Is Abhimanyu really Manjari's son - Page 2

Originally posted by: Ekahriz

But what I don't understand is the adoption papers. Like it says, the adoption was from an orphanage. Some sevasadan or something if I am correct. And also they showed a 4/5 year old boy?

There could be more to this story. She could have maybe already married and left her own son for this family and abhi. We can't be definite about this because she is in a web of lies that even her own family doesn't know.

Originally posted by: Ekahriz

You clarified a lot of things I had doubts about when I thought is there a possibility that Abhi is not Manjari's son. Now I think he is definitely Harsh's son but might not be Manjari's. Probably why she is so over compensating with her motherly love for him. Why she is so desperate to prove she is a good mom and deserves him. I also think Manjari pushing Abhi to marry ( her falling sick at the prospect of him being a forever bachelor due to his unrequited love) is because she is scared that she failed in her duty as a mother in ensuring her son settled down, rather than giving primacy to his happiness. It's all about herself, and her motherhood and not about Abhi and his happiness.

The scene where she says, after he was born he didn't cry for a few minutes, I thought he is totally her son. But it could be that, Harsh had an affair or his ex-wife's health was so bad, the plan was already in motion that Manjari was going to raise the new born as her kid. And she probably looked forward to his birth so she can be a mom finally.

And in the next scene after she says this, is Abhi hugging her and telling her not to break his trust. And I think those words really hold some power.

This word was what had always caught me to think about the mom son relationship. Why makers would all of a sudden make abhi tell such a powerful dialogue because Manjari got akshu for b'day party

Originally posted by: hari15

Ok i am completely talking about a person who we don't want to hear anything about but i had badly wanted to speak about her today so here I am.

I don't how many reasons we can give to state the fact that Abhimanyu is Manjari's son but I do have 100's of atleast 10 reasons to say Abhimanyu is not Manjari's son.

1. The first episode where she called him abhi told my mother knows me so well that she called me when I sped the bike. But is that why Manjari called him.

No.

She told Abhi that he needs to go to hospital as his father is calling him continuously.

2. Abhi told Manjari that she is the one who taught him how he should become a great doctor. She could have taught him to be anything. The guy throws punch like no other so Abhimanyu Birla could have become a boxer.

No. Why doctor

Because somewhere this woman wanted a recognition from her husband and other family members at least through Abhimanyu. To show how good she had bought him up.

3. The woman who claims to know her son's heartbeat didn't she know for her son being a doctor alone won't have mattered. He respects all woman doesn't matter if she is doctor or not. But when he spoke about aarohi being a doctor her head was struck their.

4. During engagement fiasco yes she is the one who spoke about getting his true love but was she being stubborn enough in it. The moment akshu rejected him she was like it's ok beta doesn't matter. You have your reasons. Atleast did she try to know the reason.

No

It was like she was waiting akshu to reject abhi.

5. Did she give anytime and space for her son. Even a brainless person won't do something like this. The very next day she gave a doctor doll in her son's hand forced him to hold it. Didn't she once see his torn heart and crying face.

Personally if I tell my mother I don't want to get married to a guy he can be good, rich, a full package one want but still a mother would stop that wedding for her kids happiness shouldn't she.

But here no the wedding is happening because Anand and Harsh want a doctor babu. Then what about what her son wants.

6. See all the wedding preparation going on it is like wedding of the century of a golden couple. Can't she feel the helplessness of her son. That he wants nothing more than to run away and hide somewhere.

I have my assumptions over this whole. What if Abhi is abopted? What if Manjari isn't the mother?

I think in a way Abhi and Akshara might be same. It could be simple as that Abhi might me Harsh girlfriend or ex- wife son like how Akshu is Naira's daughter. Unlike Karthik and Sirat Harsh would have been forced into this marriage by family to take care of Abhi. Those adoption papers might be official name transfer of Abhi being Manjari son.

I feel it because Manjari can be a loving mother but she and Sirat give me the same vibe somewhere.

If Naira was alive and bought up Akshu and had Aarohi as another daughter she won't have told Akshu to adjust for anything and everything. Somewhere Sirat showed a step mother feel unconsciously.

Manjari too I feel like does the same she might love Abhi and see him as her son but somewhere she uses him too for her own needs. It's like she had bind him in her mother's love like how akshu had been bind by Sirat's love.

Originally posted by: Ekahriz

You clarified a lot of things I had doubts about when I thought is there a possibility that Abhi is not Manjari's son. Now I think he is definitely Harsh's son but might not be Manjari's. Probably why she is so over compensating with her motherly love for him. Why she is so desperate to prove she is a good mom and deserves him. I also think Manjari pushing Abhi to marry ( her falling sick at the prospect of him being a forever bachelor due to his unrequited love) is because she is scared that she failed in her duty as a mother in ensuring her son settled down, rather than giving primacy to his happiness. It's all about herself, and her motherhood and not about Abhi and his happiness.

The scene where she says, after he was born he didn't cry for a few minutes, I thought he is totally her son. But it could be that, Harsh had an affair or his ex-wife's health was so bad, the plan was already in motion that Manjari was going to raise the new born as her kid. And she probably looked forward to his birth so she can be a mom finally.

And in the next scene after she says this, is Abhi hugging her and telling her not to break his trust. And I think those words really hold some power.

Originally posted by: Zenab78

Couldn't agree more Dear

You have observed it very well

Manjiri is not mother but someone else is mother of Abhimanyu.

Manjiri not being actual mother makes her more possessive towards Abhimanyu. She never wants that truth to come out that is why she always asks Abhi not to fight with his father.

In initial episode we saw Abhi and Akshara connected through pain and they both had families yet they were alone and this is actual pain which they wanted to indicate... They both will have same pain Akshu was a 10 yr kid but Abhi is not a kid it will be more devastating for him coz he has clearly spent half of his life Believing this lie. They will be strength for each other after truth revelation.

Couldn't agree more with your points 👍👍

It's always her trying to prove she is the best mother.

When she saw aarohi in temple and told it was her who convinced akshu. She indirectly took credit of best mom.

Then her match making aarohi abhi family started to praise her and Harsh too became good with her. Atleast no yelling and roaring.

Then about abhira. Both were with family yet never got that belonging feeling. Subconsciously they both know they are missing something in their life.

Originally posted by: Mehersudha

Bang on dear. This Manjari is the raita mata from day1 and we are unable to catch her as she is moving fast like wind and she is running the story from day1 till now with her confusions as we thought. But she is the real vamp in Abhira story. You pointed a points from day1 where her actions and words contradict. I doubt if Abhi knows regarding his secret as Manjari fell down acting when Harsh and abhi fought. She is half as Harsh in making his deeds done till now. The way she diverted Abhi towards Arohi is the suspicion for audience out by cvs as no mother will do in a next day immediately knowing his heart runs for Ak. Manjari seems dangerous than Mahima. I sti remember Abhi saying I only trust you mom don't break it when this Arohi jaap was about to start as Ak broke his trust. So at the end of this track it's Manjari exposed with adoption paper when Arohi is exposed by Abhi. So the chain goes in blaming bashing adjusting along with Abhira earning for each other. In the end Abhi will get Ak as his strength when everything comes out. As Adoption paper is not needed now if Neil is adopted by any chance. Abhi is definitely Harsh son and Abhira are put in same pain and situation for emo bond towards Arohi and Manjari. Manjari and sirat are the selfish moms who used Abhira for their own purpose. I personally want Abhira go away from this hell and stay out like kaira stayed initially.

Someone spoke what I've felt for so long. Manjiri n Sirat have very similar kind of parenting towards Abhi n Akshu which is to adjust for Someone else's happiness.

This is the moment I so wish Naira was here. Even though she also tried the sacrifice game but she never went ott with pushing Gayu down Kartik's throat. Here I feel Akshu ki responsibility is taking over her own feelings. This is the difference between step n real.

Why not Akshu Arohi ek dusre ka khayal rakhna?

Also I really want Kairav to have his training sessions with his mamu who has been a good brother. Learn something just because I won't diffentiate how do I stand n see one being exploited by the other over a stupid promise? Even this is unfair.

Originally posted by: hari15

Couldn't agree more with your points 👍👍

It's always her trying to prove she is the best mother.

When she saw aarohi in temple and told it was her who convinced akshu. She indirectly took credit of best mom.

Then her match making aarohi abhi family started to praise her and Harsh too became good with her. Atleast no yelling and roaring.

Then about abhira. Both were with family yet never got that belonging feeling. Subconsciously they both know they are missing something in their life.

You know guys doesn't matter what this Raita Mata does. Give her a award stating BEST MOM everyday that is enough for her. Everyone said in the beginning Manjari and Akshu are same right no. It's Manjari and Aarohi who are same that's why they are glued. BEST KO BEST MILINI CHAHIYE. Best sasu and bahu. 👏👏

Originally posted by: Mehersudha

Adding another point to above all yours remember Ak saying kv in initial episodes when she had panic attack and came from hospital sat on bench that my pain will be understood by a person who is alone staying in a family like me. So abhiras pain is same. Cvs ki jai ho they are connecting all dialogues back with scenes.

I don't know about abhira connecting dots but we are doing it really well. JAI HO to us 😆👍🏼👏