Kon Secret room ke liye jyada deserving tha

I think it was Rashmi along with devolina

Because

1. She needs friends like Devo who are straight forward in their opinion, they don't like to sugar-coat their friends. Bus Jo theek laga would bol Diya

2. It'd give her more time to think about arhaan and her relationship with him, plus Ramlal ki sachai bhi bahar aa jati

3. Shefali jarawala ki sachai bhi bahar aa jati that how she's planning and plotting against Rashmi always

4. Maybe she'd get a clearance about bhau, Vishal n aarti

What do you think guys

Originally posted by: viknandera

I think it was Rashmi along with devolina

Because

1. She needs friends like Devo who are straight forward in their opinion, they don't like to sugar-coat their friends. Bus Jo theek laga would bol Diya

2. It'd give her more time to think about arhaan and her relationship with him, plus Ramlal ki sachai bhi bahar aa jati

3. Shefali jarawala ki sachai bhi bahar aa jati that how she's planning and plotting against Rashmi always

4. Maybe she'd get a clearance about bhau, Vishal n aarti

What do you think guys

I think Sid in the secret room is still a good idea BUT not with Paras. They should have shown him what Paras really thinks about Shukla. Sid would have understood Paras’s complete game.

Paras kisi sey loyal nahi hai. He has said so many times what he truly thinks of Shukla. He thinks with his mind and this game is a kind of chess for him (mind you he is playing well) and he’s trying to get to the raja (Sid). They should have shown Sid the truth about Paras and his game. That would have been a good idea.

I’m copying and pasting here from a topic I posted -

Secret rooms are effective when the person in the room can have a revelation of some sort. Everyone knows here that Paras and Sid aren’t well liked in the house. There is no mystery to be uncovered. In addition everyone in the house knows that both contestants will be back, So there is no element of surprise either.

Only motive this serves is it allows Paras and Sid to form a stronger bond and become a fly on the wall in opposite team’s discussions (Asim and others). This is not content. It’s biases.

Sid could have seen what the Paras, Sana and Mahira equation would have worked out to be. He would have seen how much Sana really likes Paras (it seems like she does) and new drama would have unfolded between Mahira and Sana. This Could have been interesting.

With Rashmi, there really isn’t much to that story - Arhaan isn’t essentially saying anything really bad about her and Devo isn’t in the house. She’s not such a big player at this time.

Rashmi would NOT be a good choice for SR.

2. Arhaan wouldn't have said those things about Rashmi if Rashmi was out (he'd know Rashmi might be in SR & watching him, he's not dumb to not understand they won't oust her after the massive revelation on national TV).

3. Shefali was indirectly doing it (aur wo bhi acchai ka dhong karte hue), she isn't gonna openly discuss it with anyone that she tried to convince Rashmi to quit the show.

Rashmi would've been BORING inside SR like she's in main house. Plus she's got no game plan & gets easily influenced.

Only Sid & Paras are perfect candidates for SR who can make SR fun to watch & also turn things around once inside main house.

Rashmi gets so easily manipulated that she does not trust her own judgements and negates things which happen in front of her. The way Salman and Arhan took minutes to make her unsee things which she saw, heard and realized made me believe that she is dumb and spineless. She would have been the worst contestant for secret room. Woh dekh kar bhi kuch nahi samajhti.

Sidharth minus Paras. But guess makers do not deem Sidharth fit enough to be left alone.

Originally posted by: MercurialMedusa

Sidharth minus Paras. But guess makers do not deem Sidharth fit enough to be left alone.

They put Paras inside to save him from this week's nomination.. as that's the only way.

I agree, if we cancel Arhan, Rashmi would have never been a good choice. She has a forgiving kind of nature, she would have listened, watched and forgiven, she is too naive for SR. I feel, Devo would have been a good choice, she knows how to give it back to people, Paras if would have been in the main house, he would have been trapped the most as he talks, plans more about other people. Talking about Sid knowing Paras's identity, Siddharth already knows that Paras is a gamer and he can flip anytime. During nomination time, he accepted that he isn't friends with Paras. He is with Paras only because of Sana's equation with Paras and it's quite visible that Shukla gives Sana the most priority. I feel that Devo would have been the best choice. Also, Paras in an evil way is the best choice as he may turn the game. Can't say much about Siddharth as he already knows what others think about him, everyone is already against him. He only trusts Sana which in my opinion won't say anything.

Originally posted by: SimsNaiken

I think Sid in the secret room is still a good idea BUT not with Paras. They should have shown him what Paras really thinks about Shukla. Sid would have understood Paras’s complete game.

Paras kisi sey loyal nahi hai. He has said so many times what he truly thinks of Shukla. He thinks with his mind and this game is a kind of chess for him (mind you he is playing well) and he’s trying to get to the raja (Sid). They should have shown Sid the truth about Paras and his game. That would have been a good idea.

I’m copying and pasting here from a topic I posted -

Secret rooms are effective when the person in the room can have a revelation of some sort. Everyone knows here that Paras and Sid aren’t well liked in the house. There is no mystery to be uncovered. In addition everyone in the house knows that both contestants will be back, So there is no element of surprise either.

Only motive this serves is it allows Paras and Sid to form a stronger bond and become a fly on the wall in opposite team’s discussions (Asim and others). This is not content. It’s biases.

Sid could have seen what the Paras, Sana and Mahira equation would have worked out to be. He would have seen how much Sana really likes Paras (it seems like she does) and new drama would have unfolded between Mahira and Sana. This Could have been interesting.

With Rashmi, there really isn’t much to that story - Arhaan isn’t essentially saying anything really bad about her and Devo isn’t in the house. She’s not such a big player at this time.

no i dont think sid alone would have not been good choice for secret room at this stage

paras was out for surgery so he clearly knows whats going outside about the support sid is getting, so he would have not believed that sid was evicted at this stage since half of the game was still remaining and sid could be back anytime so he would have been very cautious in saying anything about sid

also he is smart enough to guess that sid might be put into secret room to see who is saying what behind his back and thus he would learn more about the game and return with new and better strategy

also paras has clearly understood channel's bias for sid so he would have guessed easily that sid is being treated to calm his aggression and even if he would have not guessed about the secret room (which i dont think is possible since he has great knowledge of bb and thus knows secret room is there in every season), so would have understood that he will return soon and might be outside watching all episodes

I like Rashmi tons more than Paras and Sidharth, but I don't think it would have made much difference if she went to the secret room. She gets influenced way too easily. That woman still trusts Paras in the game for some ridiculous reason.

I would have wanted Sidharth in the secret room, while Paras is in the main house. It would have been fun to see his reaction to the raja-rani type comments that Paras makes.

Originally posted by: peacenfun

no i dont think sid alone would have not been good choice for secret room at this stage

paras was out for surgery so he clearly knows whats going outside about the support sid is getting, so he would have not believed that sid was evicted at this stage since half of the game was still remaining and sid could be back anytime so he would have been very cautious in saying anything about sid

also he is smart enough to guess that sid might be put into secret room to see who is saying what behind his back and thus he would learn more about the game and return with new and better strategy

also paras has clearly understood channel's bias for sid so he would have guessed easily that sid is being treated to calm his aggression and even if he would have not guessed about the secret room (which i dont think is possible since he has great knowledge of bb and thus knows secret room is there in every season), so would have understood that he will return soon and might be outside watching all episodes

Hmmmm perhaps you are right. Maybe secret room at this point was a bit premature entirely.