Don't understand reasoning behind Kabir's clash now - Page 2

Originally posted by: LiveLifeHonest

Didn't PK indirectly snatch Pooja's home (by torching it) and make her and her family homeless when she was young? Today Pooja just settled the scores. If he truly understood the magnitude of his family's sins, he shouldn't be expecting shelter from Pooja at all and should just accept their current homeless state (when his family did the same to Pooja and her sister). As of now, Kabir has no basis to clash with Pooja. Yes, if these dialogues came out after Pooja tore his certificates and bothered his family, it makes sense. But as of now, Pooja is only balancing out the sins committed against her family.

omg seriosly before reading your this post i even wrote this thing that this dhamki would have made sense if tomorrow pooja torn his certificate but right now its makeing him look like hypocrite and selfish

seriously someone his thinking some sane beyond this fanwars

i am not saying pooja is not wrong but kabir is not a saint even

they way he think pooja should act like really man

itna hooda ho gaye padh likh ke itne bade ho gaye ho aur family ke liye shelter chahiye bheekh mein aur phir dhamki dete hon u even understood the pain of that 5 year old girl with a youn sister to take care off no u dont understand if you would have understood your family crime depth then right now u would not be talking like this

Originally posted by: SRKisLove

Yes I agree!

Kabir is right now thinking like a son/grandson. He is, like you said, downplaying the complicity of Dadaji, Suman and Chaachi, in the murder and defamation of Ashok Sharma.

Like you said again, and a really good phrase, "Pooja has only balanced the scales"

What I found a bit off was that Commissioner was suspended and put under inquiry for supporting/keeping quiet about PK, then why are Dadaji, Suman and Chaachi not taken into inquiry for the same crime.

All said and done, Pooja is still pretty much a grey lead, she didn't even actually kill PK, PK fell into the cliff in the tussle. She is not dark, that the show is trying to switch gears and show her as wrong (in the song sequence in the last part of the episode).

I think Kabir is protecting his family, but in that he is forgetting that though his siblings are innocent, senior Mittals are wrong. But I understand his pov, since it is difficult to accept the sins of your own family. Kabir accepted PK's but he was still devastated at his death.

Very nice post! This is exactly, what I've been wondering since morning.

I agree with your POV. Staying silent about a crime and abetting a crime are equally crimes. So the senior Mittals too should be arrested for this. And what punishment have they suffered for their crimes? The senior Mittals are really getting it off too easy. So Kabir expecting shelter from Pooja is even more ludicrous.

I hope they don't go the Maya way. Though Maya turned psychotic and was essentially a dark character towards the end, the sins, others like her mother, committed against her was ignored and no penance was served.

Originally posted by: adni143

omg seriosly before reading your this post i even wrote this thing that this dhamki would have made sense if tomorrow pooja torn his certificate but right now its makeing him look like hypocrite and selfish

seriously someone his thinking some sane beyond this fanwars

i am not saying pooja is not wrong but kabir is not a saint even

they way he think pooja should act like really man

itna hooda ho gaye padh likh ke itne bade ho gaye ho aur family ke liye shelter chahiye bheekh mein aur phir dhamki dete hon u even understood the pain of that 5 year old girl with a youn sister to take care off no u dont understand if you would have understood your family crime depth then right now u would not be talking like this

Exactly Kabir's thinking is wrong and looking at the episode today, felt he was totally whitewashed because the selfishness and hypocrisy in his speech was not fully pointed out and the writers attempted to make it seem as though Pooja was wrong.

Originally posted by: LiveLifeHonest

Exactly Kabir's thinking is wrong and looking at the episode today, felt he was totally whitewashed because the selfishness and hypocrisy in his speech was not fully pointed out and the writers attempted to make it seem as though Pooja was wrong.

exactly when i read post here i conclude only two thing either they are ph team trying to justify their writing and even trying to convince people or they are just blind fans and haters

I guess here nobody is supporting Kabir rather people are lending their sympathies only to Dhruv that too some extent... and mostly everyone is sympathizing with Jhanvi for what she went through... I guess the scenes are little rushed to show Tashan between Jabir... in this whole mess the writers are missing small logics that can actually make people understand each one POV

I didn't like the way everyone is just blaming Jhanvi for their status and not looking into their own self.... agreed that they might not want to defame supposedly dead PK but could atleast take responsibility of their own actions

Originally posted by: LiveLifeHonest

I agree with your POV. Staying silent about a crime and abetting a crime are equally crimes. So the senior Mittals too should be arrested for this. And what punishment have they suffered for their crimes? The senior Mittals are really getting it off too easy. So Kabir expecting shelter from Pooja is even more ludicrous.

I hope they don't go the Maya way. Though Maya turned psychotic and was essentially a dark character towards the end, the sins, others like her mother, committed against her was ignored and no penance was served.

OMG THIS!!

I was (and still am) so pissed that Maya's mother was left alive. I'm just like if they had to kill Maya, then at least she could've bumped off her mother before going.

If Maya became psychotic, it was also due to her mother (along with her father). That woman never did anything for her daughter, and then she tried to kill her daughter in prison, happily living those people who caused her daughter pain.

Ugh, till this date I'm angry, that Maya's mother didn't get any punishment.

I cannot whitewash every actions of Jhanvi . She is s grey FL. If i felt her actions wrong i will say that. I dont care what others think.

Didnt she broke Yabir . Didnt she broke Kabirs family (stepson and wife )

Wasnt Arush too a 5 year kid just lost his father . Why didnt she think whatever happened to me should not happen to another kid . If not kavyas ex in laws didnt came what would have happened to him.

Wasnt Kavya a widow who just lost her husband who was trying to built a new life for his son. (Lol i am a big shipper of Jhanbir and i have fought tooth and nail with yabir fans in this forum).

Didnt she used Dhruvs loves ,care and respect ,humiliated him infront of others and discarded him as a trash. He was kabirs brother.

Originally posted by: .SNOWWHITE.

I cannot whitewash every actions of Jhanvi . She is s grey FL. If i felt her actions wrong i will say that. I dont care what others think.

Didnt she broke Yabir . Didnt she broke Kabirs family (stepson and wife )

Wasnt Arush too a 5 year kid just lost his father . Why didnt she think whatever happened to me should not happen to another kid . If not kavyas ex in laws didnt came what would have happened to him.

Wasnt Kavya a widow who just lost her husband who was trying to built a new life for his son. (Lol i am a big shipper of Jhanbir and i have fought tooth and nail with yabir fans in this forum).

Didnt she used Dhruvs loves ,care and respect ,humiliated him infront of others and discarded him as a trash. He was kabirs brother.

Each and every point I agree..

Originally posted by: LiveLifeHonest

Didn't PK indirectly snatch Pooja's home (by torching it) and make her and her family homeless when she was young? Today Pooja just settled the scores. If he truly understood the magnitude of his family's sins, he shouldn't be expecting shelter from Pooja at all and should just accept their current homeless state (when his family did the same to Pooja and her sister). As of now, Kabir has no basis to clash with Pooja. Yes, if these dialogues came out after Pooja tore his certificates and bothered his family, it makes sense. But as of now, Pooja is only balancing out the sins committed against her family.

Originally posted by: .SNOWWHITE.

I cannot whitewash every actions of Jhanvi . She is s grey FL. If i felt her actions wrong i will say that. I dont care what others think.

Didnt she broke Yabir . Didnt she broke Kabirs family (stepson and wife )

Wasnt Arush too a 5 year kid just lost his father . Why didnt she think whatever happened to me should not happen to another kid . If not kavyas ex in laws didnt came what would have happened to him.

Wasnt Kavya a widow who just lost her husband who was trying to built a new life for his son. (Lol i am a big shipper of Jhanbir and i have fought tooth and nail with yabir fans in this forum).

Didnt she used Dhruvs loves ,care and respect ,humiliated him infront of others and discarded him as a trash. He was kabirs brother.

But the post was not about Jahnvi v/s Kavya/Aarush. If they had shown scenes of Jahnvi suffering juxtaposed with Kavya/Aarush then it would have made sense.

The post maker was talking about Pooja vis a vis Senior Mittals. As regards Mittal family, Pooja's actions are right. Whatever she said about Mittals being guilty was right. If Kabir had come here to avenge Dhruv, then that's a different story. But Kabir was absolving his mother, grandpa and chaachi, who were clearly wrong.