Created

Last reply

Replies

70

Views

14.8k

Users

19

Likes

227

Frequent Posters

Posted: 3 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Mehersudha

Hari , you brought a beautiful topic Manish whom I liked throughout his introduction in season2. He is stylish man and more handsome than his son having fantasy over bikes and bike riding. They have a class from introduction that Goenkas have false prestige, ego and attitude. Manish married soumya and had 2 kids kirti and kartik. Soumya had health troubles of mind and is in medication. She used to have fights with Manish for his secretary Swarna. but he was very calm .after Soumya expired he immediately married Swarna. Kartik thought they had affair and due to them his mom died but it's due to her over dose of medicine she expired. But none cleared this to kids as they are small. So manish too hate from kartik for 25 yrs and wanted to be with him close. Kartik never allowed him near he used to hate swarna and manish badly. It's Naira who brought them together and made their relationship strong . Manish told the reason that I don't want my kids to know about their mothers mental condition and have the impression on their minds at such young age so he took hate from kartik. He loves his family and binds them to be together. But he is grey for his reasons and societal pressure. It was always shown Manish is plus and minus to kaira in tracks . And all whitewashed in end helping kaira in end. The basic principles of singhus and Goenkas collide always .morals are taught but not practised here. During Naira death track Manish didn't leave Naira in bus. Naira gave kasm to leave him and get out of bus. That was their bond. And akshu brought happiness in family after her birth. Manish had accident and lost his brain behaved like a child in a track. But holding Akshu just born and coming to home changed him with small accident at home. So Akshu is always precious to them. But he was angry on kartik for holding Akshu most instead of giving to Naira. With sirat it's always compulsion from kartik and kairav. He never had proper bond close with her . It's always a strict father-in-law in him guiding her to take care of a kids equally. The way Manish is changed now for season3 is awesome. He is fedup of making Arohi understand sirats death and blaming Ak. Akshu took it in her peaceful way. And Abhi he is angry because he lost his trust on him for going idhar udhar. Akshu is his pride. He never thought she crosses this way to chose Abhi. So he is angry on her. Harsh being the main reason for not accepting Abhi. Being grandfather he has to restore her respect in her in-laws house. So he is not able to see that for Akshu in that house. That's why ghar badalke avo decision badlunga. Let's see how Abhi gets place in Manishs house. I see Manish as my father and father in-law generation so they are right in their way being stern to kids when they are wrong and love the kids when in needed.

He is always a special character from season2 having that bgm given in yesterday episode. That shows his ego and attitude. So he was back in that mode yesterday.


Loving season 2 Manish too hearing from you. The way you described him. I guess he knows to drive plane too na. He once helped in a plane landing saw a clip doesn't remember much.


Seems like he was the hero of season 2 with a bgm.


He so was ready to forgive ak but the kids doesn't give him a breathing space and shoot his bp. He is now in his egotic mode. This became a never ending circle and the one who pulled all of them is standing alone and watching all the drama. Talking aarohi over here.

Posted: 3 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

yeah i agree 👍 the only thing that i want to see manish being sensible compared to harsh putting out his concern infront of abhira as currently abhira is busy in pleasing manish only 😆 if manish puts out his concern that he is not agreeing because of so and so reason then they will focus on harsh which will speed up the process of getting approval from both the end. Coz abhi hates harsh so he does not care if harsh agrees or not. He knows his family(whom he includes in his family list except harsh) agrees for this once manish puts up his concern then everything will be crystal clear for abhira as they will know how to tackle this problem. First they can target harsh then manish this way problem would be resolved.😊

very well put the points. When we look at other family , they should have respect ,bond and trust in them . Manish already told aapka beta aapka respect nahi karta. So that shows arrogant attitude of him in his mind for his father. So when their relationships are not that good how can they give their daughter. Manjari is always confused and goes on Harshs words. Won't Manish guess them what they are and why they chose Arohi as bahu being doctor for their hospital. So he is standing strong and fighting for Ak respect same way like Abhi fought with Harsh. If Harsh changes his words and bends down it's fine orelse Abhi has to change family till then he won't bend. He might be calm after attack but Harsh has to make move.
Posted: 3 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Prachi1967

Actually..I talked my mother...nd posted in my post....my mother told....I don't told her about serial concept....just real life...my mother told ladke ne aisa kaun sa kaam kar diya ki maa baap Ko Vishwas ho jaayeah.....shaadi se pehle ladke ka khandan,status,parivar sab dekha jaata akele ladke k piche shaadi nahi hoti.........kal ko koi baat bigde ladka ladki toh alag....her roj ...koi samjahane wala...nd koi baat bigde toh koi bada ho....all parents hv this point of view


Your mom is so right. It's not about one is ok and the other elder not. It's a life long commitment where the kids need both families support.

Posted: 3 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: hari15


Loving season 2 Manish too hearing from you. The way you described him. I guess he knows to drive plane too na. He once helped in a plane landing saw a clip doesn't remember much.


Seems like he was the hero of season 2 with a bgm.


He so was ready to forgive ak but the kids doesn't give him a breathing space and shoot his bp. He is now in his egotic mode. This became a never ending circle and the one who pulled all of them is standing alone and watching all the drama. Talking aarohi over here.

He is a pvt pilot in his olden days. During keesh marriage they were all going in flight but suddenly the pilot gets fainted so with the help of copilot he takes it to reach destination. Keesh shadi episodes were awesome actually showing the bonds of both families. And bike rides he used to be teased by all in family that you are becoming young day by day. And he respects his wife mother daughter daughter in law. Though they have issues in time they used to sort out. His always famous diaLogue was Minister Saab ko phone karunga because he has closeness with him. But minister is never shown to us . Like yesterday Harsh told IG Saab se phone. Sachinji portrays all shades of Manish perfectly that I love him. He is young stylish father on ITV. Now also as grandfather he looks handsome.
Deep_deep thumbnail
Voyager Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: hari15

Manish has his flaws that is going to lead the story in its own way.

You pointed the right point out here. Why he accepted for aarohi not akshu. Aarohi fits birla's. They all are like rice kept in same pot. But akshu is different. We have seen how she suffers alone all pain. Yesterday when she said I can bear all pain but not this. So if being with abhi meant a suffering in another form she will take it.


Manish said it change your family I will give my daughter. Though he hasn't said much he has this fear and knows she might suffer in that house and won't tell anyone. He wants to trust birla's to give ak to them. About ar she will demand her wants like how birla's do and fight them won't suffer in the name of family love.


Harsh not accepting akshu is the biggest problem. Others are secondary relations but harsh will be her father - in - law another form of father a father figure. If he himself is the trouble then it's a life long suffering for her. She will always be struck between abhi and harsh as the father and son too doesn't have a good relationship. With akshu it will only increase and harsh will show it on ak like how he shows it on neil and manjari.

Guys do u think even if manish agrees, will harsh agree fr ak??? Lik suppose aftr adoption fact is out.. abhira builds their home nd then theres a grand marriage later .. will harsh participate in that???

I feel he may nt be happy or may even participate heartfully... but aftr abhira marriage nd ak comes into birla home, she may gradually change the dynamics of the fathr nd son.. nd aftr that probably harsh will talk abt kv ani marriag too nd sort that out..

firewings_diya thumbnail

Team Abhimanyu (Gen 3)

Posted: 3 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Mehersudha

very well put the points. When we look at other family , they should have respect ,bond and trust in them . Manish already told aapka beta aapka respect nahi karta. So that shows arrogant attitude of him in his mind for his father. So when their relationships are not that good how can they give their daughter. Manjari is always confused and goes on Harshs words. Won't Manish guess them what they are and why they chose Arohi as bahu being doctor for their hospital. So he is standing strong and fighting for Ak respect same way like Abhi fought with Harsh. If Harsh changes his words and bends down it's fine orelse Abhi has to change family till then he won't bend. He might be calm after attack but Harsh has to make move.

now i really feel abhi should be adopted😆

Posted: 3 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Deep_deep

Guys do u think even if manish agrees, will harsh agree fr ak??? Lik suppose aftr adoption fact is out.. abhira builds their home nd then theres a grand marriage later .. will harsh participate in that???

I feel he may nt be happy or may even participate heartfully... but aftr abhira marriage nd ak comes into birla home, she may gradually change the dynamics of the fathr nd son.. nd aftr that probably harsh will talk abt kv ani marriag too nd sort that out..

whole hearted acceptance may not be there. He might mellow down for his son. And in regular process he might change..because they can't make all positive at a time. They keep 3 people raised anytime as grey characters. Already Ar is there and Harsh ,mahima . When Manish is calm Harsh is raised. When Harsh is silent Manish is raised this week. Drama quotient will be balanced. That way Manish dadi were not happy with naira for kartik. They kept quiet for kittu happiness. It's always woh ladki e ladki e sab iski wajah se hua hi. But they changed slowly. Season2 diaLogues are on Harsh now. Kartik used to call Manish as Mr.Goenka and swarna as woh aurat. Now Abhi calls him as Sir.
Posted: 3 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Deep_deep

Guys do u think even if manish agrees, will harsh agree fr ak??? Lik suppose aftr adoption fact is out.. abhira builds their home nd then theres a grand marriage later .. will harsh participate in that???

I feel he may nt be happy or may even participate heartfully... but aftr abhira marriage nd ak comes into birla home, she may gradually change the dynamics of the fathr nd son.. nd aftr that probably harsh will talk abt kv ani marriag too nd sort that out..


When abhi asked harsh to not disturb manjari while drinking khada harsh had a smile na he and manjari the smiley couple will go with that very same smile to Manish house for akshu. That is it for now. 🥰🥰🥰


By the way I liked that smile of both very much that day.

Posted: 3 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: hari15


When abhi asked harsh to not disturb manjari while drinking khada harsh had a smile na he and manjari the smiley couple will go with that very same smile to Manish house for akshu. That is it for now. 🥰🥰🥰


By the way I liked that smile of both very much that day.

My Smiling Babloo and uski Pyari Bindu are the lovely 😍 couple that day. They are sooo adorable..
rittika thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (April 2022) Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Mehersudha

Hari , you brought a beautiful topic Manish whom I liked throughout his introduction in season2. He is stylish man and more handsome than his son having fantasy over bikes and bike riding. They have a class from introduction that Goenkas have false prestige, ego and attitude. Manish married soumya and had 2 kids kirti and kartik. Soumya had health troubles of mind and is in medication. She used to have fights with Manish for his secretary Swarna. but he was very calm .after Soumya expired he immediately married Swarna. Kartik thought they had affair and due to them his mom died but it's due to her over dose of medicine she expired. But none cleared this to kids as they are small. So manish too hate from kartik for 25 yrs and wanted to be with him close. Kartik never allowed him near he used to hate swarna and manish badly. It's Naira who brought them together and made their relationship strong . Manish told the reason that I don't want my kids to know about their mothers mental condition and have the impression on their minds at such young age so he took hate from kartik. He loves his family and binds them to be together. But he is grey for his reasons and societal pressure. It was always shown Manish is plus and minus to kaira in tracks . And all whitewashed in end helping kaira in end. The basic principles of singhus and Goenkas collide always .morals are taught but not practised here. During Naira death track Manish didn't leave Naira in bus. Naira gave kasm to leave him and get out of bus. That was their bond. And akshu brought happiness in family after her birth. Manish had accident and lost his brain behaved like a child in a track. But holding Akshu just born and coming to home changed him with small accident at home. So Akshu is always precious to them. But he was angry on kartik for holding Akshu most instead of giving to Naira. With sirat it's always compulsion from kartik and kairav. He never had proper bond close with her . It's always a strict father-in-law in him guiding her to take care of a kids equally. The way Manish is changed now for season3 is awesome. He is fedup of making Arohi understand sirats death and blaming Ak. Akshu took it in her peaceful way. And Abhi he is angry because he lost his trust on him for going idhar udhar. Akshu is his pride. He never thought she crosses this way to chose Abhi. So he is angry on her. Harsh being the main reason for not accepting Abhi. Being grandfather he has to restore her respect in her in-laws house. So he is not able to see that for Akshu in that house. That's why ghar badalke avo decision badlunga. Let's see how Abhi gets place in Manishs house. I see Manish as my father and father in-law generation so they are right in their way being stern to kids when they are wrong and love the kids when in needed.

He is always a special character from season2 having that bgm given in yesterday episode. That shows his ego and attitude. So he was back in that mode yesterday.

Waooo very beautiful


yes manish is grey character and right if not agreeging for akshu , he has his point which are valid to and extent but then going ahead and getting an innocent insulted and arrested was too much.
he wanted to talk yes he was adamanet yes abhi was impulsive but manish was immature.


but yes his viewpoint of not agreeing for mareiage make sense but hope this viewpoint came in fore when he agreed for arohi rishta or for thta matter when swarna jinxed the abhira rishta.


as an elder he could have thought of clarifying with abhi as he was the one who got rishta anwways they are gone now but to me at this point all are right and all are wrong

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: A_Star39

26 days ago

Swarna Goenka-Tribute to immortal vampire!

Miss Swarna Goenka.A women who has eaten lives of her sons,Daughter in laws,Granddaughters and their husbands,even great grand son in laws and...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa

28 days ago

Manish Goenka ki zindagi

I was watching old episodes (Akshara's death sequence Gen 1) where both Akshara's (Hina) dadi and Manish Goenka were shown in the same episode....

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: MsWhiskerson

4 months ago

Team The Immortal Fossil Manish Goenka - please moderators

https://youtu.be/6WLTaRagAIo?si=r_WHbXytBssEt-yA Manish slapped Abhir and earned my undying support with this Moderators, why is there a team...

https://youtu.be/6WLTaRagAIo?si=r_WHbXytBssEt-yA
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

3 months ago

Swarna and Manish should play Kairav and Muskan

They should not play Great Great Great. Swarna is not aging it looks so fake even Baa from Khunki saas still look realistic

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".