Originally posted by: mintyblue
Sonam was never invested in her craft or showed the inclination to be the best version of herself. Some actresses just don't have the acting chops (Katrina, Shraddha) but I believe Sonam had the potential but didn't act on it. She just sort of went with the flow. She's beautiful, and she looked like a dream in her debut, but from there with the exception of Neerja there were no outstanding performances.
Coming to Anushka, she does have acting chops and is pretty much equal to Deepika in acting skills, but she never attained that elusive stardom. She could have been right up there with Deepu, but somehow luck didn't favour her and even when she had massive hits, her co-stars walked away with the accolades like Ranbir in Ae Dil Hai Mushkil.
I don't think it's fair to assume Sonam didn't care about her craft. She did Begin her career bu working with acclaimed directors like SLB (Devdas, Black...) and ROM (Rang de Basanti) who previously had commercial and critical.
Then wanting commercial success she did a Dharma Production movie (I Hate Love Stories) which turned out to be her first hit.
She followed up with her and her sister's production Aisha, a chick flick which was a moderate success which would have the way for futur collab between the sisters (Khoobsurat ans VDW).
Thank You and Players were also mobiles she did to try and have commercial success. Keep in mind that at the time, it was the babes like Katrina who were successful ans sought after. Doing flower pot roles were the thing.
Mausam was a movie which was real good on paper and had a great opening. Alas it was toi costly and not well executed.
It's with Raanjhanaa that she got commercial and critical success again and understood what position she should take In the industry. She'll do Chuck flicks and romcom but also socially relevant movies.
As a fan, it's obvious to me she wasn't lazy but just didn't have luck for some of her ventures. She also didn't hustle lile Deepika who gobbled up all the big projects which end up taking her what she is now.
Deepika chose to work with Ranbir after the KWK fiasco and his father's subconsquent intervention while Sonam kept being stubborn and refused to work with him for a long time.
They debuted the same day but their career path isn't he same as both of them made different choices.
But in a way, you're right. At one point, when she understood what she could, she did want with the flow.
15