One more test of Faith - Page 17

Created

Last reply

Replies

291

Views

13.5k

Users

26

Likes

1.3k

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Josupra


SK you tried to kill him twice, at least now stop your vengeance. You forgave the actual culprit just like that and going after an innocent.. bahut hogaya.. ab please go to where ever forest you usually live in for few months. I used to love your character but anyone who takes a life that easily cannot be forgiven.


Wait, you are upset with SK cuz he is a killer? 😆 Oh come on.....what did everyone think he was doing all this time that he's been running around as a Krantikaari? 😆.....haath mein bandook li hai toh obviously lives bhi leta hai woh.


The issue is not that he can't take a life....heck he's been practicing this brand of self-proclaimed justice court since a long time now....but pehle people were cheering it on cuz they thought he always got justice right and only punished the wrong😆. But that's the thing - no one is perfect.....even justice warriors.


For me, everything always comes down to INTENT. Was SK's action wrong? Ofcourse it was....he did something in impulse without rationalizing it fully. But his intent was coming from a place of fierce love and protection for his daughter....a genuine love, not the china ka maal version that Didi goes around proclaiming. So he did what he felt was needed to free his daughter of someone he felt was betraying her. This is SK's brand of justice - it always ends with death only - there is never a grey area.


Characters like SK can make wrong decisions and take wrong actions but they will all still be far better than the likes of Didi who has crossed all limits in what is stemming from a fundamentally wrong INTENT. SK didn't shoot Adi to snatch someone else's rights.....but Didi is going around manipulating, cheating, lying simply to snatch things from others. That is the difference....and that is why I don't see that it's going to be hard to redeem SK....he will be genuinely remorseful and Adi will understand where he was coming from.

Edited by AreYaar - 4 years ago
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: AreYaar


Wait, you are upset with SK cuz he is a killer? 😆 Oh come on.....what did everyone think he was doing all this time that he's been running around as a Krantikaari? 😆.....haath mein bandook lie hai toh obviously lives bhi leta hai woh.


The issue is not that he can't take a life....heck he's been practicing this brand of self-proclaimed justice court since a long time now....but pehle people were cheering it on cuz they thought he always got justice right and only punished the wrong😆. But that's the thing - no one is perfect.....even justice warriors.


For me, everything always comes down to INTENT. Was SK's action wrong? Ofcourse it was....he did something in impulse without rationalizing it fully. But his intent was coming from a place of fierce love and protection for his daughter....a genuine love, not the china ka maal version that Didi goes around proclaiming. So he did what he felt was needed to free his daughter of someone he felt was betraying her. This is SK's brand of justice - it always ends with death only - there is never a grey area.


Characters can SK can make wrong decisions and take wrong actions but they will all still be far better than the likes of Didi who has crossed all limits in what is stemming from a fundamentally wrong INTENT. SK didn't shoot Adi to snatch someone else's rights.....but Didi is going around manipulating, cheating, lying simply to snatch things from others. That is the difference....and that is why I don't see that it's going to be hard to redeem SK....he will be genuinely remorseful and Adi will understand where he was coming from.


+100 toh all this..again let's not forget what SK is told too and he verified too before reaching..he is trapped for real too in believing what his eyes were seeing..so for me sk ain't the culprit here yeah the gun was in his hand but trigger toh didi ne hi chalaya na..by misusing his love for his beti and his trust on adi..hence am not mad at sk per say..


My only issue with him has been the fact that he is biased when it comes to adi it is different rules but for DC he still gives imlie lectures ke she should be accepting when she refuses that is my problem..yeah time has past but then it was long gone when the whole reveal to adi happened in PD too and sk was fierce I want that sk for DC too bas mera woh hai

Edited by naadanmasakalli - 4 years ago
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Btw plz tell me am not the only one who is disliking this ta ra ra ra dhin ta na na wala new soundtrack .. it is too mehhhh and I feel aona original sad pieces would work better

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: naadanmasakalli


+100 toh all this..again let's not forget what SK is told too and he verified too before reaching..he is trapped for real too in believing what his eyes were seeing..so for me sk ain't the culprit here yeah the gun was in his hand but trigger toh didi ne hi chalaya na..but missing his love for his beti and his trust on adi..hence am not mad at sk per say..


My only issue with him has been the fact that he is biased when it comes to adi it is different rules but for DC he still gives imlie lectures ke she should be accepting when she refuses that is my problem..yeah time has past but then it was long gone when the whole reveal to adi happened in PD too and sk was fierce I want that sk for DC too bas mera woh hai


Oh see now this is a valid complaint absolutely....the real butchering of SK happened when they mellowed him about DC....but I still feel that was more of a momentary contrivance and basically, once Mithi married him, SK felt more assured that she is over DC toh he mellowed on that front😆.


Adi ke case mein I guess he is upset cuz he feels Imlie loves Adi but he is cheating her....isliye zyada gussa dikhaa raha hai on Adi than with DC. I feel he considers DC too much of a sniveling coward anyways😆....Adi se gussa hai but he respects him more than DC😆.


Baaki the other big loophole is ki SK doesn't wonder why so called "badi behen" bolne waali Malni bhi Imlie ko cheat kar rahi hai by hooking up with ex-pati.....lol maybe that's the contrast....all the sheheri people are quick to cast blame on the woman (Imlie) while gaaonwaale blame the man primarily (even if it's unwarranted in some cases😆).

Josupra thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: AreYaar


Wait, you are upset with SK cuz he is a killer? 😆 Oh come on.....what did everyone think he was doing all this time that he's been running around as a Krantikaari? 😆.....haath mein bandook li hai toh obviously lives bhi leta hai woh.


The issue is not that he can't take a life....heck he's been practicing this brand of self-proclaimed justice court since a long time now....but pehle people were cheering it on cuz they thought he always got justice right and only punished the wrong😆. But that's the thing - no one is perfect.....even justice warriors.


For me, everything always comes down to INTENT. Was SK's action wrong? Ofcourse it was....he did something in impulse without rationalizing it fully. But his intent was coming from a place of fierce love and protection for his daughter....a genuine love, not the china ka maal version that Didi goes around proclaiming. So he did what he felt was needed to free his daughter of someone he felt was betraying her. This is SK's brand of justice - it always ends with death only - there is never a grey area.


Characters like SK can make wrong decisions and take wrong actions but they will all still be far better than the likes of Didi who has crossed all limits in what is stemming from a fundamentally wrong INTENT. SK didn't shoot Adi to snatch someone else's rights.....but Didi is going around manipulating, cheating, lying simply to snatch things from others. That is the difference....and that is why I don't see that it's going to be hard to redeem SK....he will be genuinely remorseful and Adi will understand where he was coming from.


Oh there is no comparison between Didi and SK; talking about Didi is also a waste of time.

And I do not have any illusions at all that SK has been a saint while being a krantikari; I didn’t had any issues with him when he buried Adi alive. That was true to his character. But after that he showed him bada dil when he forgave a neech like Dev and he first hand witnessed Adi and Imlie’s love for each other, Adi helped SK come out of jail, he got him married to Meethi. All of a sudden, she hears a random mystery woman’s story, believes it to the extent that he came to the city and spied on Adi and without knowing the context, he just shot him.
He not just distrusted Adi, but doubted the intelligence of Imlie as well. Anyone who believes in hearsay and doesn’t even take a moment to get to the bottom of it, cannot be a good leader and I didn’t expect that from SK.

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: naadanmasakalli

Btw plz tell me am not the only one who is disliking this ta ra ra ra dhin ta na na wala new soundtrack .. it is too mehhhh and I feel aona original sad pieces would work better


LOL nothing can beat the horror of BALAMWAAAA🤢😆.....so this ta ra ra didn't bother me one bit😆.


Aage pata nahin kitna cringe Balamwaa bajaayenge so I was thankful usse thoda break diya.

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Josupra


Oh there is no comparison between Didi and SK; talking about Didi is also a waste of time.

And I do not have any illusions at all that SK has been a saint while being a krantikari; I didn’t had any issues with him when he buried Adi alive. That was true to his character. But after that he showed him bada dil when he forgave a neech like Dev and he first hand witnessed Adi and Imlie’s love for each other, Adi helped SK come out of jail, he got him married to Meethi. All of a sudden, she hears a random mystery woman’s story, believes it to the extent that he came to the city and spied on Adi and without knowing the context, he just shot him.
He not just distrusted Adi, but doubted the intelligence of Imlie as well. Anyone who believes in hearsay and doesn’t even take a moment to get to the bottom of it, cannot be a good leader and I didn’t expect that from SK.


LOL even good leaders can have their flaws and weak points😆. SK is a good leader cuz he commands respect in his village and understands how to handle his community.


His Achilles heel is his core mistrust of sheheri log and his fierce love for Imlie....Didi successfully manipulated SK on both points cuz Adi's past history went against him...the fact that he did indeed once sideline Imlie and marry Malini.....that is what Malini is using to her advantage with the reality that she is again back in Adi's house....it's not that far fetched for someone to MU this scenario when they have basic prejudices.


SK is impulsive on some matters....lol so to me it's not far fetched that he pulled out his tamancha as a solution...he's always been hot headed too....just that we've seen him apply that on different situations and people.

SNOWWHITE83 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 12th Anniversary Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

But I have a doubt how will Adi react to SK & Imlie for shooting him twice and burrying alive & how will it affect AdiLie🤔 He literally died twice for Imlie

Edited by .SNOWWHITE. - 4 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: .SNOWWHITE.

But I have a doubt how will Adi react to SK & Imlie for shooting him twice and burrying alive & how will it affect AdiLie🤔 He literally died twice for Imlie


LMAO you really think Adi cares about dying? 😆.....is bande ko koi farak nahin padta kaun kya karta hai as long as he has Imlie with him😆.......jeena/marna is all secondary stuff for him....isko bas Imlie ka pyar aur saath chahiye😆.


SK told him the clear reason before trying to kill him toh Adi will never blame SK.....he understood his intent in both situations.

Josupra thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: .SNOWWHITE.

But I have a doubt how will Adi react to SK & Imlie for shooting him twice and burrying alive & how will it affect AdiLie🤔 He literally died twice for Imlie


It won’t impact Adi Imlie relationship at all. Adi would never blame Imlie for what her dadda did.
But I am curious to see if this would impact Imlie’s relationship with her dadda


Edited by Josupra - 4 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".