Mahabharat Retelecast Discussion Thread 4 - Page 62

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

You can cross check I m not a karn fan

I know you aren't. But you like few of his qualities that's what you had said.

Let me check

Will be Jaydrath killed today? And will Ghato enter today?

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

I know you aren't. But you like few of his qualities that's what you had said.

Let me check

Only quality of Karn I know, he's Loyal 😆

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

I know you aren't. But you like few of his qualities that's what you had said.

Let me check

Maine uski loyalty ke baare main kaha tha , baad main kaha ki usne duryodhana ko dhoka diya by not killing bheem , Yudi, twins after getting changes coz his promise 2 Kunti.

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

Even yudhishthira's subjects were ready 2 leave with him 2 exile.

Yes I read Hastinapur people cried at his death

Vidur words came true people did accepted Yudi has king .

His brothers were great love & support 2 him , he was 2 busy in conspiring against pandavas . I don't think anywhere it is mentioned what he had done 4 his brothers .

Yes he had been said 2 be a great frnd 2 karn , never heard about sudharma & his frnd ship regarding ashwatthama I only read he was neutral from both side .

About reaching swarg I don't understand d criteria only of reaching swarg , if after doing so many adharma Yudi can reach swarg with his body , 2 phir duryodhana pahuch gaya , to usme konsi badi baat .

Ya I heard he is great warrior but read karn did digvijay yatra 4 him.

Do you really feel that Yudhishtir didn't have any good qualities? We hate him for his Dyut Sabha instance and statements later, but otherwise (and a couple of more instances) he only exhibited good qualities. His good qualities outnumbered his bad qualities. Why wouldn't people accept and love him, they didn't even know what he had said to Draupadi/Saindhari. Aside the people were ready to leave with him before they would have got the details of the Dyut Sabha

You are wrong Yudi doesn't reach the Swarg with body that's not what the epic states. Once he reaches the bottom, Dharmaraj/Narad reach out to him and makes him shed off his earthly body, then only his soul goes to the heaven.

Duryodhan multiple times stated that he feared that if Pandavas take over, his royal born princes would have no refuge. He always was respectful to Bheeshm, Dron and Krip

Yes his behaviour to Ashwathama n Susharma has not been highlighted, but Ashwathama always supported him and cried at his death profusely. Susharma was ready to be termed as coward and run away after challenging Arjun, (a huge dent on his self esteem) just to ensure Duryodhan's plan is successful. Do you think anyone would go to that extent for anyone who hasn't been a very dear friend to you

Yes Karna did Digvijay for him. But for Digvijay only the best commander is sent. (I think he wanted to project Karna as the second face of Hastinapur by sending him over Bheeshm or Drona)

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

Maine uski loyalty ke baare main kaha tha , baad main kaha ki usne duryodhana ko dhoka diya by not killing bheem , Yudi, twins after getting changes coz his promise 2 Kunti.

Ok then.

By the way just curious, what good qualities did you find in Ravana?

Little late, but here's my 2 C. Subhadraharan was worse. The rest were done by suitors which would be bad by today's standards but were accepted back then. Having a brother arrange an abduction was not accepted then or now. I wouldn't fault Arjuna in this as much as Krishna.

Well I really didn't like Shaheer Sheikh during the Jaydrath Vadh fiasco

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Do you really feel that Yudhishtir didn't have any good qualities? We hate him for his Dyut Sabha instance and statements later, but otherwise (and a couple of more instances) he only exhibited good qualities. His good qualities outnumbered his bad qualities. Why wouldn't people accept and love him, they didn't even know what he had said to Draupadi/Saindhari. Aside the people were ready to leave with him before they would have got the details of the Dyut Sabha

You are wrong Yudi doesn't reach the Swarg with body that's not what the epic states. Once he reaches the bottom, Dharmaraj/Narad reach out to him and makes him shed off his earthly body, then only his soul goes to the heaven.

Duryodhan multiple times stated that he feared that if Pandavas take over, his royal born princes would have no refuge. He always was respectful to Bheeshm, Dron and Krip

Yes his behaviour to Ashwathama n Susharma has not been highlighted, but Ashwathama always supported him and cried at his death profusely. Susharma was ready to be termed as coward and run away after challenging Arjun, (a huge dent on his self esteem) just to ensure Duryodhan's plan is successful. Do you think anyone would go to that extent for anyone who hasn't been a very dear friend to you

Yes Karna did Digvijay for him. But for Digvijay only the best commander is sent. (I think he wanted to project Karna as the second face of Hastinapur by sending him over Bheeshm or Drona)

lets talk about Yudi only now

before that I will like 2 ask u preet can u give reference 4 nakul & Sahdev in entire mahabharat where nakul has boasted about his good looks & Sahdev would had boasted about his knowledge.

Yes we can give Yudi some brownie point that he gave yakshraj / dharamraj questions & revive his brothers .

Originally posted by: Andy3456

Well I really didn't like Shaheer Sheikh during the Jaydrath Vadh fiasco

waise arjun had a misplaced anger on jaydradth kya. Abhimanyu killing involved so many other maharathis. why special affection was for jaydradth only