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".