Being Holmes: Solve the Murder T9 - Page 84

Originally posted by: oye_nakhrewaali

This!!!!!

He lusted after a dead woman for 30 freaking years!

I would take regulus black and narcissa black over Snape anyday if I was slytheirn

He joined those people who were hell bent on killing the people like his bestie and didn't care for her happiness as long as what he got.

Finally! I got u....u got me...what i wanted to explain....😪😌

Originally posted by: Potterhead_05

Finally! I got u....u got me...what i wanted to explain....😪😌

The only reason why Snape is a good character becuase it was Alan Rickman who played him. He gave the character the empathy he had for him, making everyone like him. Had it just been the books, mujhe nahi lagta people would easily forgive Snape, except for his "Always" and "slaughter like pig" lines.

Originally posted by: Potterhead_05

Waise don't take me wrong...but snape ko itna glorify kiya jaata...but Regulus black was equally brave...and my argument against snape is ki log bolte h he was bullied by marauders when they were effing 15...but what about his bullying trio when he is 30+something... Also if had the chosen one been Neville, and the one mother killed was Alice long bottom, he wouldn't hv probably cared to come over to the light side if lily had been alive... Lily died so he joined dumbledore....other wise he probably wouldn't... I just feel harry could hv named his kid after reg also... Regulus blavk doesn't get the appreciation he deserves...

But still...snape in the end turned good so koi na chalta hai....

Aise even i like the Slytherin house...coz of reg, draco, slughorn... But gryffi more coz of trio twins nd marauders....

*Sighs tragically....ik i blabber a lot... sorry

But I agree

Regulus was actually a great character

Sirius kinda was lucky he had friends but Regulus...the guy was alone and still he managed himself

I wont let my bias go away about Severus but I wholeheartedly agree with the Regulus Black point...he never got the appreciation he should have got...

PS: Unpopular opinion but I aint much Dumbledore fan

Originally posted by: oye_nakhrewaali

Malfoy too. He was a bully, James was too. But they got the redemption arcs when Draco couldn't kill, when James decided to grow up (and I don't think James grew up for lily, it was sirius, he didn't want to be like Sirius' mom, a bully, so he stopped bullying others)

Exactly...i love both of em....

And tbh mereko 7th book nd cursed child itna pasand h coz harry nd draco became friends kinda (not platonic bffs but at least something ... something a kind of friendship...)

And james...well...u hv no idea hiw much i adore the marauders...(peter ko thoda kam but i don't hate him...his redemption was also done)

James also gave Sirius a home... shared his home his parents everything...and that's what i call true friendship 🥺😌❤️

Round 4 kab aayega? I am bored. 😆

Originally posted by: oye_nakhrewaali

The only reason why Snape is a good character becuase it was Alan Rickman who played him. He gave the character the empathy he had for him, making everyone like him. Had it just been the books, mujhe nahi lagta people would easily forgive Snape, except for his "Always" and "slaughter like pig" lines.

Yup!

Main abhi tak uss movie tak pahunchi nahi...maybe that's why i speak about Snape the way i do....

But bande mein swag tha umbridge ke saamne...i admit it.. i hate that woman more than Lucius malfoy...and i hate Lucius even more than voldy...soch lo

Originally posted by: Potterhead_05

Exactly...i love both of em....

And tbh mereko 7th book nd cursed child itna pasand h coz harry nd draco became friends kinda (not platonic bffs but at least something ... something a kind of friendship...)

And james...well...u hv no idea hiw much i adore the marauders...(peter ko thoda kam but i don't hate him...his redemption was also done)

James also gave Sirius a home... shared his home his parents everything...and that's what i call true friendship 🥺😌❤️

You like cursed child?!😳 Ok....For me, it's not canon. CEDRIC FREAKING DIGGORY WILL NEVER JOIN DEATH EATERS, koi bhi reality ho, hear that John Tiffany and JK? I don't care if you have written the books but no one says that a Hufflepuff will kill becuase he didn't win a contest🙄

Rest of the post, a big YES!!!!!

Achha chalo I will come back later

I am kinda sensitive to the topic of Severus hence me is going for sometime

Will comeback when others do<3

Originally posted by: Potterhead_05

Gryffindor ko bhi thoda welcome dedo...waise yahan gryffindor supporters kaun kaun h??

M gryffindor🤣

3 times gyffin mila, 2 times Huffle mila in Pottermore quiz🤣

Originally posted by: Alexia_Wilson

I still love Snape no matter what

But I agree

Regulus was actually a great character

Sirius kinda was lucky he had friends but Regulus...the guy was alone and still he managed himself

I wont let my bias go away about Severus but I wholeheartedly agree with the Regulus Black point...he never got the appreciation he should have got...

Ikr😪

PS: Unpopular opinion but I aint much Dumbledore fan

Dumbledore had his flaws... but i think he was great in what he was...accha tha funny Caring sa budhau apna😆