First Impressions!!!! - Page 5

Originally posted by: -Villete-

Hey, there’s been no body shaming here! And about the jewelry, we are not discussing any actor’s personal life or beliefs. Ishani is wearing necklaces and bracelets too and I’m sure that must have been finalized by Sanjivani’s team as part of her look and not by the actress herself. Also, I had no idea about the fact that she wears those rings IRL as well. This was more of a discussion about the people who decided the look of the cast as opposed to actors themselves. Calm down, hun! We didn’t mean to offend you but thanks for the info. 😊😊

are you sure...?? please enlighten me in what category commenting on someone's lips is categorised...??

SC fans defo will be here...obviously she is the main lead man...and most of the online hype is for surbhi chandna only...one more thing the PRODUCER didnt give her this role juz like that...they do know her worth...for healthy conversation and feedback we SC fans r very much open...but this unnecessary hate to bring her down is very much childish...

Ppl talking so highly about sanjivani(1) and critisizing the dressing sense of this season is looking bleh for me...i did see the promos and theme of both sanjivani and dmg... there also it was not at all professional dressing...and please do watch the hairstyle of those shows too before commenting...

Originally posted by: Gdbs

SC fans defo will be here...obviously she is the main lead man...and most of the online hype is for surbhi chandna only...one more thing the PRODUCER didnt give her this role juz like that...they do know her worth...for healthy conversation and feedback we SC fans r very much open...but this unnecessary hate to bring her down is very much childish...

Ppl talking so highly about sanjivani(1) and critisizing the dressing sense of this season is looking bleh for me...i did see the promos and theme of both sanjivani and dmg... there also it was not at all professional dressing...and please do watch the hairstyle of those shows too before commenting...

Bad is bad. It was bad then, it is bad now. Glamor is fine but it should do justice to the genre as well.

The dressing sense part should be adhered to in a medical show where you want people to see them as doctors in every way. They have been promoting this show every now & then as a medical show. While they have made senior cast pay attention to nuances, junior casts doesn't do justice which it should be doing.

One can always evolve & learn to make things look more authentic with time. No one has to go back in past & say "oh they had the same shit back then". Even then it was objectionable, even now it is.

Originally posted by: intruderfast

Hi Arshi ji. Nostalgia unlimited. I have 2 say. All the 2 episodes were full on entertainment.

And Namik and surbhi seems to have a promising arc. Their Nok jhok is nice.

But real stars are Mohnish and Ronit till now.

Mohnish as always as Shashank is delight to watch.

Ronit is a grey character and he is playing it perfectly. He seems to be the scene stealer for me.

Fabulous acting by both.It a stellar cast this time.

Just hope this tempo continues

Senior cast is good & brings more depth to the genre. I hope they provide the same for the junior cast as well, the subtlety which this genre demands as a whole.

Medical genre is a difficult one with all the technical know-how, characterization & everything. There can be creative liberties but they shouldn't trump the seriousness of the genre.

Originally posted by: arshi_asya

Bad is bad. It was bad then, it is bad now. Glamor is fine but it should do justice to the genre as well.

The dressing sense part should be adhered to in a medical show where you want people to see them as doctors in every way. They have been promoting this show every now & then as a medical show. While they have made senior cast pay attention to nuances, junior casts doesn't do justice which it should be doing.

One can always evolve & learn to make things look more authentic with time. No one has to go back in past & say "oh they had the same shit back then". Even then it was objectionable, even now it is.

Well first of all thanks for agreeing bad is bad because I didn't get this impression when people were downgrading this new show compared to previous seasons as if others were masterpiece 😊.

@bold: isn't that subjective to personal choices here. While I agree that Sid and ishani interactions are forced and rushed, saying only senior save show?! I don't agree. None of the senior characters are attractive to me and new viewers because we don't even know their past. It's like they are being forced on us with no introduction characterwise.

let's agree to disagree on this topic.

Guys, I gather my post offended some of you. I really want you to know that I didn't mean to hurt the sentiments of my fellow viewers. You guys made a good point and I'd definitely make a mental note of it. Hope you'd accept my apologies and let this one go. I don't want to create differences here at the very beginning of a show that we have come to love over the years. I watched a few episodes of SC's last show and definitely appreciated her khidkitod chirpy attitude on it, so I'd like to make it clear that we have nothing against her. And like you pointed out, it's taking you guys a little while to warm upto the story and old characters from this series since you have never followed the previous two shows, it's probably taking us a while to get used to the quirks of the new faces too. Let's draw a truce and give the show another 2 weeks to pan out and present the bigger picture and I'm sure we'd all be back on the same boat.

I'm here to make friends not foes! So sorry for offending ya'll with my previous comment. I'll take it down 😊😊

Originally posted by: Anonyme

This seems to be more a post made to taunt the new leads 😂.

I will try to give my views in general to things raised here:

1) I get many don't like SC here, but she is the lead here. Many like me watching only for her since we never cared to watch sanjivani or dmg. If you guys will bash, we can do same here. But we are behaving.

2) from what i remember from hospitals in my country, only in OT no jewellery are worn or hairs are tied. Rest for normal consultation it's normal. So nothing wrong in that respect for me at least. Even dressing is normal for me.

3) SC is beautiful as she is, her lips too. Before you guys troll, have a look at your own favorites actors. Not necessarily everyone love the guys in your dps or the jodis clearly in your UNs.

4) being a doctor is a noble profession. And I respect it. However I would like to point out many viewers have zero knowledge about the medical terms or equipment being used. Already I bet majority are at lost with what is happening, more detailing might really blank out viewers and seem more like a documentary. A compromise is needed. No offense meant to doctors here. But not only doctors watch the show.

. I'm all for normal discussion. Fighting or bashing, count me out.

Peace out 😊

@bold.

No where in my post have I talked about actors but characters named Ishani, Sid & Asha, Shashank, Anjali, Vardaan.

Anyone who has seen residents closely knows how this field & people in this field work.

Characterization matters to me & many others here & a great actor is one who makes you immerse yourself in the character, forget the actor, relate to it, click in the very first note. Many watch the show for content & characters & not actors and Sanjivani promised content & characters of that field. I can mention my first impressions in my review.

Sid's act was an attempt to glorify malpractices of some doctors & it needs to be called out.

Creative liberties & immature drama should not trump the nuances of the field in a genre like this, something they did unabashedly. Why should Indian makers not make a world-class show & always be averaged down by arguments like it's an Indian TV show. Medical dramas have to maintain a standard to be revered & respected in all corners.

Sanjivani isn't a clinic where all you have to do is consultation. It's a multi-speciality hospital premise where residents practice almost all the cases for the whole day. Open hair for female doctors & nurses is a strict No in hospital premises during professional hours, unless you hail from management or legal dept who are mostly restricted to their office chambers. Even male doctors have reasonable restrictions on the beard they can keep. Hospitals have strict rules forbidding any sort of hand jwellery. Look closely, they avoid wearing their wedding rings as well during work hours. Even long nails & nailpaints are strict No. Even the jwellery they wear should be minimal- earings & what not. A male doctor in his shirt half opened during his working hours isn't normal from any angle, neither is doctors shouting in the middle of the hall or corridor. These are basic, fundamental rules of the field. Visit Fortis, Medanta or any other high profile hospital, these rules are followed everywhere, even in India. A show like this should upgrade & stick to these things instead of giving into glamor just for the sake of it. And no, it wouldn't turn a documentary just because they focus on these things, it will still remain a TV show like countless great medical dramas made all around the world where they pay attention to these things.

Originally posted by: Anonyme

Well first of all thanks for agreeing bad is bad because I didn't get this impression when people were downgrading this new show compared to previous seasons as if others were masterpiece 😊.

@bold: isn't that subjective to personal choices here. While I agree that Sid and ishani interactions are forced and rushed, saying only senior save show?! I don't agree. None of the senior characters are attractive to me and new viewers because we don't even know their past. It's like they are being forced on us with no introduction characterwise.

let's agree to disagree on this topic.

It's not about attractive actors but about characters which are doctors in the show & the senior actors click on that front, as doctors. A medical show full of doctors & not actors is what the whole point is. That's the mark of a great show with great characters where the actor dissolves within the character.

But let's agree to disagree on that front for I know, people may view shows differently.

Originally posted by: Anonyme

Well first of all thanks for agreeing bad is bad because I didn't get this impression when people were downgrading this new show compared to previous seasons as if others were masterpiece 😊.

@bold: isn't that subjective to personal choices here. While I agree that Sid and ishani interactions are forced and rushed, saying only senior save show?! I don't agree. None of the senior characters are attractive to me and new viewers because we don't even know their past. It's like they are being forced on us with no introduction characterwise.

let's agree to disagree on this topic.

My point...

also no one is trying to keep the conversation healthy here...u ppl r more into trolling mocking and bodyshaming and some enjoying the bodyshaming...

u ppl can also raise ur voice against bodyshaming...

And i want to brighten the word it is ITV...

and some commenting and enjoying bodyshaming here are fans of some most illogical shows...👏

Originally posted by: arshi_asya

@bold.

No where in my post have I talked about actors but characters named Ishani, Sid & Asha, Shashank, Anjali, Vardaan.

But check your thread well into what it turned into. It was more a trolling than normal discussion.

Anyone who has seen residents closely knows how this field & people in this field work.

Characterization matters to me & many others here & a great actor is one who makes you immerse yourself in the character, forget the actor, relate to it, click in the very first note. Many watch the show for content & characters & not actors and Sanjivani promised content & characters of that field. I can mention my first impressions in my review.

Characterisation matters to me and many others too, that's why none of new viewers even connect as such to the senior characters irrespective of who is playing it. Still we aren't trolling them and giving them time to make their own place.

Sid's act was an attempt to glorify malpractices of some doctors & it needs to be called out.

I didn't even justify his acts anywhere. I agree with you on this.

Creative liberties & immature drama should not trump the nuances of the field in a genre like this, something they did unabashedly. Why should Indian makers not make a world-class show & always be averaged down by arguments like it's an Indian TV show. Medical dramas have to maintain a standard to be revered & respected in all corners.

Trps will determine mostly as you are well aware. But I believe that you shouldn't forget above 90% of viewers are from non-medical background. So a compromise must be made in between. Otherwise in end doctors will connect to show, but for others it will end to be a documentary a bit. Besides they are trying. You can DM to the producer on IG for your views on this too.

Sanjivani isn't a clinic where all you have to do is consultation. It's a multi-speciality hospital premise where residents practice almost all the cases for the whole day. Open hair for female doctors & nurses is a strict No in hospital premises during professional hours, unless you hail from management or legal dept who are mostly restricted to their office chambers. Even male doctors have reasonable restrictions on the beard they can keep. Hospitals have strict rules forbidding any sort of hand jwellery. Look closely, they avoid wearing their wedding rings as well during work hours. Even long nails & nailpaints are strict No. Even the jwellery they wear should be minimal- earings & what not. A male doctor in his shirt half opened during his working hours isn't normal from any angle, neither is doctors shouting in the middle of the hall or corridor. These are basic, fundamental rules of the field. Visit Fortis, Medanta or any other high profile hospital, these rules are followed everywhere, even in India. A show like this should upgrade & stick to these things instead of giving into glamor just for the sake of it. And no, it wouldn't turn a documentary just because they focus on these things, it will still remain a TV show like countless great medical dramas made all around the world where they pay attention to these things.

I mostly visit fortis. I understand they change when doing surgeries. Rest normal rounds or consultations is ok. Again I'm speaking from what i observe only. Anyway its been just 2 episodes to make a good review before completely discrediting them.