This message in 3 Idiots. - Page 3

I always thought the message was that no problem in the world big enough to throw yourself off a building. Nothing can ever be that bad.

anyways nice thread Luna, this is what we should be doing in a movies forum, discussing movies.

Obviously our(not all but most of us including me) temptation of discussing the sex and romanctic life of celebs is stronger than our desire to discuss movies.

Originally posted by: DragonBoy49

I always thought the message was that no problem in the world big enough to throw yourself off a building. Nothing can ever be that bad.

Jumping off the building actually helped him in not getting rusticated and getting a positive attitude.😆

Originally posted by: Luna46

Phunsuk Wangdu was an adult and was responsible for his own actions. He wasn't exploited by Ranchhodas family. He could've said no and walked away. Being an orphan doesn't give him right to commit fraud. He was part of the act, so yes, he can be charged for faking identity.

FY BTech students are usually 17-18 years old. So Phunsuk Wangdu could feasibly have been a minor when sent to the college by the Chanchad family. In addition, Phunsuk Wangdu could have even been younger.

But assuming that Phunsuk Wangdu was 18 he can easily claim not guilty by duress.

To charge anyone with fraud, you not only need the "act" of fraud but also the "intent" to commit fraud. The "intent" is very shaky in this case.

Originally posted by: return_to_hades

FY BTech students are usually 17-18 years old. So Phunsuk Wangdu could feasibly have been a minor when sent to the college by the Chanchad family. In addition, Phunsuk Wangdu could have even been younger.

But assuming that Phunsuk Wangdu was 18 he can easily claim not guilty by duress.

To charge anyone with fraud, you not only need the "act" of fraud but also the "intent" to commit fraud. The "intent" is very shaky in this case.

Phunsuk Wangdu might be a minor when he took admission but when he graduated, he must have been above 18 and an adult.

He can't really claim duress when he was staying away from the Chanchad family in Delhi. He could've ran away from the hostel whenever he wanted.

The intent was to fake an identity and then give your degree to someone else. He can be charged for that.

Hirani's movies aren't supposed to be taken seriously. I know it sounds like an oxymoron because he makes social dramedies. But his movies are nothing more than dramatized annual school plays that should be watched for entertainment purposes only.

The message you want to see is the message you see :p

Thank God it never occured to me ki aisa bhi msg hai movie me..and thankfully to majority people also.

For me the take aways were..

Success ke peeche mat bhaago..strive for excellence

Follow Ur dreams

Even in toughest situations trust that all is well

True friends always remain in our hearts ..no matter where they r and under what circumstances.

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Didnt the movie release like 10 years ago? Im sure no one cares about it or is thinking about it right now.

Originally posted by: niyati13

Thank God it never occured to me ki aisa bhi msg hai movie me..and thankfully to majority people also.

For me the take aways were..

Success ke peeche mat bhaago..strive for excellence

Follow Ur dreams

Even in toughest situations trust that all is well

True friends always remain in our hearts ..no matter where they r and under what circumstances.

Please read this article.😆

https://m.hindustantimes.com/delhi/fakes-break-into-iit-trigger-id-verification-crackdown/story-UZFAXXbNNauckMHlP3NACJ.html