Madhuri vs Sridevi - Page 3

Originally posted by: MunnaBadnamHua

saal ke har quarter ma yeh poll zaroor ata ha 😆

Originally posted by: Rekha_ji

I have selected the Sridevi songs for all. Which surprised me. But then I realised you have used all of Sridevi's TOP songs vs Madhuri's not-so-top songs.

Missing: Maar Daala, Choli Ke Peeche, Mujhe Neend Na Aaye, Dekha Hai Pehli Baar, Mera Piya Ghar Aaya, Dil To Pagal Hai (it's a fantastic album, but you selected my least favourite song from it) - although it would be hard to beat that song from Lamhe because that's a personal fave of all time.

Comparison of their iconic item songs.

Pehla Pehla Pyaar Hai was not used because it was expression of first love from Prem.While Mayani Mayani was Nisha's.

Hum Aapke Hai Kaun as an album is very popular.Didi Tera Dewar Deewana is one of her most popular song.

Majority feel Choli Ke Peeche is very vulgar.

In another thread Mujhe Neend Na Aaye did not get a 👍.

I had made another thread comparing their sensuous songs.

Comparison between two Yash Chopra romantic songs.

Originally posted by: Sambha_AreO

1. Ek Do Teen vs Hawa Hawaii
2. Maayani Maayani (HAHK) vs Mitwa (Chandni)
3. Didi Tera Devar Deewana (Hum Aapke Hain Kaun) vs Mere Haathon Main (Chandni)
4. Tandav (Koyla) vs Tandav (Chaalbaaz)
5. Dolna (Dil Toh Paagal Hai) vs Kabhi Main Kahoon (Lamhe)
6. Chane Ke Khet Main (Anjaam) vs Na Jaane Kahan Se Aayi Hain (Chaalbaaz)
7. Humko Aajkal Hain Intezaar (Sailaab) vs Morni Baaghama (Lamhe).

Song battle between Madhuri and Sridevi.These are popular songs of these two actresses in different moods.Select the best audio visual representation.

Sridevi in lamhe medley, lage mujhe sunder har lardki from Mr bechara beats all, never gets boring. I think overall Sridevi. 😆

1. Ek Do Teen vs Hawa Hawaii
2. Maayani Maayani (HAHK) vs Mitwa (Chandni)
3. Didi Tera Devar Deewana (Hum Aapke Hain Kaun) vs Mere Haathon Main (Chandni)
4. Tandav (Koyla) vs Tandav (Chaalbaaz)
5. Dolna (Dil Toh Paagal Hai) vs Kabhi Main Kahoon (Lamhe)
6. Chane Ke Khet Main (Anjaam) vs Na Jaane Kahan Se Aayi Hain (Chaalbaaz)
7. Humko Aajkal Hain Intezaar (Sailaab) vs Morni Baaghama (Lamhe).

Originally posted by: dedh

Why is this patronizing, exaggerated rhetoric so frequent in threads about Madhuri and Sridevi? Why the need to be a drama queen? Of course, those two artists can be compared - both delivered great stuff and it's perfectly OK to compare the songs, too. It's not the end of the world. Fan responses like that reek of insecurity. 👎🏼

As to my choices, I never cared about some of these songs, so I'm omitting them. Therefore,

1. Ek Do Teen vs Hawa Hawaii
2. 
   
3. 
   
4. Tandav (Koyla) vs Tandav (Chaalbaaz) - I'm stumped here. Both are so well done. I'm not even sure calling Sanson ki mala pe just a tandav does justice to its choreography, so there's that, too.
5. 
   
6. Chane Ke Khet Main (Anjaam) vs Na Jaane Kahan Se Aayi Hain (Chaalbaaz)
7. Humko Aajkal Hain Intezaar (Sailaab) vs Morni Baaghama (Lamhe).

Not that I need to answer you but you also chose to pick your favorite. So each of their own. As far as being insecure is concerned Sridevi is, was and will always be a legend. There is no comparison for her talent. I am entitled to my own choices just as much as you are. So no need to quote like that and vent your own insecurities. 😊

Originally posted by: monikameghan

Not that I need to answer you but you also chose to pick your favorite. So each of their own. As far as being insecure is concerned Sridevi is, was and will always be a legend. There is no comparison for her talent. I am entitled to my own choices just as much as you are. So no need to quote like that and vent your own insecurities. 😊

Your reverse psychology pseudo-argument simply doesn't work. I never questioned your choices, merely the unwarranted condescending, belittling, and ultimately pointless rhetoric. Obviously, there is a comparison for Sri's talent (heck, you're posting in a thread doing just that), not everything she did was that great, and, sadly, even legends tend to be forgotten and/or reevaluated with the passage of time. C'est la vie, fellow movie watcher, so some humility wouldn't hurt.

Comparison to Madhuri Dixit is unfair to Sridevi . MDN beat Sridevi hands down years ago.

Sridevi's fans can start umpteen threads and rig them but that still won't change the fact that Madhuri Dixit is far better than Sridevi in acting, reacting, emoting, dance, dialogue delivery, diction, comic timing, action and all other the facets associated with onscreen performance.

People don't watch films yet compare them erroneously . It is Gulab Gang, not Gulabi Gang.

Gulabi Gang is a documentary.

Originally posted by: dedh

Your reverse psychology pseudo-argument simply doesn't work. I never questioned your choices, merely the unwarranted condescending, belittling, and ultimately pointless rhetoric. Obviously, there is a comparison for Sri's talent (heck, you're posting in a thread doing just that), not everything she did was that great, and, sadly, even legends tend to be forgotten and/or reevaluated with the passage of time. C'est la vie, fellow movie watcher, so some humility wouldn't hurt.

No kidding!! At last we agree on one thing that legends also tend to be forgotten. But they are always remembered for the benchmarks they set for the generations to come. Yes, there are people who are going to cross those benchmarks that’s why those milestones are there in the first place to be crossed. I never said MD is a bad actress. I don’t even believe that. She is an amazing actress that’s why she is still here. But when comparing the two as the thread maker said, I will always pick Sri over MD. And you talked about humility, you are free to say whatever you want. You and I don’t owe each other anything. So please don’t tell me what to do or say and vise versa.

1. Ek Do Teen
2. Mitwa (Chandni)
3. Didi Tera Devar Deewana (Hum Aapke Hain Kaun) vs Mere Haathon Main (Chandni)
4. Tandav (Koyla)
5. Dolna (Dil Toh Paagal Hai) vs Kabhi Main Kahoon (Lamhe)
6. Chane Ke Khet Main (Anjaam)
7. Humko Aajkal Hain Intezaar (Sailaab) vs Morni Baaghama (Lamhe).