Rank these Shoojit Sircar films

So he is probably one of the best directors Bollywood has ever had. Many call him a different breed. How would you rank the films he has directed?

Yahaan

Vicky Donor

Madras Cafe

Piku

October

Gulabo Sitabo

Sardar Udham

below is my order-

October

Piku

Vicky Donor

Madras Cafe

Gulabo Sitabo

Sardar Udham

i havent seen Yahaan

Madras Cafe

Vicky Donor

Yahaan

Sardar Udham

Piku

October

Gulabo Sitabo

Vicky donor (very tough subject and a real trend setter for ayushman, rajkumar type films)

piku and sardar udham

yahaan (beautiful underrated, jimmy and minisha were such a lovely romantic pair)

madras cafe

didnt watch the other

I only saw Vicky D and Piku

Loved Vicky D. Piku was meh I think its over rated

I had Gulabo Sitabo on once during quarantine but I shut it off after 10 minutes

Piku

October

---Barrier---

Vicky Donor

--Big Barrier--

Madras Cafe

---The Abyss----

Gulabo Sitabo

Sardar Udham

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

I only saw Vicky D and Piku

Loved Vicky D. Piku was meh I think its over rated

I had Gulabo Sitabo on once during quarantine but I shut it off after 10 minutes

Originally posted by: Grumpydwarf24

You haven’t watched Sardar Udham ? That is blasphemy in my book ?

Maybe it’s better if I don’t. I thought Tanhaji was gonna be a good movie until I saw it. I’d only rate it above average lol

piku then Vicky donor

not seen others

but piku is just magic every character, every scene, and all just superstars in the movie, so much repeat value, a classic

a shame that the director didn't work with deepika again so far

tusi vi tan dasso hun twada order