Insult for the singers

I think it is a big insult for the participants of Lil Champs and Chote Ustaad and Saregamapa and ASVOI that judges who are passing comments on their songs hardly know the A, B, C, D of music themselves, for e.g. Shekhar Suman and Javed Aktar. I guess, it is an injustice towards the participant singers.....

For the dancers, they have a good judge, Saroj Khan, who has a lot of knowledge about dancing. I strongly feel that Sony should have had at least one judge in the panel who is an established singer......

I am sure Javed Akhter knows a lot about music. He couldn't last that long in the industry without proper knowledge. What bothers me is Shakher and Saroj. Their opinions shouldn't count for music. As they probably wouldn't catch it if someone missed a note. Or if the taal was wrong. I am fine with all other cases than singing. As I am sure Javed and Saroj would know if a joke was funny or not.

Originally posted by: guhasuparna

I think it is a big insult forthe participants of Lil Champs and Chote Ustaad and Saregamapa and ASVOI that judges who are passing comments on their songs hardly know the A, B, C, D of music themselves, for e.g. Shekhar Suman and Javed Aktar. I guess, it is an injustice towards the participant singers.....

For the dancers, they have a good judge, Saroj Khan, who has a lot of knowledge about dancing. I strongly feel that Sony should have had at least one judge in the panel who is an established singer......