Originally posted by: Scarlet.ferro
Though I too was on your side and found all the romance out of place but I re-watched the episodes after the 'notice' because no matter how messed up the the original bhagya has been with storyline, kundali has been consistent.
So :
Firstly I want to bring something in everyone's notice that we all were mad at Karan for believing the photo , but I have realised now that
A) He himself had hired an investigator who was spying on sharlyn because he askem him to. And with the frame of mind which Karan was in after rishabh got married, it would have been quite unrealistic if he went on to doubt his own hired investigator's given photograph as a proof.
Yes, things could have been different if those photographs were given to him by sharlyn herself but this was not the case.
His absolute confirmation on the proof (given by investigator) was catalysed by preeta's absence from the mandap.
So believing the notice was no biggie because it was what preeta was already accused for.
Engagement , the retaliation. Both emotional and physical.
Writers had been constantly showing Karan as a character stuck between his belief and his emotions. Though he himself believes that his marriage to mahira is an escape from divorce and alimony mess ( I don't know how; may be because his marriage with preeta is not registered) , he still wants to see how this is going to effect preeta because her marriage with prithvi shook him despite every mess they were in.
He was shown repeatedly on how his concern was least on his engagement and fiance but more on why was preeta present there.
Also, he needs, wants any sort of reaction from preeta's side and cannot stand indifference, clue, the WhatsApp conversation.
With every passing episodes from there on, Karan had been shown to have plethora of emotions ranging from too much hurt to absolute anger to desperation to needful. He is egoistic and there's no if's and buts to this but he needs preeta to keep him sane and that's what writers have been showing in my opinion. "Ladai bhi tumse , judaai bhi tumse, pyaar bhi tumse" though when Karan had confessed, he was spiteful but his confession wasn't completely staged. Not for me. Not for writers either. Because even during the hate track, specially jail track there were quite a few dialogues that were given to Karan which were more out of natural instincts. Eg, when preeta said prithvi ji meri aane wali Zindagi hai..
Karan suddenly taken aback and immediately responded with 'agar so tumhari Zindagi hai toh Mai kaun hu preeta. Mai Kya lagta hu tunhara'.
Karan's reality with respect to preeta is completely different from his feelings for her no matter how much twisted they are.
He agreed to marry mahira in his anger and his version of reality. But his heart had been constantly in search of reaction and in need to see the unsettling in preeta in this marriage just like how he had them.
This whole mess is because of the lack of confession from both the sides. The love and hate has got so badly mixed that both the emotions flow simultaneously in him as if they are independent of his brain.
When he was putting ring in mahira's hand, he was shown not only hesitant but reluctant because even though his conscious mind knows preeta has wronged him, his sub conscious mind keeps nagging him regarding his unclaimed un-realised love for her.
He didn't make Mahira wear the ring because he wanted to but because he remembered preeta said 'usse koi faraq nahi padta'.
It was more of 'mujhe bhi faraq nahi padta' reaction from him.
However from then on it was about 'mujhe faraq padta hai and I will make sure she says use bhi faraq padta hai' . Courtesy, his mehendi.
Amidst all this chaos, Karan has never taken preeta ' s moral safety lightly. His hateness does not include preeta getting into grave physical danger.
This is coming full circle. From terror attack to preeta being in jail, Karan had and has kept his personal turmoil secondary, first being preeta's safety.
He for now knows preeta cannot kill someone.
However he is still holding onto gold digger part.
All this romance and all is misplaced from preeta's perspective. Karan had been this fluctuating from day 1, worse , post rishabh's marriage.
comment:
p_commentcount