Performance Discussion 19 & 20 June - Page 20

I watched part of today’s episode and I’m surprised at the bottom 2.

During the power play either Pawandeep, Arunita or Sawai was the highest voted contestant, what happened suddenly?

Either they were lying then or are lying now. Anyway am glad Sawai left, though I must confess he’d gotten better, but still was the weakest along with Ashish

Saturday

Best of the lot

Ashish kul karni 👍💕👏👏👏

Arunita, Sayli, & Nihal 👍👏

Pawandeep, Sawai 👏

Bottom of the list

Mohd Danish 😕👎 (too much yelling AKARNAPRIYA singing)

Finally der aaye durust aaye “SMP singing a normal song showing what she knows & possesses but show Vishal & her mom who are misguiding her to be the jazz, rock, yodeling singer which is ok to show versatility of singing talent. But she kept singing same o this competition. I’m glad finally she showed up & sang a good rendition 👍

Sunday Kalyanji bhai episode

Everyone sang well but SMP. very mediocre singer & singing 😕

Best

Arunita, sayli, Aashish, nihal, Pawandeep

Sawai

Danish (butchered my fav Rafi Saab song)

SMP 👎😕

disclimer: no offense meant to any singer or their fans 🙏

SMP OR Danish should have been eliminated. Not Sawai

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

I watched part of today’s episode and I’m surprised at the bottom 2.

During the power play either Pawandeep, Arunita or Sawai was the highest voted contestant, what happened suddenly?

Either they were lying then or are lying now. Anyway am glad Sawai left, though I must confess he’d gotten better, but still was the weakest along with Ashish

Judges give score after completion of vote. They know the voting result before they give score. As the lowest voted contestant between bottom 2 as per judges' score is eliminated, they can play anything. Sawai was their target this week, they pushed PD to bottom 2 along with Sawai. PD is the highest voted contestant last week, so Sawai is eliminated.

I think, both judges' score and voting should be given based on same performance. Judges' should not know the voting result beforehand. The performances of elimination week should be for entertainment only.

I am ok with Sawai's elimination but not ok with the process of elimination. This is Indian Idol show, not Judges' Idol show.

How can Indian Idol think public are so ignorant and can do whatever they want. Today elimination is totally fixed like last week's. There is no point in watching this show further or participating in votes further when show organizers have fixed who will win, who will be top 2,3,4,5. What a junk show it has become. So predictable actions of everyone one including judges, host and contestants. Pawandeep doesnt get MBD and that can be guessed easily that he would be in bottom 2 and its done for a purpose. What a shameful drama everyone is playing. This show doesnt deserve any respect as they are going against public and doing whatever they want.

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

I watched part of today’s episode and I’m surprised at the bottom 2.

During the power play either Pawandeep, Arunita or Sawai was the highest voted contestant, what happened suddenly?

Either they were lying then or are lying now. Anyway am glad Sawai left, though I must confess he’d gotten better, but still was the weakest along with Ashish

This show itself is a lie. No value to viewers and their votes. This show should be shut down immediately. Everything what they say seems to be all fake.

Now every week, as long as SMP doesn't eliminated, get ready for the royal cribbing.

For eg: if an X contestant gets eliminated, you will find remarks," He was MUCH better than SMP, and did not deserve to lose"

This of course holds, if SMP is not eliminated next week!

And I'm saying HE, because, I don't see other two girls in the bottom two.

Originally posted by: GiridharM

Now every week, as long as SMP doesn't eliminated, get ready for the royal cribbing.

For eg: if an X contestant gets eliminated, you will find remarks," He was MUCH better than SMP, and did not deserve to lose"

This of course holds, if SMP is not eliminated next week!

And I'm saying HE, because, I don't see other two girls in the bottom two.

My top 4 is Arunita, PD, SMP and Sayli without any doubt, without any hesitation.

I am confused between Danish and Nihal for the fifth position. Nihal is performing superb currently but I can't forget few excellent performances of Danish in beginning of the show.

Ashish is also good. In fact very good.

All other contestants are also very talented!

I wish their bright career in music!

Originally posted by: GiridharM

Now every week, as long as SMP doesn't eliminated, get ready for the royal cribbing.

For eg: if an X contestant gets eliminated, you will find remarks," He was MUCH better than SMP, and did not deserve to lose"

This of course holds, if SMP is not eliminated next week!

And I'm saying HE, because, I don't see other two girls in the bottom two.

None of the eliminated contestants are better than SMP. hands down I can argue with any one on this related to her talent. This has become comedy from where SMP came in this weeks elimination. People keep forgetting SMP came in bottom 2 only once in whole show like Pawandeep and she tops judges scores most of the time. Even after so much sidelining done by channel during powerplay iam 100% sure she is one of top vote getters. Why should she be on elimination. Indian idol is a show based on pop idol there is nothing wrong in singing in western style on the show. She never was technically imperfect like some others for people to think she is less. Shame on makers to use wrong strategies for elimination.

Originally posted by: Karkerrna3

I hate how they are giving arunita same song.

She already sang this

Originally posted by: SamirM

it is not the public vote which is the deciding factor but the judges' score in elimination week!!!

Judges give score after completion of vote. They know the voting result before they give score. As the lowest voted contestant between bottom 2 as per judges' score is eliminated, they can play anything. Sawai was their target this week, they pushed PD to bottom 2 along with Sawai. PD is the highest voted contestant last week, so Sawai is eliminated.

I think, both judges' score and voting should be given based on same performance. Judges' should not know the voting result beforehand. The performances of elimination week should be for entertainment only.

I am ok with Sawai's elimination but not ok with the process of elimination. This is Indian Idol show, not Judges' Idol show.

Yes the process of elimination is biased, and I’ve been saying this since Anushka left. After the backlash after Nachikets elimination, they clearly said that it will be entirely juntas decision, and they had power play to give us the top 5. Now suddenly judges are back to voting.

They need to stick to what they say.