Aishwarya or Kareena, better actress? - Page 2

Comparison between two bad actresses. I liked kareena in jab we met so I will go with her. She was awful in her recent good news. Kiara advani easily outshone her.

Aish is awful in all her movies.

begum over bahu in acting any given day.

Blah this is hard but choosing Aish.

Regular Kareena is usually a better actress than regular Aish. But Kareena's worst acting is more cringe-worthy to me than Aish's worst acting. I choose Aish's fake laugh and tears over Kareena's screams, over dramatic crying and laughing any day of the week. Also Aish's best is superior to Kareena's best in my opinion. All the roles Kareena has done in life I think Aish could do them, or come close to it, 80% of it at least. K3G, Omkara, Good Newz, Heroine...I could see young Aish do these roles. I think Geet is the only role Aish couldn't play as well as Kareena. No one could. Geet was Kareena. On the other hand Aish has roles that I don't think Kareena could play even half as well. HDDCS, Devdas, Jodha Akbar, Taal, Guzarish, Raincoat, Raavan.

Kareena based on this alone

Aishwarya BY FAR.

Kareena is only good at playing versions of her personality. And Poo till date is unbearable, when people hail it like some great Mean Girl-ish performance, it's absolutely hilarious and embarrassingly makes me wonder if the standards are THAT low.

Aishwarya is inconsistent, but she does amazingly well when she wants to be good. She was pitch perfect in Guzaarish. And Raincoat, Provoked are others where she can do subtlety very well. HDDCS, Devdas are great star-performances, films where her screen presence shines bright alongside the performance being in sync with the pitch of the film. Its not a very easy balance.

Aishwarya was never known for her acting. She was only good in those Bhansali films, otherwiseshe was a total disaster.

Kareena wasn't good in her early years either, but after that she improved a lot.

and yeah, this is the right time to ask if an insider or an outsider is better.

Originally posted by: Kaya65

and yeah, this is the right time to ask if an insider or an outsider is better.

Aish married insider toh khud insider bangayi 😆

O God! Kareena any day!

Ash just cannot act. She's only a little better than Katrina, which means that she is rather useless.

I have said this about both they're both limited to a good script and a good director. You take that away from them and they're both below average to cringe worthy.

However Kareena is more versatile she can do a Omkara, Chameli or Jab We Met. Meanwhile Aish not only needs a good script and good director. She needs an extremely Indian character. The only exception would be Bride and Prejudice where she did get 3 star/4 star reviews.

But I prefer Aish more as a star because she had looks, dancing skills and was more of an overall package. And her movies def have more repeat value.

Poll bolta hai. IF must be controlled by nepotism too