What’s up with Karan? - Page 2

Originally posted by: msainhjaug

@red - all things are fine, we know he always say one thing and do exactly opposite very next moment.. but when suddenly he decided to give her a pass on Rishab's marriage misunderstanding and divorce notice n why? There's nothing to trigger it.. no point he even thought to himself about it.. nowhere it was even hinted.. it would be REALLY lame if reason was that preeta pushed him away in dressing room.. and suddenly he decided to be civil to her..

Preeta pushing him away did bring some thought in him, but it made him go further with the mehandi to torture preeta more. So there wasn't anything being more civil to her. But in the hall, after few incidents that happened within the hall and between them made him forget why in the first place he was fighting with her. He was again subconsciously trying to get along with preeta again and he has his own stupid reasons just like always.

But again karan shouldn't be completely accepting preeta, so these Mahira fake accident triggered the old anger and hate in him. Thankfully it didn't last like the other prevailing miss understandings (joining hands with sherlyn and divorce notice). But instead he believes that she can never be that cruel enough to attempt a murder on mahira and that too to get him. He still is very careful with the words he say with her whenever he is now around with her to show his support that he is supporting her for this case alone not for all other issues. He is behaving like he is returning the favor which she did for him (dadi's treatment )

Originally posted by: Scarlet.ferro

I don't think Karan was ever 'civil' with her per say, let alone after the push.

Infact, that push made him to retaliate. And he booked kumkum bhagya hall out of respite.

Even in kumkum bhagya hall, he was after her life. In fact, he stopped down to physically hurt her to get the confession ki use faraq padta hai. If you find it as a civil behavior, sorry I don't have an explanation to that.

I don't see Karan behaving in any decent manner with her except for last two episodes when he has believed she is not a murderer.

Karan mellow downed a bit when he saw her saving his family from the goon , and when preeta came to treat Dadi keeping their personal grudge aside.

I think writers are focusing more on karan's complexed emotional behavior over preeta's .

Because honestly, she is more of a pathetic written character for me.

Karan have had reasons to be the aashole that he is, but preeta being a spineless doormat has no explanation whatsoever.

She is fine with being thrown out of a house with literally every possible insult.

She is okay to stay connected and smile and blush for a man who dumped her on a deserted road after fake confessing his love and freaking married her .

I hope writers seriously take her character more into account and justify her recent behavior just like they are doing with Karan and rishabh.

well said.

whatever u said about preeta, i totally agree with u.

i m disappointed with her character to the core.

writers really need to focus on her character. she looks really pathetic and needy.

she is a well educated and supposedly sensible girl. such desperate behavior isnt expected from her.

Originally posted by: Scarlet.ferro

I don't think Karan was ever 'civil' with her per say, let alone after the push.

Infact, that push made him to retaliate. And he booked kumkum bhagya hall out of respite.

Even in kumkum bhagya hall, he was after her life. In fact, he stopped down to physically hurt her to get the confession ki use faraq padta hai. If you find it as a civil behavior, sorry I don't have an explanation to that.

I don't see Karan behaving in any decent manner with her except for last two episodes when he has believed she is not a murderer.

Karan mellow downed a bit when he saw her saving his family from the goon , and when preeta came to treat Dadi keeping their personal grudge aside.

I think writers are focusing more on karan's complexed emotional behavior over preeta's .

Because honestly, she is more of a pathetic written character for me.

Karan have had reasons to be the aashole that he is, but preeta being a spineless doormat has no explanation whatsoever.

She is fine with being thrown out of a house with literally every possible insult.

She is okay to stay connected and smile and blush for a man who dumped her on a deserted road after fake confessing his love and freaking married her .

I hope writers seriously take her character more into account and justify her recent behavior just like they are doing with Karan and rishabh.

The thing is 'hindi serials' and Indian TV serials in general have always had more focus on the female 'protagonists' and Ekta shows in particular have had a traditional focus on the female 'antagonist' as well and Kundali Bhagya isn't technically and exception, but from the very beginning, although this might be a controversial opinion but I have felt that the makers have focused especially the important plot elements with the male 'protagonists' (Karan and Rishabh) and their counter male 'antagonist' (Prithvi Malhotra). The story, the perspective, the plot and the real complexities of emotions actually coming from the 'male' characters of the show has honestly made all the 'female characters', such as Shrishti, Preeta and even Sherlyn more one toned and dare I say look oddly under-baked in comparison. Hence, Preeta sometimes seems not just doormat-esque but also absolutely pathetic.

Originally posted by: Scarlet.ferro

I don't think Karan was ever 'civil' with her per say, let alone after the push.

Infact, that push made him to retaliate. And he booked kumkum bhagya hall out of respite.

Even in kumkum bhagya hall, he was after her life. In fact, he stopped down to physically hurt her to get the confession ki use faraq padta hai. If you find it as a civil behavior, sorry I don't have an explanation to that.

I don't see Karan behaving in any decent manner with her except for last two episodes when he has believed she is not a murderer.

Karan mellow downed a bit when he saw her saving his family from the goon , and when preeta came to treat Dadi keeping their personal grudge aside.

I think writers are focusing more on karan's complexed emotional behavior over preeta's .

Because honestly, she is more of a pathetic written character for me.

Karan have had reasons to be the aashole that he is, but preeta being a spineless doormat has no explanation whatsoever.

She is fine with being thrown out of a house with literally every possible insult.

She is okay to stay connected and smile and blush for a man who dumped her on a deserted road after fake confessing his love and freaking married her .

I hope writers seriously take her character more into account and justify her recent behavior just like they are doing with Karan and rishabh.

Well by his own standards n his behaviour with preeta since marriage, he is pretty civil.. asking her to accept that she feels for him instead of saying you deserve what happened to you is pretty civil and out of context.. but you are more focused on word civil than my issue with no clear reason/intention highlighted in the show to accept this transition.. this feels abrupt and unacceptable

Even in kumkum bhagya hall, he was trying to save them from his own family before robbers entry.. even though he was pretending to be on Kareena's side he was in fact working for aroras.. he was once part of this family and will always mean well even if he can't accept that, this i can accept.. but his interactions with preeta even before robbers entry were on lighter note comparitively and were always about what she feels for him.. why? There is difference at least for me between someone hell bent on getting you to accept your love for him and getting accused of really serious moral grounds

Why is it not about divorce notice anymore... he almost agreed with kareena bua to put blame on preeta having affair being the reason for breaking marriage.. so why it went to a lighter note after that.. and please don't tell me you don't find any lighter note between above two sentiments.. between divorce notice and mehandi, i don't recall anything happening which could give preeta clean chit for him

Why all those comments about how preeta betrayed them stopped coming? In fact those comments n those issues are just removed out of existence.. only kareena bua gang repeats it over and over... he is absolutely cool with it?

He don't care about sherlyn anymore.. did he forget she is pregnant.. did he even try to know if rishab is happy at all with her.. did he try to know if she is still having affair with that guy.. what is she upto.. or was he only concerned about that whole issue because preeta was involved in it?

I am not breaking my head over these things 😃 i don't expect so much from writers but when you say its consistent, hell no.. there are other characters consistent.. actually every other character is probably consistent here but definetly not main lead

Originally posted by: msainhjaug

Well by his own standards n his behaviour with preeta since marriage, he is pretty civil.. asking her to accept that she feels for him instead of saying you deserve what happened to you is pretty civil and out of context.. but you are more focused on word civil than my issue with no clear reason/intention highlighted in the show to accept this transition.. this feels abrupt and unacceptable

Even in kumkum bhagya hall, he was trying to save them from his own family before robbers entry.. even though he was pretending to be on Kareena's side he was in fact working for aroras.. he was once part of this family and will always mean well even if he can't accept that, this i can accept.. but his interactions with preeta even before robbers entry were on lighter note comparitively and were always about what she feels for him.. why? There is difference at least for me between someone hell bent on getting you to accept your love for him and getting accused of really serious moral grounds

Why is it not about divorce notice anymore... he almost agreed with kareena bua to put blame on preeta having affair being the reason for breaking marriage.. so why it went to a lighter note after that.. and please don't tell me you don't find any lighter note between above two sentiments.. between divorce notice and mehandi, i don't recall anything happening which could give preeta clean chit for him

Why all those comments about how preeta betrayed them stopped coming? In fact those comments n those issues are just removed out of existence.. only kareena bua gang repeats it over and over... he is absolutely cool with it?

He don't care about sherlyn anymore.. did he forget she is pregnant.. did he even try to know if rishab is happy at all with her.. did he try to know if she is still having affair with that guy.. what is she upto.. or was he only concerned about that whole issue because preeta was involved in it?

I am not breaking my head over these things 😃 i don't expect so much from writers but when you say its consistent, hell no.. there are other characters consistent.. actually every other character is probably consistent here but definetly not main lead

i actually do find karan's chatacter inconsistent. all other character are consistent in my opinion. like preeta consistently being doormat.

i believe this inconsistency in karan's character is for dragging purpose. thats why he has forgotton sherlyn's pregnancy and alimony notice temporarily. he will start talking about these issues again when those tracks will be started.

Originally posted by: msainhjaug

Well by his own standards n his behaviour with preeta since marriage, he is pretty civil.. asking her to accept that she feels for him instead of saying you deserve what happened to you is pretty civil and out of context.. but you are more focused on word civil than my issue with no clear reason/intention highlighted in the show to accept this transition.. this feels abrupt and unacceptable

Even in kumkum bhagya hall, he was trying to save them from his own family before robbers entry.. even though he was pretending to be on Kareena's side he was in fact working for aroras.. he was once part of this family and will always mean well even if he can't accept that, this i can accept.. but his interactions with preeta even before robbers entry were on lighter note comparitively and were always about what she feels for him.. why? There is difference at least for me between someone hell bent on getting you to accept your love for him and getting accused of really serious moral grounds

Why is it not about divorce notice anymore... he almost agreed with kareena bua to put blame on preeta having affair being the reason for breaking marriage.. so why it went to a lighter note after that.. and please don't tell me you don't find any lighter note between above two sentiments.. between divorce notice and mehandi, i don't recall anything happening which could give preeta clean chit for him

Why all those comments about how preeta betrayed them stopped coming? In fact those comments n those issues are just removed out of existence.. only kareena bua gang repeats it over and over... he is absolutely cool with it?

He don't care about sherlyn anymore.. did he forget she is pregnant.. did he even try to know if rishab is happy at all with her.. did he try to know if she is still having affair with that guy.. what is she upto.. or was he only concerned about that whole issue because preeta was involved in it?

I am not breaking my head over these things 😃 i don't expect so much from writers but when you say its consistent, hell no.. there are other characters consistent.. actually every other character is probably consistent here but definetly not main lead

You didn't get what I tried to explain.

Its his inconsistency that has been kept consistent.

He was repeatedly talking about divorce and dhokha earlier because nothing else had happened in that period. No marriage from either side.

The focus got shifted to more on emotional front mixed with anger when marriage came into picture and preeta's apparent indifference in his engagement.

And exactly.

Absolutely nothing has happened which can make preeta forgive him. He has not even acknowledged that he was wrong to the T.

That's why I am more upset on preeta because her blushing and smiling and love moments just don't make sense.

She was on the receiving end of all his torments and if anyone who should stand firm. But unfortunately she is weaving dreams to spend her rest of the life with him.

I have no issue with character development with Karan or rishabh but definitely with preeta.

character of preeta will develope truly after real breakup of karan preeta and their namesake mrg truth out.

toot toot ke insaan strong banta hai ..somewhere she considers karan her husband because of his fake care dialogues promises..flirtings but jis din karan wo rishta bhi tod diya us din their rishta will be over !

Originally posted by: jaanulovejaanam

character of preeta will develope truly after real breakup of karan preeta and their namesake mrg truth out.

toot toot ke insaan strong banta hai ..somewhere she considers karan her husband because of his fake care dialogues promises..flirtings but jis din karan wo rishta bhi tod diya us din their rishta will be over !

IKR? I feel the real “breakup” or “separation” is yet to come. This isn’t going to be the only ‘heartbreak’ both Karan & Preeta face....

Originally posted by: SophieKarim

IKR? I feel the real “breakup” or “separation” is yet to come. This isn’t going to be the only ‘heartbreak’ both Karan & Preeta face....

this is what I feel.

normal heartbreak nahin hona... kuchh bohot bada hoga which will lead to their breakup forever...