Performance Discussion 12 & 13 November, 2022

Discuss Here...

Originally posted by: altgr

Discuss Here...

Today is Atlantic City concert. I doubt Starttofinish is going to have any mental space for Idol 13 😄

Tearjerker..as expected..Manoj Muntashir 👌

The stars today ..and always.. are mothers. Vineet's mother is n inspiration..the way she said "aisa na ho ki hamare aane se aap emotional ho Kar gaana achha na gaao"..so strong, so inspiring.

And Kavya's mother has such a wonderful voice!

Sonakshi was the best among contestants

Couldn't watch today. Will try to catch it tomorrow.

Originally posted by: PV_IFhandle

Couldn't watch today. Will try to catch it tomorrow.

Keep tissues or towel handy..will need at few instances

Originally posted by: Kyahikahoon

Keep tissues or towel handy..will need at few instances

Yes. MM really knows how to brings tears to the eyes!

12th Nov Maa special - manoj Munthasir, Varun Dhawan, Kriti Sanon.

Kavya :- That was one of the most flat renditions of Dilbaro I have ever heard. That’s the thing about kavya - it’s either a hit or a miss. For me, it was a miss this time. Kavya’s mom packed in so much feel in just those few lines. Beautiful rendition 👌

Shivam :- Chunar - A composition that tugs your heart. Shivam aced it. 👍. The feel, the improvisations everything was pat on. Shivam is going to be the Nihal for me - I used to think it will be Chirag earlier. But since the last couple of episodes Shivam is climbing up the ladder steadily. Wonderful rendition. Cried, clapped, enjoyed. 👌. MBD well-deserved

Debo :- Tu kitni achchi hai. A simple song, rendered well. But I thought they could’ve given her something more challenging. Maybe Dilbaro should’ve gone to her.

Vineet :- Meri Maa. The minute he started, I knew it’s going to be a kill. The entire vineet segment was so emotional without being melodramatic. Cried, clapped, enjoyed. 👍👌.

Rishi :- Surmayi ankhiyon. He brought in the softness needed for the song. He was better compared to the last couple of weeks. Maybe like Faiz, he could be back with a bang.

Sonakshi :- Lukka Chuppi. One of her bests. A tough ARR number delivered so beautifully. 👍👌. Should’ve got MBD.

Navdeep :- Baaghban. As usual, sang in his comfort zone & did well. 👍

Sanchari :- Neerja song - not so popular. Didn’t connect. I thought she went a bit offtune too.

Asides:-

* Vishal, not known to exhibit emotions, had me in tears recounting his own personal loss.

* Varun lipsynching the sargam part of Luka Chuppi - wow! 👍.

* sparklers today :- Shivam, Sona, vineet & kavya’s mom 😊

* An enjoyable episode with overall good performances barring a couple - also an emotional one with Manoj the Wordsmith , but without Neha’s aansoo 😁.

And finally… manoj repeated most of his shayari from the previous Maa episode of SS2 ( or was it Idol 12?)…

Manoj to TCT :- “ itne paise mein itnayich milega”🤪

Us :- no complaints sirji, after umpteen govindas, this is falooda. 🤣

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

12th Nov Maa special - manoj Munthasir, Varun Dhawan, Kriti Sanon.

Kavya :- That was one of the most flat renditions of Dilbaro I have ever heard. That’s the thing about kavya - it’s either a hit or a miss. For me, it was a miss this time. Kavya’s mom packed in so much feel in just those few lines. Beautiful rendition 👌

Shivam :- Chunar - A composition that tugs your heart. Shivam aced it. 👍. The feel, the improvisations everything was pat on. Shivam is going to be the Nihal for me - I used to think it will be Chirag earlier. But since the last couple of episodes Shivam is climbing up the ladder steadily. Wonderful rendition. Cried, clapped, enjoyed. 👌. MBD well-deserved

Debo :- Tu kitni achchi hai. A simple song, rendered well. But I thought they could’ve given her something more challenging. Maybe Dilbaro should’ve gone to her.

Vineet :- Meri Maa. The minute he started, I knew it’s going to be a kill. The entire vineet segment was so emotional without being melodramatic. Cried, clapped, enjoyed. 👍👌.

Rishi :- Surmayi ankhiyon. He brought in the softness needed for the song. He was better compared to the last couple of weeks. Maybe like Faiz, he could be back with a bang.

Sonakshi :- Lukka Chuppi. One of her bests. A tough ARR number delivered so beautifully. 👍👌. Should’ve got MBD.

Navdeep :- Baaghban. As usual, sang in his comfort zone & did well. 👍

Sanchari :- Neerja song - not so popular. Didn’t connect. I thought she went a bit offtune too.

Asides:-

* Vishal, not known to exhibit emotions, had me in tears recounting his own personal loss.

* Varun lipsynching the sargam part of Luka Chuppi - wow! 👍.

* sparklers today :- Shivam, Sona, vineet & kavya’s mom 😊

* An enjoyable episode with overall good performances barring a couple - also an emotional one with Manoj the Wordsmith , but without Neha’s aansoo 😁.

I don't think I need to write anything else. My views are 100% same.

Kavya was underwhelming.

Shivam surprised.

Sonakshi deserved MBD.

Rishi was excellent.

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

And finally… manoj repeated most of his shayari from the previous Maa episode of SS2 ( or was it Idol 12?)…

Manoj to TCT :- “ itne paise mein itnayich milega”🤪

Us :- no complaints sirji, after umpteen govindas, this is falooda. 🤣

🤣

Govinda se yaad aaya when is Dharmendra Ji coming?😆

Originally posted by: anoushka_113

* An enjoyable episode with overall good performances barring a couple - also an emotional one with Manoj the Wordsmith , but without Neha’s aansoo 😁.

Probably they couldn't adjust 6 seats so Neha missed😆