Pandya Store|Episode Discussion #84|ShiVi's Dhol Face Off - Page 110

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

56.8k

Users

53

Likes

5.6k

Frequent Posters

mpks1 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: wanderer102016

Sometimes I wonder how do actors do such scenes which have no significance whatsoever!

Like the dancing and face off to celebrate divorce, like who does that? Also this sindoor flying off on the entire face coz of wind in a hot and humid place like Somnath!

How illogical is it?
which husband really returns sindoor dabba after telling I can’t stand you 🤪

When I ask for logical stuff to be shown, I am repeatedly told that I will not get them as it is a TRP driven shown, I also know it is a fiction but still flying sindoor, dhol-dance face off, same spot jogging, flatline are these laughable and mind numbing or what?

Pixierocks thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: SlytherInMe.


personally the only offscreen drama I have indulged in is Alice and KD brothers and a few jokes here and there about the other cast members because we never get the whole story so I don’t care much

but for me the characters themselves have left such a sour taste - I watched the first few episodes the other day (something I’ve done multiple times and have absolutely loved) and I couldn’t help but keep trolling and saying here goes dhara ma again

with everything that has happened in the show it’s hard for me to keep connecting with characters, especially dhara and I do try to find the good in her, I really do

Idk maybe I’m just too pessimistic lol


You are not a pessimist aashu.

They have butchered dhara beyond repair.gombi can be salvaged, but I am not sure they will do it or not.

I have always had a weakness for bhabi ke bhakt devars.there I said it.

And the way the bond had shaped up in the show,it was so heartwarming to watch.

The scene where Dev and shiva beat up janaradan.they come back home. Apply medicines to each other, the ykb hug.❤️

The godh bharai scene where all the brothers come together and say that they are dhara bhabis kids and raavi becomes Shiva's proxy.❤️

The scene where shiva hugs dhara after throwing raavi out of the house.❤️

The whole wedding sequence,the lo chali mai dance sequence.the scene where dhara spreads her annchal and asks shiva to accept raavi .❤️

It's true that shivi hooked me to PS, but I gradually loved all the characters except for dev.somehow i could never connect with his character.

This led me to watch all the episodes before leap as well.

As you said, now even the old epsiodes are losing charm because the bond which seemed so pure now appears fake.

Even I want to love dhara. because whether we like it or not, she is the lead of the show and will be present in each and every episode.it will be so much better to watch the show if her character is shown to be the same as the pre leap and initial Post leap times.

wanderer102016 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: mpks1

When I ask for logical stuff to be shown, I am repeatedly told that I will not get them as it is a TRP driven shown, I also know it is a fiction but still flying sindoor, dhol-dance face off, same spot jogging, flatline are these laughable and mind numbing or what?

It so is !!!

I connected to this show coz of its realism and that’s the worst part When they go off the rails after being somewhat realistic!

Atleast with other shows you can expect stupidity from the first episode!
But with shows like this and even KHKT, when they descend into stupidity, it’s heartbreaking coz we all saw the potential the show had! 🤪

Pixierocks thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Raingoddess

@Bold Bingo! I think it’s this amongst a few other reasons. Even if the content in the episodes is bad, we can at least discuss and even troll. But the offscreen stuff is beyond me 😆 Unfortunately, it does affect the mood overall. I don’t mind differences of opinion (in fact it makes the conversations more fulfilling) but not everyone feels that way.


I personally feel like there is a undercurrent of extreme dislike (hate might be too strong) towards the cast (barring 1-2 of them) and now the characters. There is no balance and room for conversation. No one party is at fault. The writers are messing up big time but the offscreen drama isn’t helping either. I could be totally wrong but that does deter me sometimes from commenting. I have my set of opinions that I don’t intend to change without good reason but I enjoy reading what others think. We can dislike the characters and talk about what bothers us. Or find the small things we like. But if we outright hate them, what is left to watch 😆


A handful of members that were present early on are no longer here and I’m sure they have their reasons for leaving. We had many more neutral fans of the show earlier. I think we are missing the balance both in the episodes and on the forum. It’s unfortunate but happens with almost every show. Oh well.


Aww I’ll try to update this weekend! With work being busy and the forum not being what it used to be…. I’m losing a bit of inspiration but your comment is def encouraging 🤗 I will try to post something this weekend!


Thank you for always supporting my work and for bringing so much positivity to the forum! I really enjoy interacting with you, Piu, Sara, Avi, etc… and it’s one of the reasons I’m still here ❤️


You are right somehow.

The offscreen drama has made me dislike some cast members.the writers are not helping the matter either.bad writing is making me disconnect with the characters of the show.

Shows and characters which invoke passionate responses has Always been my favourite.i love watching conflicts in which noone is partly at fault and people can debate over their actions and analyse the scenes. We get so many perspectives about a single scene.

Give me a good negative character and I will gladly watch it.make anita a vamp whose actions makes me apprehensive, whose plans are witty and actually has an impact.

What bothers me is when you show a positive character being violent and illogical.when the character graph swings like a pendulum.

I would have loved if rishita stayed the grey character that she was portrayed like in the beginning.i loved her haveli scenes.the scene where she chides Krish for coming to their room without knocking.made sense.the scene where she refuses to eat jhoota khana because it disgusted her.as someone who is not comfortable with eating from others plates, I could connect with her.

I would go gone crazyy if my in laws smothered me with hugs and kisses and made me eat from their plate.

Her irritation in the money matters made sense as well.

Her insecurity about raavi was also bang on.had she been a minute late, raavi would have been Devs wife.

I even liked her in the bathroom kaand.

I can't digest this sudden change in rishita.when did she develop a fondness for dhara? When did she care so much about the family? The change should have been gradual and slow.

Dev has been reduced to a prop.

Krish gets some lines here and there.

Raavi scenes are repetetive.no clarity about her thoughts.

Suman swings like a pendulum, one moment she is like DILs are the izzat of the house, it's their responsibility to maintain it.

The next moment she throws shiva out of the house for insulting raavi.

They have not kept a single character likeable.infact some shivi fans have also ended up hating either raavi or shiva.

Edited by Pixiepadhi - 3 years ago
mpks1 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: wanderer102016

It so is !!!

I connected to this show coz of its realism and that’s the worst part When they go off the rails after being somewhat realistic!

Atleast with other shows you can expect stupidity from the first episode!
But with shows like this and even KHKT, when they descend into stupidity, it’s heartbreaking coz we all saw the potential the show had! 🤪

It used to be realistic at one point and if they continued to follow exactly like in the original, would have been full of positivity and realistic. But looks ITV audience want negativity, separation, vamps, villains, misunderstandings etc to drive the show which is totally different from what the regional audience are looking for.
The only track that copied exactly in this version is the marriage track. Everything else is different. They take the track concept and give it a completely different treatment here.

Dhanam (Dhara, here) pregnancy reveal was dealt differently . One promo and week worth of episodes to show from the time she found out, her breakdown and later others got to know and the emotions of each character was shown beautifully, Here everything was done in one episode and finally led to more misunderstanding between Shiva and Raavi😕

Edited by mpks1 - 3 years ago
deeps07 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: wanderer102016

It so is !!!

I connected to this show coz of its realism and that’s the worst part When they go off the rails after being somewhat realistic!

Atleast with other shows you can expect stupidity from the first episode!
But with shows like this and even KHKT, when they descend into stupidity, it’s heartbreaking coz we all saw the potential the show had! 🤪

I say, we still have hope left..our trps aren't bad..so they dnt need to go beyond a certain level..

I have seen what has happened with too good shows..becz of trps..it was very realistic, deeply touching superb talented actors. Proper characterisation....everything was perfect..but not the trp..they tried to run the original theme I think around 120 or 130episodes..once the rangu people.began to catch their collar for trps..they started showing magnificent snakes coming out of wedding garlands in the middle of marrg..andnthe snake venom is out even without a visit to the Dr's..we believe the makers were taking inspiration from the trp topper nagin show..🤪😆I quit right from there..I am still mourning for that show.😒.it was so good... I used to envy star shows then..pandya stores has the advantage of timings and trp..its not in a dangerous position..so I am hoping atleast they won't stoop to the level of introducing nagin or magic show to it for higher trps.. we just have to bare with bhabhi staring and bhabhima ka bedroom decorations..🤪

And oh yea..some sindoor flying..dhol bajaana with jogging dance at awkward timings...😆..I am trying hard to be ok..😆

Edited by deeps07 - 3 years ago
wanderer102016 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: mpks1

It used to be realistic at one point and if they continued to follow exactly like in the original, would have been full of positivity and realistic. But looks ITV audience want negativity, separation, vamps, villains, misunderstandings etc to drive the show which is totally different from what the regional audience are looking for.
The only track that copied exactly in this version is the marriage track. Everything else is different. They take the track concept and give it a completely different treatment here.

Dhanam (Dhara, here) pregnancy reveal was dealt dufferently. One promo and week worth of episodes to show from the time she found out, her breakdown and later others got to know and the emotions of each character was shown beautifully, Here everything was done in one episode and finally led to more misunderstanding between Shiva and Raavi😕

I think this show lacks depth, they focus on the wrong things!

Despite Gaura being the leads, they didn’t show much about their sacrifice! Dev and Shiva went on abt room! They should have been worried abt how gaura feel, how it might have impacted dhara’s health and about the taunts!

The pregnancy reveal also, they needed a private moment to just let their emotions sink in! When you wish for something for so long, you take a moment in silence to realize it’s a reality and breathe a sigh of relief and joy!

Instead they spent time on dikthana! The writers don’t have the ability to show character depth!
that’s the issue with raavi too, she only had 2 traits in the beginning- happy go lucky and in her bubble of Dev love!
after that bubble burst they have no idea how to write her!

She goes full Hulk mode on sneha and Rishita, but keeps quiet with dev and her friends! Make her consistent🤪

milkcakejamun thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Raingoddess

Me too! I agree! Nothing will match those subtle scenes! I’m enjoying episodes here and there because my expectations are really low!


I also miss the vibe of the forum from back then. It’s a bit different now 😆 I mostly drop in to hear from you guys and share my thoughts. And I stick to the EDT for obvious reasons.

Do post more often if you can. Even if we can’t appreciate the scenes, we can enjoy a few laughs 🤗


@bold, 💯! My favorite scenes till date are those that weren't aimed to be romantic like Raavi acting as Shiva's proxy, Shiva being rattled by the noose, Raavi holding her pallu to shield Shiva from the sun, her grabbed onto his sleeve instead of his hand... so many different ways to interpret those scenes, and I loved the discussions we had back then


The scenes now are too direct... as if the CVs want the audience to interpret the scene in one way possible 😔 Even the dialogues have taken a nose dive. I'll reserve my comments for the BTS since I'm not 100% sure whether BTS drama is fueling the changes, but sometimes I just wish they followed the OG tracks (not make new tracks) but fit it to each character's personality...


I'm still finding it hard to believe that the girl who was willing to be a proxy/defend Shiva multiple times against Maami is now making such quick judgments... marriage should not have changed her this much... the core conflict should be, "Can I reconcile my past and move on to have a romantic relationship with this man?" not "Let me continue to misunderstand this man and brush off every insecurity he has "

Raingoddess thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: SlytherInMe.


personally the only offscreen drama I have indulged in is Alice and KD brothers and a few jokes here and there about the other cast members because we never get the whole story so I don’t care much

but for me the characters themselves have left such a sour taste - I watched the first few episodes the other day (something I’ve done multiple times and have absolutely loved) and I couldn’t help but keep trolling and saying here goes dhara ma again

with everything that has happened in the show it’s hard for me to keep connecting with characters, especially dhara and I do try to find the good in her, I really do

Idk maybe I’m just too pessimistic lol


Ashu 🤗 Yeah I’m with you. I don’t care much either. You know my thoughts from that dm I sent you.


The writers really did a number on the characters. It’s not easy to love them. I certainly don’t feel the same connection I did at one point. I feel like we try to find as much good as we can and do have some interesting discussions. We really do. I don’t think you are pessimistic. In fact, I have seen you actively try and find something to look forward to or even read/understand other POV’s. That’s all we need to do. Be open to discussion and accept that two different opinions can coexist. And the trolling is a healthy way to vent. I have lots of fun doing that 😆


The show is simply not what it used to be. I think every show goes through this. There was a point towards the end of KHKT where I couldn’t even go back and enjoy the older episodes. The FL had turned me off to such an extent that I couldn’t even enjoy the aspects I loved initially. Took me some time but now I can enjoy the episodes again. I guess I have left all that drama and hurt for the show getting messed up in the past. I hope the same happens with PS one day (I’m sure it will).


What turns me off is the outright hate that comes from other intentions. I choose to ignore them now. Thankfully, there are still so many I love to interact with. ❤️

On a side note, can we expect any updates from you? I miss reading your work 🤗



Raingoddess thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: sunsaathiyaa


aw, this was so beautiful, it made me cry ❤️

thank you soooo much for making my day 🥺

I love you to the 🥰fridge & let's just say I don't come back🥰 🤗❤️

Image

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".