Should the OG creators of a song do the remakes?

My qs is since the makers of a film have to make remakes of songs, should they get the recreations done by the original music composers?

Since a song is a composer's baby, they can give it the best possible treatment with the new technology.

Example: I really liked the two songs remade for Judwaa, they still had the essence of the original, and I think Anu Malik was involved creatively for the remake..so obviously the finished product would be good. Other than that I just enjoyed two remakes- Aankh Maarey and Laila Main Laila...the other songs were mainly butchered and sounded like an EDM-Bollywood-too many-beats mess 😆

So what do u guys think?