Another perspective - A few questions for Imlie - Page 2

Originally posted by: brat2008

@ bold

Just asking with my really limited knowledge of the law 😕

Is an instigator for a crime convicted ever? Since Malini did not pull the trigger directly

Is it a punishable offense ?
I have no idea about the sections etc etc of the law 😒

malini never said to Satyakaam to go take Aditya away and shoot him in some secluded place.. she called him and said that Aditya loves only her and take Imlie away from here..

Since her intention was not to kill she cannot be the mastermind of that episode and whatever happened was purely Satyakaam’s action ..

As rightly questioned by Aditya to SK( rare case I say this serial is right lol) he asks SK what if someone comes and says something abt Imlie tomorrow and I blindly believe them then how would you (SK) feel.

it’s all up to individual judgement .. the world is full of pranksters and instigators .. not all have same intentions but a person has to stand his own moral ground before shooting a gun ..and here Aditya was not some random person hanging out with his daughter but his son in law.. when Adi sat SK and Mithi at the lodge and explained to them his messy situation , how can SK then blindly distrust that same Adi without giving a chance to speak ..and Imlies Mata logic don’t even ask.. she never fought or went to jail against the villagers, her nani, Aditya when he refused her initially and SK twice for attempt to murder.. it’s the intent to kill that convicts .. yes SK had intent to kill Malini didnt ..

And Imlie mata wilfully let a girl marry his husband that is also cheating .. but makers won’t show that..

All done to spoil and butcher Malini’s image and character for viewers and along with it SK character also butchered..

Originally posted by: mili9

Ditto, ditto, I am wondering about this too, my friend😳 Same with limited knowledge about the law. Just enough common sense not to get into trouble🤔

Didn't Imli let Satyakaam who calls himself an activist get away with attempted murder? Woh aparaadh nahin hain? That Imlie who fights for everybody's just life, is now partial to her dad and calls it a misunderstanding? Even then, she kept harping Malini incited the bechara Satyakaam to pull the trigger? How the hell does she know that? A call came from T residence. Was there a recording of the voice and forensic analysis? There are many women in T residence, how do you zero in on Malini?

I still don't understand how this is about social justice. Malini is supposedly drugged too along with the Adi guy. Other than taunting Imlie that she did the needful, she didn't admit that she "molested" Adi guy in front of anybody. So, how did they come up with the allegation that " Malini drugged and molested Adi guy". Even the lawyer guy is chanting this. Did they do a drug screen on both and find out that Malini didn't have any drugs and Adi guy did? As of now, going by what is known (both of them being drugged and doing hte deed ), at best it can be termed as an accident, how is it that the guy became the victim and the girl is the culprit in the eyes of the law? How did they bring this allegation on a hunch from Imlie? Based on this hunch, a supposedly gaon wali ladki ( I am not using this in a derogatory sense, but giving the context ) orders the police guys to arrest a person and they arrest her? Somebody who has connections with the central minister? Chalo jee, I salute the police guys here. And suddenly dhoka, aparaadh and more buzz words are being used? May be now a video will appear or fingerprints on the bottle with whatever drug, GHB or whatever it is, will be sensationally presented by Imlie

How is that burnt saree evidence of this far-fetched story? Let us just say that I hate my neighbor and I accuse him of coming in and destroying my back yard, because he has access to it and that one of the pine cones is found in his premises. Can I order his arrest? And say I will gather proofs at a later date, just the lock the guy up for now? 😡If people can accuse and get other people arrested on a hunch or because you don't like their face , who can live freely in this world? Is the law and order so weak that you can use it as a tool to avenge your enemies? 🤬Where is this law?😡

That KC guy has his own axe to grind. I know that this show will completely decimate Malini and her character and burn her down to the ashes. It is very sad to see this, this is obviously not justice in real life, but that written by the Gods of the show, the writers

oh goodness! You expect too much from this show .. this show has potrayed things wrongly from the time Adi got married to Malini .. till that point the serial was okayish and the cast seemed refreshing and due to work from home situation and dinner time slot I had started watching this .. but after Holi episode I dare not play this before family and only see in Hotstar ..

Imlie is the lead , she is always right ..

but makers can’t digest Malini having a huge following of her own ..so done deliberately to tarnish her character and silence audiences who had been sympathetic towards Malini.. but the writing and execution of the scenes is so pathetic what to say..

Imlie can deep dive into valley, she can fight off thieves to terrorists to kidnappers, miraculously top the state.. she can also accuse anyone but the minute someone says something to her she kucho nahi jaanat hai.. so she lets Aditya marry Malini, let SK go Scott free on two murder attempts .. forgives Nani easily when in fact she was responsible for ending her dreams .. still proudly talks about her village given their regressive stupid customs ..

Heights is that today’s episode even judge didn’t cross questionAditya as to why he married Malini when Imlie was already his wife .. kaunsa judge hai yaar.. who does that ?? People know how police lawyers grill but here even the judge is made mute by makers and writers .. ulta first charges would have been slapped against Imlie and Aditya as Malini could directly have said Adityas action led her to all this .. her path is wrong but she alone doesn’t deserve punishment too .. just like Imlie mata dialogue when she let go SK ..

Malini could have been punished IF she specifically instigated SK to kill Adi. That is a crime. Niether she had the intention nor her words implied that SK kill Adi so she cannot be punished for it. Abettment to do a crime is also a crime but that's not the case here

FInally someone is discussing abut SKs crime and Imlies partiality . This show is full of hypocresy.

Originally posted by: Divi1301

oh goodness! You expect too much from this show .. this show has potrayed things wrongly from the time Adi got married to Malini .. till that point the serial was okayish and the cast seemed refreshing and due to work from home situation and dinner time slot I had started watching this .. but after Holi episode I dare not play this before family and only see in Hotstar ..

Imlie is the lead , she is always right ..

but makers can’t digest Malini having a huge following of her own ..so done deliberately to tarnish her character and silence audiences who had been sympathetic towards Malini.. but the writing and execution of the scenes is so pathetic what to say..

Imlie can deep dive into valley, she can fight off thieves to terrorists to kidnappers, miraculously top the state.. she can also accuse anyone but the minute someone says something to her she kucho nahi jaanat hai.. so she lets Aditya marry Malini, let SK go Scott free on two murder attempts .. forgives Nani easily when in fact she was responsible for ending her dreams .. still proudly talks about her village given their regressive stupid customs ..

Heights is that today’s episode even judge didn’t cross questionAditya as to why he married Malini when Imlie was already his wife .. kaunsa judge hai yaar.. who does that ?? People know how police lawyers grill but here even the judge is made mute by makers and writers .. ulta first charges would have been slapped against Imlie and Aditya as Malini could directly have said Adityas action led her to all this .. her path is wrong but she alone doesn’t deserve punishment too .. just like Imlie mata dialogue when she let go SK ..

Good evening! Kya karein, my friend, my head is spinning with the justifications offered to the cheater couple in this show. The greatness of Imlie and the arrogance of Adi guy are so jarring🤢

@ bold....So, the judge didn't bat an eye with admission in the court of law that this guy has two wives😡Haan, we understand that the crime at hand is molestation. But why isn't bigamy not addressed when they have all proofs that came out in the open from the horses mouth? Like if you go see a doctor for a toe itch and in the process, you have a heart attack, usse nahin address kartein because the problem at hand is the toe itch? 😡🤬 What stupidity?

And I am not an lawyer, so correct me if I am totally off mark. But I am assuming any profession would have some professional ethics such as maintaining your client's privacy. Yeh disheveled lawyer guy just blurts out in the court what his once client, Malini asked him to do? He thought it is such a sensational comment from which he would gain something to prove? Looks like he has his own axe to grind against Malini more than his interest in proving the molestation charges. Toh, if she wanted to postpone divorce, how does it prove the allegation? Woh cheater couple bhi at one time asked her to postpone the divorce for their own reasons. I don't remember for what.

But today, it seems like Karma is biting both Imlie and Adi guy on the behind😃 I know it won't last long, but for today, I will be happy for Malini. Ek choti si reprieve thi👍🏼I don't care for the means or the acts🤢. Both of them experienced firsthand what it feels like when your life gets dragged from underneath you, for a reason you can't fathom👍🏼 Especially Adi guy's angst of investing 10 years of his life to his work🤣. Ab samajh aaya how it feels when you snatch away something precious, like somebody's emotions and make fun of them? Humiliate them by saying that a big chunk of their life and their moments with you are a farce? Take them through false pretenses and then backstab them? I wish the newspaper fired the guy for bigamy. It is cringeworthy hearing his co-workers talking casually about his " do shadiyaan"🤬Shame on you writers, that you would let this guy get away with bigamy. Because of this, even though they are trying to bring in a crime such as molestation in, I feel nothing for the guy🤔 Because, my mind digs up dirt on the guy, so much so that I don't really care what happens to him👎🏼.

I feel slightly bad for Imlie,🤔 but I don't feel that bad😲. I am a little disturbed by my lack of feeling. Again, because of the self righteous path the writers gave this young girl and complete lack of remorse for cheating Malini and decimating her life by being an accomplice with Adi guy, I can't forgive this girl too. I am not proud of my lack of feeling for a young girl losing her education, but I am truly fed up with her greatness and eternal gyaan. My brain turns off the moment I see her distributing free ka knowledge and wisdom around🤢I won't say anymore.....

Why is Adi guy going along with this case if he doesn't feel that it is right? He is not a minor that he has to comply with mommy's direction? Am I missing anything here? This guy is an opportunist, always looking for an easy way out of situation. Kya pata, Imlie could do all the work and maybe, just may be, he can get out of this free without a scratch😡.

Ek ajeeb sa sukoon mila, like a balm on a burning heart For today. The writers will burn down Malini to ashes and nothingness soon🤬. It is very sad that they have to give the only normal, relatable character this trajectory😡

That is it from me.....

Originally posted by: mili9

Good evening! Kya karein, my friend, my head is spinning with the justifications offered to the cheater couple in this show. The greatness of Imlie and the arrogance of Adi guy are so jarring🤢

@ bold....So, the judge didn't bat an eye with admission in the court of law that this guy has two wives😡Haan, we understand that the crime at hand is molestation. But why isn't bigamy not addressed when they have all proofs that came out in the open from the horses mouth? Like if you go see a doctor for a toe itch and in the process, you have a heart attack, usse nahin address kartein because the problem at hand is the toe itch? 😡🤬 What stupidity?

And I am not an lawyer, so correct me if I am totally off mark. But I am assuming any profession would have some professional ethics such as maintaining your client's privacy. Yeh disheveled lawyer guy just blurts out in the court what his once client, Malini asked him to do? He thought it is such a sensational comment from which he would gain something to prove? Looks like he has his own axe to grind against Malini more than his interest in proving the molestation charges. Toh, if she wanted to postpone divorce, how does it prove the allegation? Woh cheater couple bhi at one time asked her to postpone the divorce for their own reasons. I don't remember for what.

But today, it seems like Karma is biting both Imlie and Adi guy on the behind😃 I know it won't last long, but for today, I will be happy for Malini. Ek choti si reprieve thi👍🏼I don't care for the means or the acts🤢. Both of them experienced firsthand what it feels like when your life gets dragged from underneath you, for a reason you can't fathom👍🏼 Especially Adi guy's angst of investing 10 years of his life to his work🤣. Ab samajh aaya how it feels when you snatch away something precious, like somebody's emotions and make fun of them? Humiliate them by saying that a big chunk of their life and their moments with you are a farce? Take them through false pretenses and then backstab them? I wish the newspaper fired the guy for bigamy. It is cringeworthy hearing his co-workers talking casually about his " do shadiyaan"🤬Shame on you writers, that you would let this guy get away with bigamy. Because of this, even though they are trying to bring in a crime such as molestation in, I feel nothing for the guy🤔 Because, my mind digs up dirt on the guy, so much so that I don't really care what happens to him👎🏼.

I feel slightly bad for Imlie,🤔 but I don't feel that bad😲. I am a little disturbed by my lack of feeling. Again, because of the self righteous path the writers gave this young girl and complete lack of remorse for cheating Malini and decimating her life by being an accomplice with Adi guy, I can't forgive this girl too. I am not proud of my lack of feeling for a young girl losing her education, but I am truly fed up with her greatness and eternal gyaan. My brain turns off the moment I see her distributing free ka knowledge and wisdom around🤢I won't say anymore.....

Why is Adi guy going along with this case if he doesn't feel that it is right? He is not a minor that he has to comply with mommy's direction? Am I missing anything here? This guy is an opportunist, always looking for an easy way out of situation. Kya pata, Imlie could do all the work and maybe, just may be, he can get out of this free without a scratch😡.

Ek ajeeb sa sukoon mila, like a balm on a burning heart For today. The writers will burn down Malini to ashes and nothingness soon🤬. It is very sad that they have to give the only normal, relatable character this trajectory😡

That is it from me.....

At bold ..according to Imlie makers their way is the highway🤣🤣🤣 sigh way for us 🤣🤣🤣
I somehow always find Sumbuls expression outright cunning .. example see the chai utensil snatching episode .. then the next minute she says kucho nahi jaanat with tears and hell it looks so fake and immature.. Mayuri is comparatively a seasoned actress and she’s given decent performances in whichever role..Gashmeer’s dad was a good and famous actor but Gashmeer himself was considered a flop actor till Imlie happened and his fate now turned... ST still has a long way to go.. and going by the flak Imlies character received from many I seriously doubt !!she Edited by DT and everyone now knows how Bollywood and television industry true nature is so I just don’t care ..

ok so Aditya directly sleeping on the bed over losing his job of 10 years but when Mayuri did the same because Aditya didn’t inform any family member and Malini about his whereabouts she was expected to act all okay and fine and smile .. Aditya fell sick many times too out of worry for Imlie only that is love rest all fake ..Aditya’s passion was his job and Malini’s saath as per his claim .. Mayuri’s passion was Aditya as per her claim .. as she saw her parents always fighting Aditya had become her everything ..but the confession to Malini episode was so badly executed ..how can a person treat his weddings as a joke .. jab man kiya ek shaadi manli and dusri toh aise behave karta hai jaise ki hi nahi..she fainted ok but that’s before wedding na .. post wedding immediately Aditya could have told Malini abt PD episode ..and then they would have ended the matter then and there .. even after confession to Malini he delayed confession to family .tab kaun faint hua tha??. it’s all bad writing nothing else..which made the leads lose their own ground ..

and I still don’t get the point of this track ..

When Tripathis got to know about Aditya Imlie wedding . Malini was a positive character then .. even then Tripathis didn’t accept Imlie in fact even when Malini said Imlie is not a maid she is her sister they were more furious saying that makes them repel her even more ..

So with Malini getting negative or ending her character how does that make Imlie accepted by them ?? Are they fine with SK’s two direct attempts to murder on Aditya .. so going by shows logic he’s a criminal too and will he be so called samdhi for them ??.. what about Nani and Meethi the opportunists - one who married Imlie forcefully and Meethi after having consensual relation crying foul all her life as if it was only Devs fault .. they would want such inlaws for Aditya ??

Edited by DT

I in most of my posts I mention on the writing and loopholes and makers only ..

this was long .. I will reappear after few days like always ..

Originally posted by: pink_doughnut

Hi everyone! Don't get me wrong, I love Imlie, and I think Malini is so ghatiya she cannot be redeemed in any way. But I have a few questions for Imli.

1) I love the message being given in the show; men can be victims of SA too. But my question is, is it not the victim's prerogative as to whether he wants to file the case in court or not? Because he is the one with the greatest trauma. It is not Imlie's right to make that decision for him right?

2. Definitely, Malini should go to jail for her heinous act. But if Imlie truly believes in justice then why doesn't she fight for justice for Adi against Satyakam? And by her logic, Adi did do an immense wrong with Malini by marrying her; he should be in jail too. I am not bashing Imlie; I also know for a fact that all human beings including me have a propsensity to protect our loved ones even at the expense of our integrity. But Imlie's constant jaap of "Sita mayya" and all that, does she have the moral high-ground to do that? Isn't she a hypocrite too?

SK tried to kill Adi twice rite ?? Then why did Imlie easily forget that?? And forgave him?? No one instigated him the first time , still??

And even if the second time Malini instigated him, she and SK will be punished differently in the eyes of law .. But Imlie was behaving as if both will get an equal level of punishment which is clearly not the case as per law ..so she’s clearly ignorant or doing it out of revenge for Malini just to get her punished by hook or crook..SK has two attempt to murders to account for ..Malini calling and asking SK to take Imlie away doesn’t even come close to that..

SK tried to kill Adi twice rite ?? Then why did Imlie easily forget that?? And forgave him?? No one instigated him the first time , still??

And even if the second time Malini instigated him, she and SK will be punished differently in the eyes of law .. But Imlie was behaving as if both will get an equal level of punishment which is clearly not the case as per law ..so she’s clearly ignorant or doing it out of revenge for Malini just to get her punished by hook or crook..SK has two attempt to murders to account for ..Malini calling and asking SK to take Imlie away doesn’t even come close to that..

When did Malini called SK and asking him to take Imlie .

She told Sk , that despite Imlie with Aditya, he still Love Malini . She practically draging Aditya for shopping, pretending to buy things for Imlie . She assume by saying Aditya still love Malini . SK will take Imlie away . Her plan backfired.

About Imlie , after the truth reveal, let’s wait and see what action Imlie will take for SK . If Aditya forgive him . You and I can’t said much .

What SK did was wrong. Usne aditya ko baat bhi kerne nae de. But we can't ignore the fact usko is point par Malini le kar aye usay laga woh imlie ko le jae ga but Malini ko ye nae pata k pd k log asa bunday ko punish Kertay hain. Shadi kerwa suktay hain.

Jaan boojh kar Malini ne aditya ke life Khatray mein Dale. Aditya Mujhe jewellery phena dain ase harkaten Ken to kya SK aditya ko like Kare ga?

Dono wrong hain par usay bulaia kis ne Malini ne.us ka gunah ziada ha.

What SK did was wrong. Usne aditya ko baat bhi kerne nae de. But we can't ignore the fact usko is point par Malini le kar aye usay laga woh imlie ko le jae ga but Malini ko ye nae pata k pd k log asa bunday ko punish Kertay hain. Shadi kerwa suktay hain.

Jaan boojh kar Malini ne aditya ke life Khatray mein Dale. Aditya Mujhe jewellery phena dain ase harkaten Ken to kya SK aditya ko like Kare ga?

Dono wrong hain par usay bulaia kis ne Malini ne.us ka gunah ziada ha.

Agreed, compare to Malini , SK punishment should be more severe , he didn’t give chance to Aditya to explained and clarify the situation. Even as a father , he has right to behave such a way . Imlie can’t be bias .

Giving excuses of Malini instigating SK to do crime .

My argument here is , Malini called SK to take Imlie away . Did she ask SK to take Imlie away ?