Chalo aman ko thoda bahut akal toh tha - Page 2

Originally posted by: sree96

No I disagree there were instances where he was supportive especially during Praveen was manipulating Roshni also during the memory

He couldn't stab Roshni and allowed her to attack him.

I am repeating again it's Alia track that destroyed him. The CVs could have handled it better.

I agree.. I was watching few old episodes and scenes yesterday and he was very different.. they completely destroyed his character in this track.

And I was seeing how he talked about everything so.ooenly with dadi and took her advice. In current track.. suddenly they have reduced all such interactions.. and even aman roshni also talked before.. even though sameer case mi understanding he behaved badly.. yet MU hi sahi he talked everything that he was thinking..

They turned him totally ridiculous in this track.

Before that also when Roshni was thought to be hallucinating he was supportive.

Again it's not as if Aman didn't try to save Roshni he did from well despite warning from Tabeezi that it could cost him his life in the Kala jungle and again he was readying to suck the poison out

Both characters are flawed if Aman issue is trust then Roshni is self respect.

Originally posted by: sree96

Before that also when Roshni was thought to be hallucinating he was supportive.

Again it's not as if Aman didn't try to save Roshni he did from well despite warning from Tabeezi that it could cost him his life in the Kala jungle and again he was readying to suck the poison out

Both characters are flawed if Aman issue is trust then Roshni is self respect.

I do not recall aman saving roshni in the kala jungle but I do remember roshni saving aman multiple times in kala jungle:

- LCR

-TBR

- during Alia missing baby time

Regarding sucking poison I have already said multiple times he was redeemed after Kabir’s track. Regarding him supportive during manipulation time? He still thought she was wrong but he was kind. He never wondered why and never looked for remedy.

Aman issue isn’t trust with roshni only he had no issue trusting Alia. Roshni has zero self esteem and she forgives easily. Thankfully with third time is a charm and this time she will stay put.

This is for Viba, I think you should revisit old episodes. I really think you need to tone down each to each opinion. If you don't like Aman fine but please don't think you are an expert that you need to push your Aman hatred down other people's throat.

I don't see anybody else commenting on as much as you do. And these are fictional characters so I think you should take to actors and the crew are doing their job.

I think it's to the credit of the actors that they are able to evoke such emotions in the viewer.

Originally posted by: sree96

This is for Viba, I think you should revisit old episodes. I really think you need to tone down each to each opinion. If you don't like Aman fine but please don't think you are an expert that you need to push your Aman hatred down other people's throat.

I don't see anybody else commenting on as much as you do. And these are fictional characters so I think you should take to actors and the crew are doing their job.

I think it's to the credit of the actors that they are able to evoke such emotions in the viewer.

Well this is a forum so why shouldn’t I comment? You don’t like it don’t reply but I will comment as much as I want.

Secondly I have watched it and I have never ever tried to shove anything down anyone’s throat. You incorrectly said aman saved roshni in kala jungle and I am asking when? Don’t reply if you don’t want to I can do what I want. I think you need to understand that actors gets paid and they are for the viewers so if I a viewer is not happy will say so. They aren’t doing me any favours they are actors because they want to.

Also please tell me when have I pushed my opinion on anyone’s throat? In fact there are few who love aman as he is VSC and there are those who don’t.

I think you need to tone down telling me what to do!!!

Sorry for interrupting in between just want to clarify Aman saved Roshni they spent night in jungle ..he took arrows n kala jungle to save Roshni and he is about to dead roshni placed flower he got saved ..He is the one who saved Roshni first putting his life at risk so we cant blame him he never cared for roshni..May be we forgot and hate him now ok because of current track but we shouldnt forgot what he did for Roshni ..he have trust issues I agree but blaming him for every single thing is no point as we all know makers rushed Roshan love story because its for 100 epi so one r other character they didnt showed detail ..We all understand Roshni easily beacause from starting she is funny , talkative and cvs showed she loved aman first they showed all ..but frm aman side even he cared for her , feelings for her otherwise in sameer issue why he will be possesive and angry ?? because of his character he is not expressive , dont show much epi r fast forwarded ..but initial episodes all his feelings, care for roshni showed and even his actions few times he hated her he has reasons too ..i disagree he fell in love just because Roshni died for him .. as i watched all 70 epi at a time his love suddenly didnt came because she died for him ...but if anyone remembered he admitted accidentally to dadi after separtion he loves roshni Before roshni death...its just he didnt realized until she died!

Originally posted by: Roshan_93

Sorry for interrupting in between just want to clarify Aman saved Roshni they spent night in jungle ..he took arrows n kala jungle to save Roshni and he is about to dead roshni placed flower he got saved ..He is the one who saved Roshni first putting his life at risk so we cant blame him he never cared for roshni..May be we forgot and hate him now ok because of current track but we shouldnt forgot what he did for Roshni ..he have trust issues I agree but blaming him for every single thing is no point as we all know makers rushed Roshan love story because its for 100 epi so one r other character they didnt showed detail ..We all understand Roshni easily beacause from starting she is funny , talkative and cvs showed she loved aman first they showed all ..but frm aman side even he cared for her , feelings for her otherwise in sameer issue why he will be possesive and angry ?? because of his character he is not expressive , dont show much epi r fast forwarded ..but initial episodes all his feelings, care for roshni showed and even his actions few times he hated her he has reasons too ..i disagree he fell in love just because Roshni died for him .. as i watched all 70 epi at a time his love suddenly didnt came because she died for him ...but if anyone remembered he admitted accidentally to dadi after separtion he loves roshni Before roshni death...its just he didnt realized until she died!

Thank you for that reminder - you are right it did happen. I guess here it’s subjective. I never felt his love until after the death track. After roshni left he didn’t even look for her to make sure she is okay and she had to come to him. Also if he loved her back then why didn’t the tree bloom?

If he was possessive during Sameer track why kick her out twice? Also I did say back then roshni should have spoken up but she didn’t and that’s why the redemption of Aman was good.

I actually liked him a lot after redemption but with alias track the hypocrisy is at fore front. For me at least he is not redeemable now. I also know roshni and aman are end game and no matter what that won’t change. But regardless of his feelings or not he has treated roshni very disrespectfully and unfortunately I can’t let that go as possessive love. Basic respect is must whether you love or not.

I do appreciate you clearing the kala jungle but.

Originally posted by: vibha28

Thank you for that reminder - you are right it did happen. I guess here it’s subjective. I never felt his love until after the death track. After roshni left he didn’t even look for her to make sure she is okay and she had to come to him. Also if he loved her back then why didn’t the tree bloom?

If he was possessive during Sameer track why kick her out twice? Also I did say back then roshni should have spoken up but she didn’t and that’s why the redemption of Aman was good.

I actually liked him a lot after redemption but with alias track the hypocrisy is at fore front. For me at least he is not redeemable now. I also know roshni and aman are end game and no matter what that won’t change. But regardless of his feelings or not he has treated roshni very disrespectfully and unfortunately I can’t let that go as possessive love. Basic respect is must whether you love or not.

I do appreciate you clearing the kala jungle but.

I respect your thoughts ..Each and every person feel and understand each and every character differently .. As i said my case i watched all epi at a time so i understood Roshan and their story better way even if i watched frm start day 1 and waiting for episodes i should have missed few details because remembering all is difficult for me ..So i also judge based n that but here my case is different i watched the show recently one month old so i understand them like this ..others may not agree..because other feel other way too..but for me Aman character is complex hav layers and Roshni is simple and easy to understand ..So her love is always straight forward in actions r words not like Aman that how writers showed ..

In start episodes he always cared for her and hav feelings for her but he didnt realised ..if he dont realise then how he know that love feeling ? So nargis flowers not showed up ..And in sameer case if he doesnt care for Roshni how he become possessive and angry ?? Any person showing these feelings means love, care , liking something should be there we dont show all these kind of feelings for some random person n the road right..we show these kind of emotions if they r close to us so i dont agree he only loved instantly just because she come and dead for him ! May be people need few shocks to realize love for others and roshni death to aman is one of them to him ..and we dont value and realise people worth until we loose them. Thats happen in real life too !

Coming to Aman searching Roshni he went to search he didnt find her and we got leap too ..Makers always rushed things so whatver we missed details its writers fault but again they planned for short epi so they wrapped up all fast forward ..

About now this aliya track i have few issues few epi they showed aman trusting aliya blindly they should have handled in a way aman not trusting roshni fine then dont trust aliya to then that would have been better but al done so cant do anything ..after middle of this track i didnt see anything much like trusting only aliya only he not doubted aliya thats it acutally he didnt cared much about her and i agree but not about trusting her ..cvs only highlighted his trust issues with Roshni only and we know why and separation track so defo he wont trust her anyway .. Aman throwing rosh out i blame both not only aman ..Rosh should have been careful when she knows aliya is playing ..i can understand her mother in danger but she should have handled situation better way ..So i am ok with this separation wont blame only one for aman throwing her out his anger is justified too .. upcoming i want Aman should understand Roshni and realise her value not just saying sorry and same i want Roshni should understand her self worth morethan anything she should start respect herself and use her ayana powers more intelligent way not to use without thinking outcomes!

Originally posted by: Roshan_93

I respect your thoughts ..Each and every person feel and understand each and every character differently .. As i said my case i watched all epi at a time so i understood Roshan and their story better way even if i watched frm start day 1 and waiting for episodes i should have missed few details because remembering all is difficult for me ..So i also judge based n that but here my case is different i watched the show recently one month old so i understand them like this ..others may not agree..because other feel other way too..but for me Aman character is complex hav layers and Roshni is simple and easy to understand ..So her love is always straight forward in actions r words not like Aman that how writers showed ..

In start episodes he always cared for her and hav feelings for her but he didnt realised ..if he dont realise then how he know that love feeling ? So nargis flowers not showed up ..And in sameer case if he doesnt care for Roshni how he become possessive and angry ?? Any person showing these feelings means love, care , liking something should be there we dont show all these kind of feelings for some random person n the road right..we show these kind of emotions if they r close to us so i dont agree he only loved instantly just because she come and dead for him ! May be people need few shocks to realize love for others and roshni death to aman is one of them to him ..and we dont value and realise people worth until we loose them. Thats happen in real life too !

Coming to Aman searching Roshni he went to search he didnt find her and we got leap too ..Makers always rushed things so whatver we missed details its writers fault but again they planned for short epi so they wrapped up all fast forward ..

About now this aliya track i have few issues few epi they showed aman trusting aliya blindly they should have handled in a way aman not trusting roshni fine then dont trust aliya to then that would have been better but al done so cant do anything ..after middle of this track i didnt see anything much like trusting only aliya only he not doubted aliya thats it acutally he didnt cared much about her and i agree but not about trusting her ..cvs only highlighted his trust issues with Roshni only and we know why and separation track so defo he wont trust her anyway .. Aman throwing rosh out i blame both not only aman ..Rosh should have been careful when she knows aliya is playing ..i can understand her mother in danger but she should have handled situation better way ..So i am ok with this separation wont blame only one for aman throwing her out his anger is justified too .. upcoming i want Aman should understand Roshni and realise her value not just saying sorry and same i want Roshni should understand her self worth morethan anything she should start respect herself and use her ayana powers more intelligent way not to use without thinking outcomes!

I can see why you feel that way but for me love or no love, care or no care, basic respect is must. Aman has flip flopped a lot and his respect was like a see saw. He would treat her well and then something would happen and he would call her names. He saved her but she was there because of him. Okay even if I let all of that go I hated that his care was conditional as well. You don’t call names to a person you care for and you don’t kick them out of the house twice. I am not talking about trust but simple respect one human has towards other. Even if he was upset with Roshni’s mum profession and her one dance it doesn’t allow him any right to disrespect her and certainly not after marrying her. He was very hot and cold with her and even if it’s his nature or what he was respectful to Adaah his half wife? Maybe her profession was acceptable.

After roshni died and redemption of Aman after kabir I wanted a proper love story track where foundation is built but instead this Alia came and brought his flaws out with more clarity. He said to roshni I love you a lot but love and trust goes hand in hand. You can’t have one without the other. This even after roshni proving her worth and dying for him. I don’t buy the hypnotised drama and him going for walks with Alia and in her room at midnight all this was not needed.

Roshni has a very good heart and she has never had a family and their love. She said that to him. Had he paid attention to roshni his mother would have been fine so he is responsible for his mother’s condition and roshni didn’t leave Parveen she had permission to go. Of course only people who can confirm one he doesn’t trust and other can’t talk. Also his throwing her out all the time is very disrespectful as well. Although today I didn’t mind as I wanted her gone by any means so this was okay.

For me Aman was never a price catch and his Alia track proved it.

Originally posted by: vibha28

I can see why you feel that way but for me love or no love, care or no care, basic respect is must. Aman has flip flopped a lot and his respect was like a see saw. He would treat her well and then something would happen and he would call her names. He saved her but she was there because of him. Okay even if I let all of that go I hated that his care was conditional as well. You don’t call names to a person you care for and you don’t kick them out of the house twice. I am not talking about trust but simple respect one human has towards other. Even if he was upset with Roshni’s mum profession and her one dance it doesn’t allow him any right to disrespect her and certainly not after marrying her. He was very hot and cold with her and even if it’s his nature or what he was respectful to Adaah his half wife? Maybe her profession was acceptable.

After roshni died and redemption of Aman after kabir I wanted a proper love story track where foundation is built but instead this Alia came and brought his flaws out with more clarity. He said to roshni I love you a lot but love and trust goes hand in hand. You can’t have one without the other. This even after roshni proving her worth and dying for him. I don’t buy the hypnotised drama and him going for walks with Alia and in her room at midnight all this was not needed.

Roshni has a very good heart and she has never had a family and their love. She said that to him. Had he paid attention to roshni his mother would have been fine so he is responsible for his mother’s condition and roshni didn’t leave Parveen she had permission to go. Of course only people who can confirm one he doesn’t trust and other can’t talk. Also his throwing her out all the time is very disrespectful as well. Although today I didn’t mind as I wanted her gone by any means so this was okay.

For me Aman was never a price catch and his Alia track proved it.

For alia track if writers give proper redemption track for aman now we have to see...anyway i always love separation because of passion and angst ...so for that one character def gets butchered here aman ..daily tv soap it happens ..but anyway i always take in a positive way so im k with this stupid reasons for separation ..i want to see aman sorting out trust issues and again his realization how wrong he is with rosh all i can watch just bec VSC acting ..i’m greedy to watch ..and about today epi m ok with his anger because his mother is n critical condition ..any son react like the way aman reacted so m ok with this ..i dont blame him . About rosh even parveen said to go but promise between her and aman so she should have been careful..after separtion i want her to be independant , respecting her self and love herself and same time she also stop using her clips here and there without thinking of consequences ..So this separation and leap will bring freshness to story ..hope for best