When in the house, the relationship dynamics are dictated by outside factors like Salman khan/weekends, callers, guests, and wildcards. The factors inside the house will be the captaincy task/luxury budget tasks, hokes and tiffs between housemates, the equations they already share outside, and of course the four walls! And those cameras.
So I was wondering, would asims and sids friendship had suffered this dramatic downfall if they would have been outside? Would arti be still this much interfering? Would paras and Mahira and sana keep oscillating, or would there be no side to oscillate? Would asim fall for a committed girl, and would that girl still be so comfortable with him even after knowing he is falling for her? Would sana be conflicted and this vocal about it if she likes two guys and can't make up her mind?
What I think, that even though the big boss is a small experiment to see how isolation affects people in general, it's also an experiment to see how human beings behave typically, I found that no, human beings do not behave that way at all.
I do not think that these people push each other when they face conflict on the job. That sid and Rashmi may not like each other but they won't talk about each other behind their back and they would be cordial, even friendly. That sid and asim may have differences they would still be friends.
That once outside the house, sana and sid won't sustain, sana needs attention. Constant attention And once outside, sid will have other commitments like job, parents, siblings, friends, the attention will wane off. That paras and Akanksha will continue to be happily ever after for few more months. That asim will find his one space and will be back with sid as a friend. That Rashmi will ditch arhan for good once outside, may even take legal actions.
I wonder, will we behave the same way if we were to be confined like this? maybe we will. So even if the show is 'scripted', psychology plays a major factor here.