Tamil film heroines.-a general discussion

Originally posted by: kadhambari

some of the actresses are no more & some are no more actress,what is the point in rating them?

i agree with kadhambari😳.

Originally posted by: cinemalover

i just wanted to help people rate actresses in a neutral way rather than idolising.

here i have seen many people fanatically and blindfoldedly praising useless actreses, who dont even speak their own voice, are treated as great actresses.

If this is your statement Cinemalover, then by all means remove Simran's and Sherya's name from the list. They should not be graded along with Savithri nor Kushboo. It is a great insult to Savithri/Padmini/Kushboo. Even Meena can fit in Kushboo's shoes but to put Simran's and Sherya's name along with these great actresses, oh come on. It is like comparing a branded perfume to artificial perfume bought from the streets.

I am surprised that you have listed physical features as No.1 attribution in cinema. Here many of us are rooting for acting, and you are listing physical features as No. 1? That should be in bottom of the list.

May I know on what basis you have picked this list. This shows favouritism. Very obvious your list is all abt your favourite actresses. Your list have left out so many talented actress like Sowkar Janaki, Jayalalitha, Laata, Sri Priya, Radha, Jo, etc. You should have accounted for each era, then your list will be correct and you will see there will be a healthy participation.

You said here i have seen many people fanatically and blindfoldedly praising useless actreses, who dont even speak their own voice, are treated as great actresses. So please tell me, are Simran & Sherya speaking in their own voice? For Godsake, Sherya cannot even lipsync properly! I heard some actressess who cannot read or write tamil, read their script in English and give a good lipsync.

Come on Cinemalover, many of us here are matured adults who knows how to value an actress. It is alright to idolise actresses as long as you don't go overboard. If one of us idolise an actress, then there is someone here who is overcritical about the same actress. So that balances up. Who you see as useless, may not be useless in another person's eye. Have you heard "one man's meat, is another man's poison"? We do not need help. Thank you for your concern.

i agree with ditty,shreya is nowhere close,where we can rate her.she is just coming as a doll in a movie,not a great performance.

Cary,well said dear.👏👏

Originally posted by: cinemalover

i just wanted to help people rate actresses in a neutral way rather than idolising.

here i have seen many people fanatically and blindfoldedly praising useless actreses, who dont even speak their own voice, are treated as great actresses.

Originally posted by: cinemalover

all of you dont understand this topic at all.
all i attempt isto do is to analyse certain top heroines
of certain time with the 5 point criteria that i have.
for me a heoine not speaking her own voice can not be called an actress at all.

But does all actress in your list speaks with their own voice😕

so there is no true heroine in tamil cinema after sridevi.

Urrm 🤔excuse me, i thought in previous page u were prasing highly on Simran

and jothika had never been a top star, but it was all hype created.

i really dun wanna go into this again😕. On second thought, let me find some articles from india forum on Jo being the top star😉

i am writing what i believe to be true and found to be true.

So are we 😛, but then again, nothing can be prove true in cinema world

i am hardcore fan of superstar rajinikanth and watch all his movies 5 to 10times.

but setting aside my rajini fan attitude , i can say convincingly all his movies are worst kind of films from a critical point of view.

well, thats ur opinion. For me, its totally opposite 😛

i dont like kamalhasan due to personal reasons.but i can say tat he is the best actor in india and he is true and honest to cinema than all of the actors combined.

one thing we both agree

so when you analyse something you put aside your personal whims and fancies to come to a logical conclusion.

Are you telling that to us 😲...

dont think and write as a fan ,which most people here do.

😆😆😆 good one ....

Originally posted by: cinemalover

all of you dont understand this topic at all.
all i attempt isto do is to analyse certain top heroines
of certain time with the 5 point criteria that i have.
for me a heoine not speaking her own voice can not be called an actress at all.

so there is no true heroine in tamil cinema after sridevi.

and jothika had never been a top star, but it was all hype created.

i am writing what i believe to be true and found to be true

i am hardcore fan of superstar rajinikanth and watch all his movies 5 to 10times.

but setting aside my rajini fan attitude , i can say convincingly all his movies are worst kind of films from a critical point of view.

i dont like kamalhasan due to personal reasons.but i can say tat he is the best actor in india and he is true and honest to cinema than all of the actors combined.

so when you analyse something you put aside your personal whims and fancies to come to a logical conclusion.

dont think and write as a fan ,which most people here do.

Vow cinemalover u write quite logical too.i am writing what i believe to be true and found to be true,i hope this apply to all of us.U may found it from u'r sources & we from ours,thats the difference.we have our own scale 2 rate actress,y do u think we shud follow u'r parameter 2 rate & rate the actress u mentioned above?

We can have a voting 2 select the actresses 2 be rated either.

Originally posted by: cinemalover

i dont believe in voting , i believe in personal conviction.

😲 why did you open this for honey? For voting right??