It was a task ....why bring gender issue here - Page 2

Originally posted by: s2397

Mahaan sid s didn't even think to say sorry for once.. Even if you unknowingly do some mistake you're supposed to say sorry. That's the issue.

The question could be reversed like why he didn't let go knowing that he could end up hurting her. Both were wrong and mahira deserved to get the same treatment like mr. Shukla.

So u are saying that he should have just let Mahira win...so what is the point of playing then...pehle he ek kone men baith jaaye....do u see the unfairness in what u are asking him to do?? Mahira shouldn't let go...but Sid should let go...wah wah👏..

My problem is why not BB giving them tasks where mental ability is used and not physical so much....but if a task is there where men have advantage ..then so be it.....men don't have to suffer because BB's tasks are stupid.

Originally posted by: tina59

I am sorry but people are unnecessarily making it about a gender issue.

It was a task where everyone is bound to get hurt coz the task itself was designed to snatch and collect. There was no way this task was going to be done peacefully.

As Himanshi said everyone got hurt irrespective of being a girl or a boy.

Coming to Mahira- Sid S in this task

Sid S is tall and bulky and that goes against him all the time. How is he supposed to play such a task which requires physical force. Just coz the person against him is fragile, is he not supposed to give his best?. In this forum, people call him saand, hulk and a bully....mainly coz of his size .

Next coming to Mahira, she got hurt catching the sack which Sid S had held on to. Obviously the more powerful one will win the round. She got hurt and rightfully got upset. Sid S should have apologized to her then and there and also helped her.

Instead Mahira accused him of pushing her which worked against her in WKV. Then came the Paras push which was immediately after that and Sid S retaliated too.

Mahira too pushed Shefali and then asked her to not touch her.

All I want to say is both went wrong and playing aggressively happens with both parties . Everyone got hurt This was dragged like a chewing gum .

Now coming to Rashmi, she is an entitled hypocrite who thinks she can do no wrong. She can interrupt , target, talk about anyone but if anyone else does the same, they have no class or are mannerless

her language is even more vile.

Devo can talk potty talk, hit , Mahira can push and give gaali's, Paras can demean women with words, Rashmi can talk crap , go to someones family, Sana can call someone "wh+re", Sid S can demean women, Asim too,

Basically all of them have been the same , but why glorify one and put down another when all parties have been involved in mud slinging and bad behavior. I don't understand why drag the gender issue.

There have been so many seasons where such tasks has happened where physical force has to be used and be it guys or gals they all used to give their best and have done well too. I didn't see many playing the woman card or the man card.

You summarised it perfectly! Housemates only complain about sid’s Aggression forgetting their own actions and instigations. Acting like they are innocent victims...really enjoyed the WKW - the push to Mahira was proved false, he had not even touched her.

Paras’s finger —was not Sid

The reason people like Sid inspite of his temper is because he is honest and actually states the fact as is, not like others who get amnesia on their own actions.

Originally posted by: roni_berna

It doesn't even call for a gender issue as anyone who's strong should use force moderately and not be so strong that anyone else gets hurt. Sid should know when to stop but he doesn't care and hence he grabbed the sack with full force. Not touching or touching her is not the issue but causing harm purposely is and this task was such that everyone got hurt while Shukla and Shehnaaz were two HMs who did it on purpose while others got hurt while throwing sacks and boxes or by mistake. Just imagine you grabbing something from a person and that person goes and hits something which causes an accident, who will be held responsible then? This is how accidents take place.

Yes, Mahira also pushed him on purpose later and started pulling Asim's shorts which was wrong but I don't support the grabbing sack incident. You shouldn't be using so much force just for some stupid task.

WRONG....its a task where people have to win.....its the responsibility of each person to look out for themselves....the minute Mahira realized that she could have gotten hurt...she should have moved out...Sid shouldn't be responsible for Mahira......Its like that task where people were putting stuff on Asim's face and he quit....because he didn't want harm on himself.....you can't make the other person quit.

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

So u are saying that he should have just let Mahira win...so what is the point of playing then...pehle he ek kone men baith jaaye....do u see the unfairness in what u are asking him to do?? Mahira shouldn't let go...but Sid should let go...wah wah👏..

My problem is why not BB giving them tasks where mental ability is used and not physical so much....but if a task is there where men have advantage ..then so be it.....men don't have to suffer because BB's tasks are stupid.

Valid point, if everyone starts thinking about not hurting girls then they can never play. There were 4 other girls also playing why its always Mahira who complains..she was the most aggressive of all , she feels like she is some miss high and mighty and others are all trash. The way she acted with Asim , literally pulling his pants down, she pushed Shefali then started shouting don’t touch me.. she needs to practice what she preaches..

i agree, today also mahira was asked why didnt u leave the sack, n she said sid ne bhi nahi choda. why shd sid leave? he was doing a task? mai ladki hun he is a man, then y consider yourself equal if u want a man to give up the sack based on ur gender?

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

So u are saying that he should have just let Mahira win...so what is the point of playing then...pehle he ek kone men baith jaaye....do u see the unfairness in what u are asking him to do?? Mahira shouldn't let go...but Sid should let go...wah wah👏..

My problem is why not BB giving them tasks where mental ability is used and not physical so much....but if a task is there where men have advantage ..then so be it.....men don't have to suffer because BB's tasks are stupid.

My point is It's unfair from both sides. Why only blame one. Then why should mahira let go. In the game even she wanted to win and she also couldn't think quickly. Why should she calculate only and not sid. An aggressive person should also need to be careful.

P. S. Brain games bb ke bas ki baat nahi hai.. That's why all these stupid physical task.

How do the other guys manage to play the same game with the same rules without hurting people in the game? 😕

Sid's team had more girls and the probability of them getting pushed around was much higher than Mahira. Could it be that the other guys know that its just a game and in their competitive spirit you should still be mindful of not hurting people?

🤣🤣🤣

Originally posted by: s2397

My point is It's unfair from both sides. Why only blame one. Then why should mahira let go. In the game even she wanted to win and she also couldn't think quickly. Why should she calculate only and not sid. An aggressive person should also need to be careful.

P. S. Brain games bb ke bas ki baat nahi hai.. That's why all these stupid physical task.

Exactly! Why can't the rules be more clear? BB is to be blamed for pitting girls against boys in such aggressive games with the obvious advantage to boys. What does salmaan mean by move out of the boys way? Why should she? BB creatives have really low IQ and are unable to come up with any tasks that allow for equal play. I would love to see more mental challenges than these stupid boring tasks where people with half a brain just go destroy the whole game and make it ugly.

Everyone got hurt but nobody fell as badly as Mahira did. And this is the second time it happened. So it was bound to become an issue. Sid was targeting her whole day so she had an outburst when finally she fell. On top of that Sid (and Asim) jeered at her without being apologetic and that made her even angrier. Also when she was sitting in a corner Asim climbed on top of her to invade their territory and in retaliation she went to snatch sack from Shefali. Paras team was playing fair. In first round they had returned Asim's sack when he was acting like a baby, so obviously they got angry when other team was getting aggressive and stealing too.

All your points are right but Salman didn't touch any of these topics. Okay Sid already got punished so Salman should have said Mahira and others were also wrong but the way Salman was talking it felt like he was justifying Sid's behaviour and putting all the blame on Mahira and those who fought with him. The only person who was glorified was Sid.