Ep 174 - 26-JUL-2019 - Pyar Ke Rang

inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#1

It took me time to think and write about this episode because there was lots going on under the surface of all the lighthearted moments we saw, but here goes.

In the opening scene HS fell asleep on the couch. Did he sleep upstairs all night? If so, what progress in their relationship! Poor guy sleeps cramped up on that khatya downstairs and now on the couch, but one day he will have to do renovations in the house before he marries Babita. I do see her sending him off to sleep on that couch when she's angry with her husband.

Pyar ka Rang

We got a really lovely scene, in fact one of the most beautiful scenes of this show, when Minnie watched the colors from the crumpled sheet of paper slowly flow into the water in the jug. This reminded me of my childhood art project. I don't know if it was CG or not but just the way it was used to visualize all the colors of love was endearing. There was also another message for viewers when Minnie woke up to find the water had turned black. Life is full of colors and shades, each flowing in a different way, but if you let them all settle and mix, they become murky as they lose their individuality. Each form of love has its own place, its own beauty.

Minnie had thought all her life that she knew her mother very well, but now she has opened up to the possibility that there are facets of her mother she knows nothing about and wants to understand if there is scope for pyar ka rang.

All Yours

HS is a smart man, he already knows that sorry doesn't work every time and as always Lala shielded him from some of the blow. I loved how he laughingly tried to lighten the situation and after Babita went upstairs, the imagery he created of HS stepping on the 'bechaari' kulhaadi was spot on. I really love their dynamics and the actor playing Lala is wonderful. Wish I could find out more about him.

HS' face was so innocent but so honest as he said "sab kuch aap hi ka hi to hai". It was a slip of tongue but he didn't shy from it. If Lala hadn't been there he might have stayed in that moment a bit longer, but still he did not hesitate to tell her that she had the right to scold him. Just like that, he gave her back the right to invade his private space after having rudely asked her to leave him alone the other night. I loved how his voice softened while he said to Babita:

Haq hai aapka, manne bolne ka, samjhaane ka, daantne ka.

(By the way, I am trying to remember if he wore that kurta before, but he looked extra handsome!)

So Babita was telling him off like a thanedaarni and an outsider wouldn't even know that she wasn't his wife. She did have a point, though. This was not the first time they'd argued about his drinking. It was not just about saying sorry, it was about correcting a bad habit. No matter how many times they have these apology-forgiveness sequences, until he himself decides to stop drinking (or at least stop getting drunk), this will continue to happen. There might be a day when he will swear off it for her, but the deep-seated pain that he still holds close to his heart needs to come out first and be healed. I think when Babita really is head over heels in love and starts to pay closer attention to him, a lot of his issues will finally be discussed between them.

Pearls of Wisdom

I know some viewers are annoyed with the senior Khuranas still being around, but I think the CVs kept them around to provide another perspective on society and how some things change with time while others remain the same. Minnie could have never imagined that her grandparents would have such a beautiful romance to talk about. The flavors and colors are different but it's important for her to continue to see that marriage and love can be beautiful and successful too, as in the case of her grandparents, who are the parents of her own useless father. I actually enjoyed listening to their anecdote and Beeji blushing was very cute.

Naeem Bi continued to tease Babita, but it was hilarious when Madhu continued into a zone that Babita was supposedly clueless about. She is faaaaar off from that point where she thinks about intimacy of that kind with HS and I don't think she wants to go there just yet. I am glad Naeem Bi continues to nudge her to open her mind but to Babita, they are "just friends". Anyway, she was disturbed enough to tell Minnie off, and yes she sounded like a mom warning her child to avoid the wrath of her father.

It was just an excuse anyway, as I don't think HS would scold Minnie if he saw her sitting in that mess. Rather, he would be a child once again and join in. In fact, I am hoping she still hasn't cleaned up by the time he comes home so that he sees them both (or at least Minnie) making the pots and then uses that idea to appease Babita later on. Minnie said that their plan A was dependent on Hanuman Uncle, so let's see how that plays out.

Work-life Balance

Babita's chat with Bill reminded her of the simple truth in her life: that her daughter's happiness was above all her work. I think this is part of Babita's growth process to learn to balance her work commitments and her issues with others, versus the needs of her daughter, who sometimes just wants to hang out and do fun stuff with her mother like most kids do. After all the upheavals in their lives they deserve to spend some simple moments of joy together.

Truly, Madly, Deeply

I think this time it's important for Babita to fall truly, madly, deeply in love with HS before she decides to marry him, rather than be rushed into it just because everyone thinks it's a good idea and because she thinks he's a good candidate as a friend and life partner. I don't think he'd have it any other way either. She's still a reserved person so I don't know if it will be the shy kind of love or if she will be madly, visibly in love and express her emotions openly. In either case, I'm in no hurry as I know her journey would be lovely to see.

I do have another concern, though. Love is not enough for them in the long run. There needs to be understanding and true sharing between them. Until recently, Babita has been focused mainly on her problems and needs, while showing caring towards HS in small things. She has never gone far into his private space and looked deep into his heart, except for that one instance when she dictated the love letter to Imarti. Even then, it was her impression of the situation and not something HS had voiced.

Till now, he has been the guide, mentor, and agony aunt to Babita. He has seen her in the worst and best of situations and knows how to deal with her. However, he has never really shared his problems with her the way he does with Naeem Bi or Lala. She is not his confidante yet. Far from it, in fact. With Minnie he does open up to a certain extent but only when it's in relation to her. Besides, she's too young to be burdened with the problems of grownups.

I think what I'm trying to say is, HS is much further into his journey to be fit as her life partner, while she has not even begun it yet. For this relationship to work and be successful long-term she needs to be his equal in that department, i.e. she also needs to be the emotional support in his life who will stand by him through thick and thin.

I don't know if HS will go through some hardship in future where he will have a tough time coping with a situation. By that I mean something unrelated to mother-daughter (not that they haven't put him through their version of hell a few times already). It's in those moments that Babita would need to step up. I think she might end up learning more about him by speaking to Naeem Bi and Lala because I don't see him just suddenly opening up about sensitive issues and past memories. I don't think she has any idea of the tragedy he has seen, how it turned him into the man he is, how it racks his soul even today. He treats her as a co-parent, but she's not quite there yet. If she knew of the circumstances of his loss it would definitely touch something deep in her heart and give her that extra push to become his in every sense.

This wonderful man has experienced far greater pain than he lets on and beyond what she has experienced. He is still hurting on many fronts and I don't think he will heal so easily. Yes, he's a tough cop on the outside but part of that is also his way of bottling up his emotions. Babita is still on her journey to become fully strong and when she is ready, she will be able to look around and see that HS needs that emotional support and someone loyal to stand by him while he heals. Or maybe she will become tougher as she learns to be strong for the person who helped her daughter and her come this far. HS is no saint - he has been giving and giving and giving. He is bound to snap one day and on that day I wish to see Babita right beside Lala and Naeem Bi to catch him before he falls.

Speaking of which, I have been thinking that it's been almost a year since they moved into his house. Would Imarti's death anniversary come up? Would he honor her and their child's memory and be a total mess on that day?

Procrastinating going home

I am once again wondering if something will happen to Lala because of the way they talked about tera ghar mera ghar, and HS feeling hurt when Lala said his house was too small for him. This was a wonderful scene - he didn't forget his friend or their bond and the easy camaraderie they share is almost medicinal when he tries to deal with mother-daughter tantrums.

I also liked that HS decided to face the music after all, not knowing how long Babita would stay angry, so not wanting to go into self-imposed exile. He respects women but he does not need to or want to be afraid of them, so he will deal with whatever comes his way.

Some of my favorite dialogues:

HS: Yo hai mhara pushtaini ghar. Kal ko pata laga bhai mother-daughter dono ne kar liya qabza. Mera to ghar nikaala ho gaya.

LM: Dil pe to qabza ho rakha hai, haveli peh bhi qabza ho jaane do!

HS: Apna ghar apna hota hai, aur main mere ghar jaane se kyon daroon bhai?

He wanted to go home and remind them who's boss - who's the kirayedaar and who's the makaan malik. Let's see if his determination remains this way because he has two lionesses paying rent to live in his house. If they are still making pots when he enters his home, I bet he will melt right away.

I also love the way HS sometimes slips into a Punjabi accent in the middle of his standard Haryanvi one, like he did when imitating Lala saying "Babita penji". It reminds us that he's a Haryanvi cop born and brought up in Punjab, who understands the ways of Punjabi society but still retains his Haryanvi identity.

Pre-cap

A lot has been said about this. I don't want to read too much into it but I still feel it's premature. If the pottery scene is to show them bonding and for him to cutely apologize, I understand. I guess they are taking it in a different direction to trigger Babita's introspection regarding HS, especially in terms of how she feels when he touches her or is in close proximity without any specific need or obligation. It's to awaken her feelings of desire as a woman and to appreciate her own self, to see her own self the way HS does.

Edited by inlieu - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

2.3k

Users

6

Likes

39

Frequent Posters

cynicalities thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2

Reading your episode analyses is just as beautiful as watching the episodes themselves! They're always perfect and eloquent and so, so beautiful! ❤️

As for your concern that HS and Babita are not on the same page with respect to their relationship, I completely agree. HS has been with Babita through what was possibly the most traumatic phase of her life. He has seen her, helped her be stronger and more confident than she was before. But Babita knows very little of Hanuman's own struggles and sorrows. She barely knows anything about the people and the situations that have made Hanuman Singh the person he is now. For a relationship, Babita still has a long way to go.

inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Manasi_MD

Reading your episode analyses is just as beautiful as watching the episodes themselves! They're always perfect and eloquent and so, so beautiful! ❤️

As for your concern that HS and Babita are not on the same page with respect to their relationship, I completely agree. HS has been with Babita through what was possibly the most traumatic phase of her life. He has seen her, helped her be stronger and more confident than she was before. But Babita knows very little of Hanuman's own struggles and sorrows. She barely knows anything about the people and the situations that have made Hanuman Singh the person he is now. For a relationship, Babita still has a long way to go.

Aww thank you, dear! You are too kind and give me too much credit. 🤗

I'm glad it was worth the read. As I keep saying, the material I have to work with is so rich and creative that writing about it is not hard at all.

@bold I have a feeling this may be what the CVs meant when they said this was only the beginning of the next phase in the lives of the Patiala Babes. Until a few weeks ago, I would wonder if they started to flesh out HS' character arc seeing his popularity, but now I know it was always written that way. They have very subtle ways of connecting present events to those in the past so that things always come full circle. The writer is a genius, a master at her craft.

Edited by inlieu - 6 years ago
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Was waiting for your take on episode , it was worth the wait 😊, loved your description of each scene and beautiful interpretation of them.. Yes I also agree Babita has to go a long way in understanding HS.. she has made little steps though already..in holi scene when she puts tikka on HS saying he wants to see strength of Imarti in every woman just gave glimpse of how she started acknowledging his immense love for his late wife.. her conversation with him when he says about Imarti complaining to him and how babita could see difference from love he had for his wife and what she could never receive in her life..and with understanding of that love only she could instruct letter to Imarti from him ..that was to bring out his pain which she got glimpse of in his voice the other day when she accepted Imarti's Diya from him.. from that woman who was not trusting this guy to him being her confidant ..to her being point where he cud release the pain cluttered inside.. her journey into love has already been going on... Her taking care of him.. her trusting him.. even with most precious person in her life..her Minnie.. she unknowingly has been going along in this journey of discovery of her feelings for this man..

Thank you for such detailed review , please keep them coming

inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: riti4u

Was waiting for your take on episode , it was worth the wait 😊, loved your description of each scene and beautiful interpretation of them.. Yes I also agree Babita has to go a long way in understanding HS.. she has made little steps though already..in holi scene when she puts tikka on HS saying he wants to see strength of Imarti in every woman just gave glimpse of how she started acknowledging his immense love for his late wife.. her conversation with him when he says about Imarti complaining to him and how babita could see difference from love he had for his wife and what she could never receive in her life..and with understanding of that love only she could instruct letter to Imarti from him ..that was to bring out his pain which she got glimpse of in his voice the other day when she accepted Imarti's Diya from him.. from that woman who was not trusting this guy to him being her confidant ..to her being point where he cud release the pain cluttered inside.. her journey into love has already been going on... Her taking care of him.. her trusting him.. even with most precious person in her life..her Minnie.. she unknowingly has been going along in this journey of discovery of her feelings for this man..

Thank you for such detailed review , please keep them coming

Thank you, dear! I am quite embarrassed to hear you were waiting but you give me too much credit.

I think a part of Babita will always be in awe of the great love Imarti and HS shared and how he is crazy about her to this day. I am curious if she will ever be jealous of it and maybe even insecure about her position in his life as his second wife. She has always been second, first in Ashok's life and then in HS' but I want HS to make her realize that she needn't compete for a place in HS' heart because she had made her own. Besides, his heart is big enough to love both women equally, but differently.

@bold, beautifully put. From hitting him on the head with a stick to striking him when practicing her self-defense moves, to surrendering to him stepping in when Minnie was rushed to the hospital. When you think back you see all the little steps and the clever writing. I love slow-burn stories anyway. 😃

Edited by inlieu - 6 years ago
tk2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

Firstly, reading your analysis is something I've come to look forward to as much as the show itself. Thanks for taking out the time and doing this (although the show is so good that I'm sure you love doing it too).

Secondly, I'm actually glad we and Babita hadn't known about HS losing his wife during child birth till now. She wasn't/isn't as in tune to his feelings, his struggle, his pain as he is to hers. I wanted Babita to accept HS as a father figure in Minnie's life before she got to know this aspect of HS and it's good that it happened before that. I wanted nothing to sway this decision of hers. We sometimes forget how difficult it can be for a parent to give responsibility of a child to someone who was a stranger to you a year back, or someone with no blood relation to them. This is because of how good a character HS actually is (and how well Mr. Dave plays him). It is a big step of trust, respect and understanding. She has wholeheartedly accepted "Minnie ke Hanuman uncle", now she just has to understand the man completely and accept him as hers.

Edited by tk2015 - 6 years ago
inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: tk2015

Firstly, reading your analysis is something I've come to look forward to as much as the show itself. Thanks for taking out the time and doing this (although the show is so good that I'm sure you love doing it too).

Secondly, I'm actually glad we and Babita hadn't known about HS losing his wife during child birth till now. She wasn't/isn't as in tune to his feelings, his struggle, his pain as he is to hers. I wanted Babita to accept HS as a father figure in Minnie's life before she got to know this aspect of HS and it's good that it happened before that. I wanted nothing to sway this decision of hers. We sometimes forget how difficult it can be for a parent to give responsibility of a child to someone who was a stranger to you a year back, or someone with no blood relation to them. This is because of how good a character HS actually is (and how well Mr. Dave plays him). It is a big step of trust, respect and understanding. She has wholeheartedly accepted "Minnie ke Hanuman uncle", now she just has to understand the man completely and accept him as hers.

Thank you for your kind words, dear.

Yes, I had always wondered how Imarti had died and why the cause was never discussed, but leaving it for that episode was a masterstroke. It was so poignant given what was going on in their lives, especially considering it came through Naeem Bi and not something HS himself talked about. I can imagine the loss of his child and the associated pain is buried very deep in his heart because he wants to leave it there. It's something that he wants to keep for himself for now because the thought of even letting his mind and heart wander back to it is daunting and impossible for him to deal with. Minnie fills a much bigger hole in his life than he could have ever imagined and this is why seeing her in pain hurts him so much more than anything to do with Babita.

@bold
A lot of single parents are worried about the impact of remarrying on their children. Would their new partner be the right fit? Would they accept each other? etc. so I am glad they got this box ticked in Babita's life before she moves on to the next step. Also, considering a lot of her anger towards Ashok stemmed from his lack of availability and support as the father of her child, she has had the fortune to see HS' involvement in every single aspect of her daughter's life.

How he brought her happiness and how he fought for it, how he was hurting when her precious daughter was hurting, and how he was there whenever she needed him... All of these facets have allowed Babita to see how HS would fit in if not as the father of her child but a new member of their previously two-strong family. She gave him the right to discipline her as a parent but I don't know if she's given any thought to him actually being Minnie's father. She is not privy to the conversations between Minnie and HS, so she is unaware that they have long since become father-daughter, titles notwithstanding. I am not sure if many people would agree with me, but I think that HS subconsciously became drawn to Babita too as the mother of his daughter first, and then his lady love. His child would always come first, and I don't think there's anything wrong with it.

I don't know if Babita will ever find out what happened the last few days, but one day she needs to realize that it is her journey to HS that needs to completed before they can become a family. He's got one arm tightly wrapped around his Veer Balika, the other outstretched towards the mother of his daughter. She has to listen to her heart and if it beats for HS, all she needs to do is to fold herself into his waiting embrace.

Edited by inlieu - 6 years ago
Saiyaa thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

very beautifully penned as always........👍🏼

inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kriya_12

very beautifully penned as always........👍🏼

Thank you, dear. 😃

Tennessean thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

Love your in depth analysis of the whole situation. I like how you have mentioned about how Babita needs to be his emotional support. I don't think Babita has ever asked him openly about his personal life. It is only when he starts talking about Imarti, then she gets a clue. I think she has to go deeper into the conversation with him. Also, HS talked about his mother to Mini so she doesn't have an idea what his mother had to go through. I agree with you that she needs to step up and would love to see Babita in that mode. Also, this should and would raise their comfort level with each other and we could have more conversations looking at each other in the eye.😉

Related Topics

Patiala Babes thumbnail

Posted by: Anj_01 · 3 years ago

Ok, dont ask me why but its holi and I wanted to post something but couldnt complete it on time. Its stupid so dont have high hopes. MiNeil OS...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".