I am not going to sit here and put down Vidya. I think she's a great actress and has done great work. I loved her the most in Bhool Bhulaiya and Kahaani. I am not doubting her talent.
But despite her talent - she is very problematic. She looks the same in the past couple of movies, same saree's and house-wife look. She needs to go beyond that. If we can rip apart Katrina for doing the same thing in every movie - then why not Vidya? just because shes good she can do the same role over and over again and I am just supposed to self-arouse myself and be okay with it?
Vidya lacks versatility and her image is very problematic. its not about weight but she just looks very unkempt and unhealthy. Look at people like Raveena who isnt exactly skinny but still presents herself with lots of grace- same with Manisha Koirala, Juhi etc. Vidya is in that age group.
You cant just act good in a movie and walk away with praise. Its not only about acting, this is the glamour industry for a reason.
0